Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Reflexiones ético-estéticas
| Autor | Amador García-Carrasco |
| Cargo del Autor | Doctor en derecho. Académico correspondiente de la RAJL. Escritor. Miembro de la AEAE |
| Páginas | 169-222 |
'2672,(96.,-867,&,$<',265()/(;,21(6
e7,&2(67e7,&$6
`S^_NaSN[bSSNNSP[_
Doctor en derecho. Académico correspondiente de la RAJL. Escritor. Miembro de la AEAE.
5HVXPHQ # ( 2 !
0'? $ '! )C5
%% ( 2! =$
'& &) !5$
(! 4 &" 2(0)} ((
%'1~)"%" 2
!"# $'1)B1(&"3
'2%# * )
3DODEUDVFODYHB" 2"'"&" "2"&"0"
*"(" ="1)
$EVWUDFW* # ' 2# #0'?(~
6?**# (') *%% # *
!?*#4**6 *' #*)
* *#*%! 4 "
' % 2 a)} (*46 %?(#6 %~)
*" * #"#! % 2(" %!#?
*)B( *" #?(*!#** ! %)
.H\ZRUGV'" 2"#"*" "2"*"a"6"6"
*"()
k0'?'
!""2 !% } %~
!1)' ( kK
1)0'?k12$ %5 k&%"
%5 # 1" %5 ()F tk
' 878H"+=
"( *2/" %' !*
'$3 )
Amador García-Carrasco
8-.
B E' " %
}(~" '! 2)
"($*#3+,.8H/)
. 0'?"$
%5 "( '%"
( (#%) '*
1" k 3% (
2 421 )0'?
% 'm %"0? "' "*?
)1"*"% '" %)C
' "$ "$ " (
"(*) % )
*!" 2 ( "
(' "(#" % %
'')& %'" 2"$'' (
% )0'?
#="1 = #1)"*
" '"s & $ %
! " =( ! 2
1="# %'
$!# &)!('"
)12 " (#13 " "
"! )! !2! !
"(0'? $(2' )% !
"1$ " ) "$=
! " ) 31$!3
!& ')31 2"(0'?
"($ # 312%"!
!"!=)M="*1"(!& !
! ' ') "
) "$"" !}* D='~
2 '2"( k3# %
2(! %%) t( t( ! "
( )
&M=)0'? % }* ~)C
&% )q2%r"2"#""$
)C % &"$ 3
)
% " #'}~) '1" &
$ *!1#="( $$
'"(1=1K 1 "
8-8
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
1"1 %%}~" 2( %
)%1 }(~" ()C
!# 1'k# }!% ~"3
#=$}% * ~"$"10~
k" #) =}>(# ~"$
1 "( ! }
~)}B!~ *!
$ '"$ %(
4 ) weltanschaung* "
* !"("&"
# "%$=)C' "
' 2(& "
$&(0 !' ( )
#% 4? ""2)
"!"%5 %"(*"
% # !2!)$%
& 2"(= &"
%"44" " )0'?
% '%"!(! )* (
2 "$&(!"
" " "* 4
(# ) * %"
( $1"$ '!$ (
! )% $"$ =(
"' k "
2" B(* "}~" 4%?'" }
* ?='~) (#$%=
$)$ " (# "
$!'""=()
1 #1v!$'
*=v! "*
$! % " 2!1!)
0 $*($)"
!""* 0'?! "(
% ')
% !" }*
D='~"%" $ # $} (%~"
k (k %* "#"
( "' }* ~$0'?'
"0(2) K 0(
"( !% $
)0" "!"&"%
" 2 "('=" $
'$ *)0'? ' %$$
Amador García-Carrasco
8-,
! % "$% *=){& *!1
tk % ) } (
%~"? ?'4 $*! 2=%"
"'%) "!1
%( &% "$%'&* (' )
!0'?# '
* ) }2%~"2"! ("'
1 * "*1
" %"# "}#= ~$20$
' ) " * %! * K
*""$ !)}{"~)0'?
)B% *$ 2 "
$% ' )2%"2%
'"$# (!2') }0 ~0
'?24""2"% 4" ! *1
1 2Kq}! #
%' ~"'* %' '
$ ($ #)y!$*(
*1% ( #! ! ""
4 = "$ ! "
'% =$'% ' #!zr)
" " )
"% *("$ *
* "( %$
4% "t2"
!"$!2 $ "*(* "
&""' )}~ ! "(
0 $1 %) %
$ % ) 1'% ="
*( % " ' =)2%
' tk )F 1 !
0'?% !&K}0 k"~"
2" !' "
D='"$ !?'" $ a $*!"
)1"# "$&0(
"#
*"$ ' 2("
#1"$ ((1"( 1 !)
} '~)'') 1 *(#
% '"0'? " "''%| =(
k ) 'n" 4% )
C " ' $***(
" % ="$ 4 0"
! 1* ) !"! "!
8-:
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
#" $!' $"
&"3 #(!)!='"'
!="1C)F )C13K '!m
$ #( !)&
* !) '3k
= % "(K}{ $3
!~!%"~&(~!~) }0 ~"
2"0'?!%v$ ! 5
1}* D='~"$*
v(Kqu0!%"!)***
((!u1* % $*
'*($ !%1)*1 *!
$ ( (m #( "
' !%($ *" $
* u %$ !2 " $*
) ' &* !*! "(
1" $*!1 ! &(4*!1%
$"%5 "*! 2 )%
!%$** ("1 5
%"3 "
* 14(*$1 *!)"5)y{&1$1
*!!%z
u(%! !%)Ck &
'=$"% 'u2& $ 1
! 3 )C*$1$!
4 $()C $1# m
!K*!1#(" $21 *!
% )2% u(&*!k
$ (! " $*!1! *uC
*&" " # m 2k &
K'(1*!!!%"($("
$# !"*! ' "
2 *("" $" 4"$
*$1& %'u0%$1
m2 'm'$%'
!(!1" "1 ""'(! (
* "($*% )
1$!%u #1'#( '
* ( "*! =1) '"
%# K!% $m
"!"52$!% !
"'& !% " $ $)
*! r)12 4 =&
& 20D=')% "
Amador García-Carrasco
8-;
! % ' !%"4"
) } ~" ! "1
"0'?4 *??="
)=2 # 8HH82' *"'=$
*!1'!( !# '2)
*!1" m=*" *"
%1 }51~)*0'?
! *" ! " ""
0(2"$ &)" $
"n!}="*"0~"$5 "% "
= "!=( %1"' "
* ( )C$1!' D?%"$ }B
'~"+),l/"'K} !#&"
$&% 4 ~)&0'?1
4 " # 44)%"}
%~"!="( * *1) =
%1 K} " $ $
~" } # ~)C 5**("% $0
}#(= ~" $M F)0'?
)0'( !*!" %)#1
*!$ " 0'?)
" !%|"'
#} ~"$ $"* =
"# }
( "= ( '
'2u~)C%(" $ %3%)
C"!"*3)' $#
! # (2)}~ "
( " #1"$ 2 u&*(*(1" "%5
1)
$1*( }4 ~ 4
"** $' " '((
"!& 4v$!%
%1v$B%X %t2 "
k " 0$ *!$*v''
%1 > v($* ) *!"
qM ~! "=*(n"$
( !& ) ?
},..8~" ' 1"$% )C
!"! %$!
=!K}~" 0" 0)
" = $! "
"($ #"'&&(= " *"
! #= "
# )C " % "# "(
8-I
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
(2#!'** "2)
% 0'?" )>*$ ! %1"
$ % %"k} ~"(
*1 "! (" ? ?'( "
?'(' % =""2 "
20'?" 2"#"
k3 " 2 ( " %
! )1 "
2"t2 2$# "$'
'1 !! $% $&!='
* )C1"' "k3"$ $!!
t &! 1 *" * )C
*1$k" (#*!) '0'?
t2'' " * !(!$ *
"2"!2)C1"0"$
0 ' "$
2" ()!%""
4!"}( " ~" = $0
2"1%) 2'" *
(" *!! "*( )0
%)4#1 !$ "!$'
)C !$*( $ ()
0'?$!! = *!m
)! " '1
% $ ) ' "(**"
!)C*"}&$2~"$!2Bk )C
% 5 '"% =Kq $!
!2"!2(("!" 2(
" ( '" *(#
$ " &(' r)!'
$k ( #( * ** 2
* " =) %5 }1
~ 2 =) k )F$ *
' 0'?!!!1"
} " 2' ~)
} % ~ '! }(~)0'?$ *!
%"(( )C
" }~!# '#" (%
K}x$&'% = $***~)
4%"$% * ""2"! "
)"k " 1 "&" " !
)y0 2zy k"'&("
" ' z $}'
0 $2~" *!"
(" 2)$ "0"%"
Amador García-Carrasco
8-G
2) !2) #1"$1>"
$$= %#
()>*$' 0'? %)1m 2
%"& %& ) #
*="}tk !$~" *! $
2' % =2' ' "
%(1( )
' "'"" "
$"( tk " $
$= "% *#1)$
*** "($*' 3 $*% "
mutatis mutandis)" 4
"" 0"(%)q{ %
= "$ 4 )' $
& r" }* u~)C
>*"8-(",,"
"$ '1 (#!
# ' "$0'?"("='"'=
4% 1 & )'=k
2$> * ( }! ~"
#''tk' ' " 0'?"
$ )2& * #$ !
K}#"%1 ""
* ~)}B!~"
1 "&2(* )B
} # ~ !%)0'?# =$ (4!)
C $&" #")$
$ '" $ 4$"D" !=)
C $ ! =
)"" %"!"1"
k$( *1"% !$ $
%}' ( ~)#' * )#(4"*
($ ' % "%0'?)
$% ""(" ($&
" " ="0u='"
"2u
'=> (B*'=$ }B!~
#(!" } ~} % " %
=)(*!#= ~)0'? !1
' m 1 %"1"& =)
*&! $ #
) "
* "( %' )%' }(~(
%1%% =
8--
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
}% *!~%)C #" "
"' ) %1"4#" $
} ~"+)F/"} 5$ 4#
''2u~
$ ' "$ # ) !'
% 4$ !4K} "
'~)C$ ' 2 1
! "(" 0'?" (k% %)
'"
) " " 3! =" *
)x' "*?M >(
""2" ' }1 ~"
%"k $0'? )xC*
3&>% D#?" }B#~1
#% }B!~K
}u*'$ ' u!
$( )B % "
( !$ " 4 (!~)
>*$0'? !1 ' "$(%
$ %"( } #%~ )
4 &$ $k
!"=' ($&
1 }~("'&% 0'?"'1
}~}* ~=( '= (
(B)1!
)&' 1 '"( !
2' ('2"( #$k*$!
1" 'M%K}%%
" !$)))~)! )
F' ( k"$' )
*($ #&' $ *3)
$ % "(% 4 ' !)
!%u
!"F ?"$ *!!$ %2($"
1%$$" )$"
$! " ! !
)
%= "
"$!!!" %% v
% 2" $! ( "
2v%$" $ !*"1
>"$ *!)1*!!
Amador García-Carrasco
8-H
} # ~"' "( $ *1}0
~"$1 2 ) !k"
% v=}
=~v )C # ( 2
"%$ '" $
'! )C5%% ( 2!
=$ '& &)
v$ !* K}y{&
%z %)( (!~v !5$
(! 4 &" 2(0)' }2%~"
}~" }> D='~( } (%~)0B'"
K} ((%'1~)
"%" 2 !"# $'
1)C '!" tk $*
}1 ~ ' ' }* D='~){=
v$ !% 'v *!)*!"
=" !%" ' 0" %' (*"
"($'' }* D='~K
v$!$0k)!"y'z
v1"!) $*! !)
v) $(" "($
*!! )*K %**! $2KSi
Dieu n’existait pas, il faudrait l’inventer)*!$* '
0)! $0k" $
01 '(#=*!)
" '" %($*% * *!r)
' 0) %1)'
} k ~ ')
0&! '4%v
(' $#"1= "
2 (' !!!v0'?
=% $ k" "
&" %"
'$*}%1! ~)
k #'" ' 6 )
$0'? ' 4"(!
) !%"1 2 "'B K
2 ""% "0!
)C' # ')'
()( " " =) }*
D='~'& "# ( ="
0'&" '=$***(# # 0K
8-7
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
q "% "*2"(=)
" "(0( 2
1$!r)
C!=%*K)))% %)))"'*
#)+C1%* D='K))) '
& ( %2 )))
wE
F(* & '"
!2'K}0'?' '&!=~"1=
} %~#Kq!=' r)C* 'D"
$%" & " K}'!="!=
')*( ~) " " %'
'"$"* " 0)'&
= (} ~$**!)
q '!!2# %1 !
"$% r)
% " ' K
!& }# %1~"')!
> )1 )
" )!=0'?
'" k % " ! )
" " K 4% "
! "'1% % 4'%k
$'% %')
"#%' " }D='~"
k" 5 uk )
0!2$ + a!"%1('"
F/K
q ' '0'? 5 *(2
( % '"!! 2"
(% (" "
( 5 1 =
% Kk ( "
"( 1 " *!" 4" #
$( )!$( '
#! 5 (% ! q1r"($
Amador García-Carrasco
8H.
'! $ = %
'Krimen y castigo+8HGG/"El idiota+8HG-/"Demonios+8H-,/(Los
hermanos Karamazov+8HH./r)
'k }4~'!"$ (! "
'$ #$ % "
k)C % K
$%0(2)0'?3
# &"("(' 1 %"$
} *~
"'' '')E'' ''#
'& "$ (0)! * "'&
2"$" '% %v"
0)C' m*14= !5$"
"'& )$0'?# (#=)
! }~) ' 1 *" * )
% $ # $
!'1 %#1"($ M!"k" 2$
" )
C 5K
q'% 4' '0'?*
! $'
(% '+Crimen y Castigo, El idiota, Los
hermanos Karamazov/"*!Memorias de subsuelo (
'%*!r)
()C* v(%& v %
!"$5 }0 ~)
}*!!~" " !(%#
* (=k% K
qumi delicia' 1 $ '!la conciencia demasiado lúcida
% " $ 1$*!1 =el fondo de la infamiam
$$era infame$ 1ur
% 4%1 #% ' !
0'?"""3 ( %
2' 5 #*! "$!r)
C K
" $ %# $
!% %" 2
$*) $' 1$
8H8
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
% ') *$)C $!
(k "! ! 2K$
"v2v" )
qu * # 'K %
" %!(
( )$1 " "'
*=*( ' r)
C$}%#& )2 1
k0'?" }%1~ 2)
' ' %'" %
* *"(% ! %)E
!"}1~"$0'? !$='
"E=( "= (%*)
' "$ "$}11k
~"#%(%"#
* k "
=$"? ?'"$ } (
%~)01$ " K
qu '* %*!Kordinarios
'"
( ' !(extraordinarios"
$$ q*1 ( # %
("**k r%5
k q *v$ *4v=
u!(5
$2 % 1k%r)
qu% &%1k
? ?'" !v 1 = $
! 4%' D='v%1
ur
'2=$m2"'
(" )0'? 11
k)C'= 2 #' % =
$ } ~ %}k ~)
0*1 $%) "? ?'
"2 )s***2 '2"!
* * )2)%
! "$%) #'1
k )4 24"(0'
%2& (" 2&)
Amador García-Carrasco
8H,
$ 22 2*!'%)
$ **K
C*$1a" #(# # "
4 2"$ 0'?" $1"
D'K
qC "('
)10* 'u0
){ ' =("0)
= ''" k*! '" '…”.
0 2" # "0(!)*! '
0'' ) * % 4"
* ! $ %)*=$!%"$
! ( )
qu*! "% # " !
%=$ %2ur
& %2"#% *!* &
'!" !"( *(%$&
* $ 4)C$*$!
)%$D'0)C$"%
k} ~K
“…$) ! = 0("
$1*!1) ' = D'ur
0 ( " ' ((
(1" ) ' $' (*
}* D='~ }%
$~ }~'"'1#=%
' " # $ t(! $
?' ) $'' 2"
} ~"$#1% )
$ !' = % %)'
# )1#= $ # 1#*"
* "(% 2 0"$2)
1= #% !
0'?""!! (
' (" M= )
qu %$* *(
1!24= 14r)
8H:
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
C$%* #=$ " *!
%%( # $*
! ) ' ( $! "(
0!k *! ' 0 )3!%
" )' * 3) "
% " "$''
(%% !)*! 1!"(!
=" "% )
' # %1" (2 }!%
~)M4 ! 2 = 1(
0)%)C'" 1
1(' " k
&)4#10'?" %$ 3$$
K *% " * '"
$ 0)M } ~Kq~
"#)))¡ ~!*
~ r)
'=0'?*!0 "($$')
}~ )= " ''( !=)
" #""' "$ ='
("$"'!"*( "0'?!
" ' % !)q 2
$" B*? ( "*!
percepción anticipada $ !r)C0'?
''0)
0$$ “belleza y visión divina”, $$q
1 'r" 1)C $
&= !& !4%1"$
*("*% )C # ( =K
q ' $ $
)2) ($ 3 (
!&m =m&)
q42 r(''*)))r
C 2" ("$
5 $$ 1)*"
'! " ' ' %&" '14)
C =4 }* D='~"
3 2# " $3*"
$* t2! (! ""!"% )
4 % )** )*1
"!! " 0)C1 =
$'='M F }'~" 1,..-($(
' # '$ *
Amador García-Carrasco
8H;
& " ( %" * 2#1
"k)
# 0'?("("
)C ' ' (*
1 #2 $
' )' ''$
$ *( !?'"(%1
)y0z*%"
* $ ) )y$& z!&
2K}B ~"! &"( '14
*%"% $#( )
} (%~ 2" # " "$B1
B% "$=%$ *')? ?'"$
)
qu ??"5"$ 1K'
2) 2 " u que no
pertenecía a la tierra sino al cielo. Sólo en el cielo se puede sufrir por los hombres
y llorar por ellos sin condenarlos... $y$& %
(zr)qF )C u u(*te redimo de todos tus pecados
porque tú amas muchor)
$4" '"* "
$ ? ?')
q " ! "%%)=*
(! 4 '*!!r)
Ck K " 2)Cu
+ ""877:/$0'?
"* !(!'!' "
5 =" !'1 "$
''"("$*!" $* "
*$ '? u
q 4 "2"
'" ( "
$ *!$#* !"r
# =$'"M F)C#
* ! 0"* $ "*("%
% %!(( & "
!> (M)F*+!"87G7/)
* " & " }* D
='~"1 % 0'? $!2
4Kk &&)F% ) '
% # )
8HI
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
In medias res" )F!88K} " #5~"' "
"4& DKq *= F% !
$**3 )))0$ ur
>( )' !$ " "
$B(}~ $}'~)C*?')
!' D ** "$*5
"("4 " %)y ' #
% 4%%& "(z
C1" 1% "} '?'~"$0'?
1"' !B
!(}2~Kq 1) $
*!!" *!1* 2r)C Kqx #1
"' "$ 0r) 0% (!)
!%"' '')x{& 1
*
% '?'"1F" '
' &"=Kq )))2
())) k )))
% 3 ('r)
"2 )( )E!' k
? ?' } (%~)
1F (5 ' ?')s"
# "$ ' )C) !=2"
$ )>($1 #"# "
!( "( "$0)02%
" $ %$1 "% $
)q' $1"0" 5$!$m
r)CKqr) (
#!=**5 (>m
$'($! "( 1" )
$&*! )' (?'!& )C "
* ""$ ($
%5 4%*="(' ")C
?'Kq 2" u "
(*r)F' Kq0 k"k'u '
r)
0!v 2*v 1! &
}> D='~) !' % &" "
0'?1!% k"$!'
=%" $4
%"$)0%$ $ =
!% 0'? "!& k
2"$" " (4)
! # "t2"( ' $1
Amador García-Carrasco
8HG
) 10'?
0? " ()! " *!"
* } ~(Kq ($$1"
( $'r)
0 ' )$"mutatis mutandis"*!!"
# &($ t
)' !& &# )C
")C%K
q%1* )C %'1rv$& 1
!vq * '#$'= !
) $ !k )
1k !" 0r
y' $=# z
q !& r)C$2)qy!zy$&
zB* (*# )Satana sum et nihil
humani a me alienum putor)xC%!2)
*!1!*!( #"'=!
' * *1 4 )}""~"2
K}1("%" ~)($!' )q
&" 0) !r)
y z0?1!"
%1 % )! =
4#1"$ ' &"= ! ()1
1v % v$ ='K' !
0)q#! 2 " 1 r)# ')
' }B!~" %
$# ')E"') "1
Te Deum !) ")
' % !k0)C% %"
% )
q0%$ & )
x51$ k
y{& *( z
u*'="
('u}2~ u
%)
u' " $u* (#
$ * *!
)
uB4#""4$(*
! u(("!"(5 $'(
! uC! F!4!'
8H-
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
! u(' ! uuy$&
1z$k %1 )
u5 $*($0 *!u
* 41u0ur)
') k %* K)
#=uB %"!" $!!
) 4'"( (
}~+F%/}" 14(!'~+=/"
} 4!~" !} ~"} ~"}!~"}~"
}* ~"}%~)))}*! '~! $0(
k " ' ~*!~(*%
u$2 ')
0 *(() %*)y$& 'z
"' $ !2 =&u$
! ) = # }~ "
& )% * $
?'**)C *#! ' )
1"$%# k "
' *! *" "' K}!**~"
0'?)?'# )qy{& z
* ' ()y$& z!u!&
!(r)# & K
q&r)0# )* ' K
q' 1 0"'' *!1 = "'1
!)x0' r
>( )}21 $!# ~)'
='!( )
&!"5 1%"0'?"
" %( 2' " '
!%('$ ! )
))"}1#~" = = Kq>!1
5!%$ !1 r) 2
B"* (( "*!1 &
)"0'?!! (4v(%# v
$ 2)C&
}~"!" "' * %"
3""! $ !%!:...
!u %}~ "~*
~"( = )B5 $
}22~)xC$& * 1
20*! "# " " "$"
3"2*!" 88)C = %%"
2')a%" 0"$
Amador García-Carrasco
8HH
*!12 B* ){ t
$ "(2$!'( !4"%
')xCB5 & * (%
"? Kqx !" F 1'
)x %3n~Bk *!
" ' ( = #" $
' $' !2 ) 1!8,"}2
&( ! ~"0'?*(
$" $0 !
&) 1F"} 1B~" '
" 4 2) !%"1 !2"($1
& %"$!'5
')C "1F" ' "
(# }y{& z~)'
2 5%!)
}F%~$=n"K}B%" *(
! $0~)%1! ' "
}~ %)!!! ) 2
!%=( ')
&)q1*' 2$*!1
'r)C #)
)F) # )$1%1k" 1% "
! (%)4$% !
')2 " "
)'( & '&
'(''%%) 4$1!
&'%! )0'?*#
} (%~"% 4$ *(
)! 2' )C % ">
$&' &) *?*( 2$
) 0'? ') *!
'## &)
'# k) "" "
&"$1! )q
#Kq¢"%"&1"$' %') $(
&! "$! )x{&# % 4}42
~"$$ '"2
" *"'
# (2)C#12 $"
'="( k= "'& "($
*)2 " 4$*! *
( k)" "% 1"%"
%( )
8H7
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
>( # '} *~' "4$ *(
*!*!) #%"B&K}
~)##"4" * #%
5 ( (
* ) "$"1*! "
%(% )C*4q{
% !1(
1'r) " % "4#!
!"(' #%!2"2$
*%)C'$1 } ~( }~"' (*"
* $3)C0' % "! ()
B'$1" #" *2%"$
(0'? = !)
D'*"4"* )F"$0'?} *"
#&" %'
!%=) ''
%2 %1)}qk! u~"q$
!*" =r) "
#uC )F"!?'"# %
*Kq*("32"$*
( $$2
* ur)q $& ' # $ "
("'" ' ur)qC
*"' 2u32 #
*( $ * u '
} ~!u ' u'*!
'! ! 2( r)4
!'$ 4 !0)C%
# '" '
"$ *" #!)
("!$0'? !4"
%%$*&}'''~% 0)
a0%" ' %2=)(!2'
!% )q!2r"1" * )
# " 1"0'?" 4)
B =1! K}
" $ ! ur"q =*=
!( &r) !
&) # " 5!%" $q
( & ' k!r)!!
$} 2""25 "}k'
% 4 ~"$2""B%*)E} * ~"$
} $ % 4 ~" !1} ~)'
Amador García-Carrasco
87.
$" '" *}~} ~"k'
#!0'?"$! #)
1 ' $ *!!"
)C % "v % *#
% !v$ *! )q3
2%' *!(!! r)
"$!!"'!" "
(!"$0'?*!1#
) %5 $$)q
' u (
$ 0urq3
2r)q ($
"(! $2=ur)
)" 4)% %!"$
!)C*( !&Kq34*!
*u"#
" "!="2u
ur)C%%Kq4"$!
*!"2 % K(M "$'
'2( % ) * r)> !
1"'0'? 5 ' #"
% 4 * '& )"*!
"Kq" &'*2r"! =
t)qB $r)#"
1 ""' %&""G"
*1$ # " 1"!
$!#)Ck1 )1
*k# %'5!"$
4%' ( 2 #" %!
2$1)% 0'?)#
}% 14~&Kq$* " " $*
k' 24= u( r)>
" 4 $# '
')C$*( 1" #"*
* )C%Kq ! ( 1r)
0 '0'?" !"& }%~"
%$' 1"*"($ %5 *
% 4 %"$ 1 %!(
%!)C% 2Kq ! % %
u uB'1 u
>&! !uC$ # % %(
% "% !& ur)
)C&$ $%&"
1&" "
878
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
=)q!
t % ' "! (2*!r)C
= =$$! 20'?" "("
$)q{!!' (m!'
1( % 1ur)
1F"}2 4~"4Kqa&
%*' %0urq<5"*$'"
$ 2r)CB"( ' 2Kq'
2=%) !1 0" %r)B!'
!'" " '&0)$!&
)C4 " %"0
!)qx
xD" r) $ *!1'"! "
" 1
$ **)$!k "(
# k1')
1%*( ' ( )*!& $
$0" # %(" % * "
$(* 2 )y %&$&z
0 % '"(%1)*""
Kq{1#)! "
% (!r)Ck 1$4 "2"24"
"! $ *Kqu$ #
"%*2=%uC '& *
u2= ur
*"("$0 ) !%"*
' )C$1'' K1 (
%()BKq( &1uC&
'k #r)qF$*! 2r)
4 '( )C "
*"$' 4 KqxE&"$"$
0r)
B %"(0'?! )D
Kq>' $"%1"$ u
r)C"' a* ?"(!
$*1 2 ) % $!% "($
% 14 " 3*)q '1
$4'ux{&4 !%&$
k qC$* r)C&
*" 10'?"# )0 Kq
u * % )x{& k3
% r)
Amador García-Carrasco
87,
* 3& Kqy$&*z
*( % = $)! (* (
urqx'x * ! (4
'q( '''"2*! #r)
C# 2 "% )%" )
}B!~"k3(
=* "1 "
) tk 1 1)C%$} ~$
= *! #"' %(
)0&u1 ="(**"} ~"> (BK
q % " % =ur)M " %""
}~" %)% " "
* qy{& %z %)( (
!r)
q*!% ! 2
" !%)*!" "
1r)$#ak$ 2q
#r)C! #"1$!
k )q ' #r)C
2Kq*! ' % = 2"
' 2)4
' % =r)"(*' "? ?')q*!
K $'$ !&! " %"
'"'' %"
!ur)q*! *' K''r)
$* 2%m1 ' )
>1 # "(4* '"
(" $*!!2% )
1}%~" " "
$ #= ! )$ F
*! 5$ 4#'"k
% 1) 1
%!M?}' 1~"&*!!)
0'?*$}*!%k
$ % 2" '' %~)+)F/)C
& '" &$ *
2)( $&* " $%)'=
'= )E$ $
$ }!(!~"!"$
% ( } 2 ~"%}%1(
%1~$(* )
}~0'? = #)B* }~"
* "5 # 1$ *$! "'=
$ ="(4 *4 }
87:
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
* D='~" 1 }2~' %)
1 1 "$" '% !"
&)C""2"$ *(
" ' =)>$1
' "$#% 1 # "(
!12 %') #"
" !%2 $ 2 )
B* } !=~"0'?k
'" ' 1)C$
2$ 1' "& $!
'" )B* % ' (
% v$&2$# %' v
' %&) 1 Kqr"$ "
%"!=)x{& $'
2 %"$ $ %
* " B%X %M $
2 *!" $ "B* "'$
)$ %)q3
%r"" a 1)C0'?'
'( )$
!K}!"1=u~)
1"4%1 ) 1 !
)B ! "* ) $*
1()*$ ! " (
"4% % )'( "$ %"$B*
) !)B* }~$*
5"(* "($*5 '""!
"'& '(! "$" '="4
'& "5 $'&*)C " "
%* "&Kr )0%
r)C( ' "1>
!)q % ( ur)C
)q % " % =r)E %"$
}B!~")"1 #()
')*2! "$ "
%1# $0'? % "($""
'' )q 4#(' r" )
" "% "( 1 "!!
!$' $ = )C* %5 }k
! "$~"B"8,)
1 *#=) 3)1%}
* D='~" $* 3*$
%(*! )!k $ !
)Ctk &3& 0'?Kq!=
Amador García-Carrasco
87;
%)Br)!= $("
*2 "' "% "$ $}
%~)2' "! "4 t }~"$
! ) $ t ="(
m1"q = *2r)y
'&4z')B %1"
'"*$$#
1)
!" 0'?" &( "
% !="1 ! % )
$* "'&& *
"( !"!" &)
% " B* " #!"$ %3!
%5 ! 4))}~ 3"
$*" (!2= $0'?
* )!=" "1 !( ){(
2$ # M" 8HG;K}£ u (
k u!~)
!!# }''~)
y'11%=" !Kqx''"
'' *! )zr)qF 1 ="*!
ur)0'?!& ' !)q%
( #r" #$)C
$*( % * !K'' 4 "
! !"$ )
wE
0'?'' " %
""? "> %6("> >" 1
( $1 "( '*("
&='""+)888/) " %)88;#
B%*Kq!$* "$'' "
# r"$! 1*!4
)s2)y&!#z (%"
*2 ) %Kq $#)
r)C? ?'Kq $##) !& r)
q *!!2 %r)2 * "
) ) "1"(
! #* )*! 2 (
" }B!~"$ ) $
'' $3 " 2 )B *
!$ 1K}* 2"
r)C $ *$% "
& " %# !)4 "$="
87I
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
')C% %%* (
) }* D='~"$'
= ()q( (
%1'')C *! u=)$
0((%u(%1!
%( !) (= !r)
0'?* "( 2
K} *"' #~)+ "8IK8;"(" "
>*"8.K:;"*" # ' /) %1 2$
}(*=$$~"$& ?
!k% 1)!$0'?
! !"$$ #
4 )q*(' "%
r k *
=)q* 1 %1!
'''" $ ur)
D='# # * )"
" #= ="$**2("0)' "
" ' "(k" "
! (%} ~ k
)$ Kq$1 % % =
(%&r) "0'?"2(! 4 "
("! ) #
% !"!%1)D='
=} k (% ~)1 B*? ""$
4 $v $ k"(=& v
}~ = ')C D=')2
&%0'?*'% $(1
4 '( 2 # "%$(%
=)2%)' ""!1%)C
" )F!8Kq>( $
!" $r) } (%~"1
Kq( 4 ' ) !r)
$= ' 4(#
4 }* D='~)q %
2)1* r) ? ?'K
q0KC*(0 ''r)q%5 M!"*!$
$$ *r)'
% )
0'? }!~# ' "
#"%( '
&) 0'?' % =''%%"' % =}
* ~$ 4 2' )C$#
t )D#?v}"
Amador García-Carrasco
87G
0'?(1#% %
BkM)
r)F% #Kq ' '% $
**' %" $% u
$ **r)3"}
* &~)? Kq*'$*( r)
!E* ?Kq0'?!1 '!'r)
M%Kq0'?!''=r)
a1B$=(>?B? )!?'!u 4 "
(%$ 2'"'%
$ ! 2 )
C* $ }B!~ 2
k "(! D?%" %
'0)=*1$ *"0('?*!1%
' "# %)0 $2 %
2}>(# ~)!# } (%~)
! }~"&"1 "$
!2 )E!("
!& " $" ' "
5 )0*1tk !&(2"
'0) }0 k1
~ k )k * )
#1 ' D=')C'
$"0 k* !(
) $
k "!!' )0'?
!5$ v &"44v
!"(' !"($'&
}2~(0)C1$! }2~ &
!2'&"0 )0 $! 2
)((0 2? ?'} (%~"'%
} ~"' D=' }* D='~)#
0'?" $ )C'
*}2~! ' %!#
)2" ' 0"
" #
3*" # &) > %6( }1
4~K} 0'?*!1 1!($ u%
$!! ~)* ! $$1
"'= #)E$=
2('= "$" }~
&"%} ~) !%"* K}
5$ '3"*~"$1
)> %6("((2 1k " }'
D 2~ *0'? *!$*
87-
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
% '" )C0'? #=
'" 2%"} 2 %
'(*(4 ~)B(4)C3"
%# ""'=#K}y
*!! (* # z~)E*
?$% "$0'? t( )>!
) $$ t( )
Ctk *! (2)}'
%!'(% $ !~) t "$
} ~ *1) )!
#( )>( *
"$1# "(%)
'0'? &$
%#(*$ }2%~""
' 1) "($'% '
! 2$ )'"( "
" % )")5
% )'3 !"( '
B10' ) 2* }>(# ~)
( )% " " '" & 1 (
(' 3 )0 } (%~"*'
}~"} ~("!" }2%~)C
" a%' "$ }2%~) "'
*2$(*2)0'?"( #=)
& 1#==!)'?'$}1
(! 0'?k
( 3
'u$!' # "'
'~)C3K}&= &~"4 $*
!?'1 }~)2=%
B= }t%~"( )!?'
5*! } #! ~"}
$~uC $! 2$0'?!"(" "
' #!)!& (!
( ' '1%)%
' !?' !""4& $
} (%~" (? ?'" !M!"q$
*! %5 '1 $ (2%)
*( '1 ' '%( ' )
!~)'((=% } ~
}'1 !~ !!?'"$ %!
( $" "} (%~)$
1(* 2 !)
5 k # }~)!?'$#
k1 % 2" (& )0
Amador García-Carrasco
87H
$}' !~)K2$! )
C"%"= % # #
& ' # k "}$ 21$ 2
% '" *&m '
'& k~)
0 "("$!?'}~" (
(K(#)2"0'?!!
'# * $ 2 )
2' ) $& $1 &2"#1"(
#1 ) '5 ' &(
'!& )' ' (# %
* "$2) " (=)
" $ (=)!& !#>!)
$!5$2"? ?'"$
$%)0'?"(* " %$
! '" 2"%" ")C
')!?'%}!~8H;G"
# n6%$ }2 *
~) 2)4 )F!,"}* D='~"
"" ' 2"K} ! !"
3 = " }! ~*ux{')))
y$&( zy! z" 2"
' '"' "
&%( % r)C%Kq "
!2$# "$ #
( )k !"' r)$1
'" " $%)
!"( ! " 4%n
" 2(" & "'
}%1! ~ %1k")qk*
! r"
M'" ( )! "
%1! ) (k* }!$~"
(% %}%% ~"$ )
1*( !$ }~& 2 )
% % }* D='~" } ~
* 3=)>(% (%
%"*( # (
)0'? " } 4~"
K}*$" %' 1"!
~)' " 3*)
0K}a !"% 1~"
$"(} (~)E}{ *
'"An die Freude*"}E%1~)}$*!
877
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
!( "*!
= %"~) #$=
!"!& = ='$""
% 14)*( 1 2 = !"
=* "% )0'?(0"
!* )BKq( *!"'(%"
!!5 0)% !" 2
*2"3"(( %1 1!u
%1 ) '
#=%& )$***!*!(*
' r)
C$1 =" '(*!$ 0"
% ="n!"*u
#&' "'k' %()C
Cv!='vKq!=% u$
4 !u( 4 !$0* %r)C$$
$!=0" !!) 2"D?%(
1" ( '" ("
%Kq= * != '% =u
0(!)= * !)+0)"
!,/) )F"0%*! *} ~K}(
" "" D='~)C*"} ~
Kq'u '=
"! r)*$2 * "(
0)C& )qxa '"0 (0r
}%*~k)%**)# 0"
%1#" 2)' "
1 " $ %)# $"
* ( )01* %$#*
!) "} ! 21~" $'%
%1)$1# " *"
$!3 "$ 0'?""*(*=)
q %u %' r)C$
!#"$' 2'"!2
}#~ "$'" #1)%u
* )}0 = '$(~)x}2
~$}#~ }#~%' &)
'10 *) v$&2v0*
$x % )C"* K
$0%2!( '*)
0" #"" !%")1&
0'? = ! $*! %)(
#) *(%"*!*( )*! )
)0! )C!"
Amador García-Carrasco
,..
''*"!Kqx$*' !! uB
&*3=r)"' %& !"
}!%&% *!~"* K}3" (% u~)
='14"3 $!(% 1
" $ *%)} *% ' ~) ! "
vkv"$ "% ' "!
v! v! *2(}% 1~=)C
!%"'* 1$}! ~)q
4 ( r)q 1rv ?'"
!!*2(&v%$=)q & %5 %)
$1 2r)C 5K}v vk%$
% !0( %!"= =
*" *! %5 r)$ "$ % !
= #"!& Kq0*!'&= r)2
0'?}= !~6"$$ "
($= =" $!&
! "$" "' ') #""
}12~ }$2% *
4 1 '~) = "
4 ')00'?1"!K}** *~)
C%KqC ( "%'0u$k%
2' "% % r)'
&"($& }'0~ $ uq
$ %0 ' % )B!
!)(} =~0$*k%
* $ ( r)>($1 }2=* ~"
$ #0( 4 !!"
$" #)C "
%1Kqy{& " * % *!
%z))) % "($
!'"%% ur)C$#=
1 'uC}%% ~ #2)
""$ 4 != k%)=
%1" #* )
5!!#" '?')q
$" #" $' % ( 3$
" 3! ' r)#"
# "' 3)! )C *
$ '#)$# #=!!)C5
"y! 3"
4 z0'? ! 2"$ }
~ ' '%)?'!' "$
"}!&~ (%" 4% 1
"$ )C' "% *2Kq
##'m % !! r)C%4Kq*!
,.8
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
'#*!1' 3$'%u*!
'#"1"*!1"'%) 3 !
'=( 1 u$ 1#r)
0""D?%" *" '?(!)
)F"%Kq*(0u &$ u( *(
*!$!= 2"$ %r)'
$!0) &%"0'?1
! )} 2~)q>!1$%1
)15 ''!&= )
1'r)0 = ! ( #
} ~" !" ' $(%)
B(% 4' ' "
?'"$*% &$!
# )%"* *! K %0(
")C" Kqx #( %1
$**!" % "*3
y{& ! zr)' "K
!)
{ k
&$*1# $ ' 0)*
# k '= )
Cu>(%B4# !)
#( )q>*!(*!3
$' (' $! )x%#
k C"$2 %" )
qF(% )F # %5 %r)
%$ *2)1
) " & !!"
" ' ' "$) } (%~"B#
% % !"$ )?
?'' $!$$$
) 2! 0'?)'
" "$!" $!)
)*( !!*(2)
y$$ *2=%2 (
$& !''($& z
y{& * z
)
y$&zy{&= *($ 1u
* z
Amador García-Carrasco
,.,
>%( K #1"!k
#(" % #= =
t "}'~utk 0'?'$4
=* "( 0(2)
0"!& v $ =vKq
1)= ) r)>*1 K
="0uC"$ " *%"$ =)
C *'' "0'?Kq
=( m1!2" "*!1% ( !
*!k'1r)
% 0uE
1 ' (*!12$$ )0}'~K
%! = q$k !* '!
&*!(%4"$*1u
*)%1$ !& ! 3
!ur)
#% )
q "* % F% r"
*)q3" "%%" $)
a1)B ! )5$" &
%1r)
0'? $) %1 K} 0
$ $ ~) }
~"$' " '" )
" ! vque tutta la vita onora"v ''
&%" !5# )0 ="*"
$ 1n!"(0'?" %'2''"'
% = ( ) 2% (
& )0 %('')% $
"$% v% " " v} '~ ')
% $* v ' n!"
*!v$1!+>%/
*!+=*/ 0)!" (
*'" & $ %
}~(}!=~" !"$ 0'?t("
* )0'?}~ 2" v
( %v&"1 "1"(
! v} '~#')
}*21~ 4v2vD='" "
%k"%1" " "0" "
" %(!"!("2$k!"2%
(u $$$%)! 2
' ( * % "a )0'?
&ad inversumK} 3 ~vdocendo discimusv(&
,.:
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
v v)C**!}~} *~"}'' ''~"
$ )C**1%" !
$$%1 > 3)
FwE
} )$ 2~)#0'?
)2 !" "(!$
'0'?) ) 5" #)
B1( )1" )E k)k*"("
$% ''"k3} #~
)
!;"*'"$ $)}'= '
4 *(" $ #(%~)( '"
u}0! %~K!*4 "
* 2) ()"0'?"q
&k~)C*!!Kq u
$u(!'r)
$10'?""*!1""$$ )
4 "
%)% $!1 *!"
%)0'? "'( 1
1)C'}(& "( #~)}'
$ ~) '!" 0'?"
$*($#)C* ' $2=%K
""u )% Kq'"
3"$ %"'$ $ %r)
$ k ? ?'" %
" Kqy % # $
1zr)C} 1~$ *= $0
)C% 2Kq '"#ur) "
)!F }'% ~2 %1' %)
1 v $ k 0% v "* "
""( $$ $" 'K
qC(2 ("((0% )F %** '
)y{&$1zC "$ $r"
a* ?(#)kKq{' '
! 2*4 1u #'u
1" $k" ' *!*!
)1 ( )>= 1$m
"'!r)( }~)$
#"$ 4%" $*% K
}! ' ~"K}4%! !
*2~)x{''"4#1"!"$#
')#"% )*} 1"
Amador García-Carrasco
,.;
)C 12 $ !~) =
$ (0'$(($ } ~$*(
}(~v 2& %v(1
} $* ~"*(& ()
0# ((2* (' "$ } 4
~0= "($"*!*"$
v(*2! "$
v)"$ *2*%" "* %5
("%}~K "$! ! 4)
% $%)!2(
" 21)
' = " )F ' '
4')F %%+re-ligare/$ 4ux
0"($" " 4)C
1K
&&0(' )
$* u&
" $ %#)
C$0*#=(0) $
'0' )>( #k%
0'?($* %4)C $'
* 2 4 )0'?
%v!> %6(!$
(*$*1 '
2v}2""2" ~"(' %"
! ( "
1"(= 2)% "} ~
( "'" ! )$! $
? %( (!11
"(( '
$!u !) )
%%*!$ (2=%
% "1'(0(2 (
20'?)s ="
# "$ )
$ #1# ' %1
($1 !% )
FwE
0'? ( ) ' %
'! ( )$ "
,.I
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
%"% ! $t2
*)C =v%$*(v} *'(*! ~"
(1$ )2
""B"}% '~)>
)F!;"$}!~) 1
*(} 2~"$ 3*"
* *! &"# 0)C*( $
*21!%(! '}*
2~) # ) *!!$
3v$ v (0*# )
% 2$3'"(!% )
"% # KqB*2 # # "
2"'r)q1 3! '3!
'"'& 2ur #
u !%"*('"(Kq !*
2 (''r)$ *(2" 0 }#2~)
C%% 2(' % =) 3"*"$
40*!# )C"%%5
4 * "'"$!K
B" " "*)
$ 3 K
" (*!u2&!& ! (
&Kq1" r)C% k"
* }! ~KqC'$*!!1 # u
*$ '%| =u)
' % ="$' " ')
=* "}!!~1)C 3$"$
' " !K
"y z(*&
u(' & %)
( %) 3%'
( =K
*u '1K0)'= %
)
"' %"$" "' % =2)
Amador García-Carrasco
,.G
k ! ' ' )
%*= ' ) 5 ")
!!)!& ? ?'"4 *=$
% !% !% "% ) "
* % $ )%"
k'K
x(' 2' )
0'?*( a'1Kk (
)$) 0'?#
$ K $"% "
") 2} ~('' "*$
$ ' " $& ! v2*(
1"}!2~&='" $ 2 ('' "
!%){2 k "
" ('') % %)
}'3~"% "% % " >"$
$( ( !}k ~" %#1
$!)
2 $ * (2) $ (*
*$*$ ! ' ' "($
" ! 2)q{&1*2' * r)' 2
$"% # )
1!F%) '
(k)>( $} % ~)'
"2 )q'%| = $' r)
' "#"#% "$*
5 )0 2}#~! **"}~)
yB! zv)
' $ ) &$
)
C# 1!' #=' (!D=')
*!0" }'~)&
$ *! **"n)0
"1( 2)> %3 0'?
0"% (* K} #=!!
)3" (1~)0 X'#= "
$ "2 )
} *! ~0'?}~ )E1v%v(
'$1)0'? '(} ~ %%
"% *' ) }~K *!!"
,.-
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
* ?v4%v$!*!!}~m
} '1" u
2~)xC ! 20'?
* "$ #(!" ( 3)>(%'
) !2( v"
% $& = ' 1 }>~v)C
}~$* ?" ! !"
} ~" ( !)xF
xC'%| =* ? *k 0'?
$)C !"$} "* ?
vv % ! $ 1~)
#'a 2$2 ( !)
% 1"$%a 2 2)C" "
21 & "#*!" ! (" !k
$&u'$}= **~(%!
* )C"*" '*"% )
"}*! ~ !$ !*"
k&)&# )F'
%D='" !I")"'$'
" # " }'=~"
$13!?')!& 1K
# $# "! % " ' 8H8,
$"!5)% 3"(
%# )
'= !&0 "!!1"
(}#~)y0z#(= = )
yzy
*2v4#1'v $"
>20 * )$1}* =~ 'K
*2 ) (8H-H*2
30'?*) (*2"
')B* " !" # 2 )
2 # ) 4#1$
( ' % )
#!} 5 ~"*! #}
~" % ) '$#
"4 "($ % $
)0$% $ #(!
' ) v$ =2"!k v
4 *%}% ~ 4
!2'){$ * )>
"$ '' *% !"
($"( ' #1"
#'* ) 0'?$%1
Amador García-Carrasco
,.H
} !~)%"1>%"'
*!)}v' v*(!"
!"4 '#')# ''
~)*"$%K' )4#
1$ =3(('"
v*( %1v$
"$ $ ' !2'" )
*(0'?% )}y$&*!'
% 1# z~)' $2'
*! " "}k )$
0*! u ' * u}CkK}}'
~"k 0" " & u
# ~)
)v0' "4#)C% %
!%# "k 0"$4#*1
!" $ 0 k" $!$k"
% 1'= )C% }
k0# ' ~"F)*!$ *
' 0) =*1$*)
$k1)$ 4" ) '
% # )C k&)
}!$01 '(#=
*!) u$** *!uC(*2
u0**!'&u~)
CK}k 0~)' ! !!
')}1"&$k( 0" *=
0" u ~) "$' *=
* "t20" )2
* &" !$
"!"$' 0)? ?'
K ' =!" $1%
' % )}~ }% ~"
!"$%*(')>F%"(
%>" } ' ~' (
$2 '>"2)*='
*= "% "' "
*!'}> '?~)'
" %)' $% !
1 ($& #) ""
# " " 3)0'? (
'= # 2"$$1# "
*2) ! (%"$
$' %) $!
* )C }?~"!#
,.7
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
)k3 ')C $"4 "
#=Kqx = "3m * ' r" "
'&3"4 " 2( ) 1
'% 3) % 4 )C
'' % =0 }~"$(*! 2
# )q %k 0"" "''
+ 2/1r)
$ $#" "(& $ $##$
!& )qy'' !1zr"%' )C%
!$4 24u& )
>$1 0'? "1
&( ="
#)'4 '}* D='~ *
k ' %$ 2 0)
}a $~" "' " k"$
' *($ 1!1}#~"
*$)0**" ")
1*=" % "} #B~"
"( 1$ $&m'=*=!
" ! $*
( )>( 12"( 5 0'?)q0
!r) !**!
#) $ )k}xF' ~ # F
$) "a $}%~
kK}$ u~)B& "
&(0$ 2"
(
" )} %~"'
$* 0) $* )C
k " !"'!!1"$
)0'% K>20
$'1"% * '
")*! %) $"'=
"*! '"( ' k $
#)}x0"!2=~)> 3v
%5 } ~v1 }3
~"a %v)* %"( ' "
'#!)*! '"$ }3~ )
>("2"" " 3 ="
2"}#?~"( % '
)*# ( ) )k%
3 $ " % " '"5
# =* "'y$& 2*!$$
$ ( % zC%K}u1)
$ 0u # $'
Amador García-Carrasco
,8.
$!*! !3!2
uu~)CK
)
1F 2%k%&
1 v}y!"?'' "
#1"$*!=1" (
# *1z~v( ' )0$"
" !$ 'v2 ' "
a* ?v(=)q' $'r)
t2 ?'(0"*2)qx&"!! "2
r)C =K"* u" u*
""!! )
}0% ' *! % ~
!k" '"% }%~"
n)>' 0 " &"$'
# (2 %#( =K} 3)s$
= ~)1"}!!1 # "#
$2& )n *
' * " (*" #"( #')}
$&u1 1~)}0 %''"
'1('~)$! %
"$' )Ck " Kq
! "(r)
(# " "il Poverello d’ AssisiK}2
0"%2" !& '*u
%0u2"!""ur) 1
=1)}C('! ''% ="
'!= %~) >( ('"
( $ '*)Cn
}' ~" ! "1!)q
'=! !' ) ' =
* % !u=(( 1$
=! %0r)'=" "
* "1)C 31K!
k) uyk10s! z "(
$ k(k "(14#)
}C*$1$!!*0uy>''%
3u)
&%('' ( !)
C(!&*K}3"3$)M !
3~) %"%25 "& )
0k )C0)x{&k %
,88
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
B%$ " % " 1"
"# *?)&$& )E$
( %" %%(
)M "0" }y4
* "! %1"*$
!"*$>%% }*1~"0 )
' 2 ! " ! &"($"%5 2"
*4#1 %)!"$ %!
$ !} ~)"$& "
}%~)4 (%
) %(2)'
$!*)y0 ( 'z
&#!$* %'" '
$ = )C 1 E>( 3)y
'( 'z5 $* =&$
$=) 2 (
!#(%1)q'' $"
(!'r)q*! ="'( r)
C* %1!!" ' %(
>*('" k)}$
0 !"(''){ !0'
" $ *(1~) )!(
#= ')F !"(2
B%> ="$= )! 2)
!% $'3% )E
**)B()0'? # !!
0} ~%$}# ~ !)' " K
} =%' v v(v ="
1v(#" "k*!~)y$*!
=z)*!"% )C
$ )M& )C# K
q'! ")>1*2F!(
%0r) =tk 1!
% "($ ' *" &
$ "(**"{2)2" 1"
*(3"$}!a!!~
!& 01 )qF($03r)
(! =*(( ("
!$C" 5 m}'$
* ~"F(K}''
* ~) # #"
(Kq!1 !
$ "(*(1$*1#=r)0'?
4" 1)q!0 ! ('r"
Amador García-Carrasco
,8,
k$}1~"B " 3 )%
%! 2""*(k "
t" =)C*(K"
!( !'%| =1)
nvn" v ''}
~"!}% ~"k "
% * "$ $ )x{& '
'"'"3}x "1(5
!0"$ 1~)*
) #=$***2 %" $
!u #=)
ux ' =
0'?t5" {2)0k "1"
$=%%"v*1# ")v 1
( %!$=)% & !K0
(
"q ' r"*(uqk%
'r"# 5 )
x{& 3"$1F%"($
(
'1&Kq'1' %
'% =2r)q%r)C"'"
$$ * %1 "
) #$ 2 0'?) $"
2" " ) K1&)C "&
! % '"% $1*"
*?"!" #!)$" '"
*?vM v!& *(k"% "
*"( !=m! !$)0'?!
"$' 2"( 2 0
&$**$ u 2 )y*(
zx1"( )}~
#' & "! "($
'!& #1"** $
# ( )'
" "! %* "
%1! ((
( $ )(
$0'? " # (%u*!
$!!)x{&C !
!# "'B "$ % ' %
"$ % ))0'?
&"*# ')q% ( &
*! ! (*ur)
,8:
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
!}** ~)
*"$ } ~ *
)%$5 * %($0'?42!2')
"#=Kq % >2
>!r) 2)%
=* ) *($ %"
M!K}F!0~)C=)C " "k )q
"$k)0*'){#r)C
! " # " # *
!"$')q* 0)B= !%=u>
!r)$0'?}!* ~
}!% ~" %v' $}%~"&
&$ }!~"$% !
}% %2~v 2' )02" 3!
*!"%% # $'
* ) ! 2m"
!k * "$2 )
q2( ='! (
0u( %%1r)C Kq!!
1( 4 kr)'1 "( }
%~"$ '"
Kq0'u!!$% 0(
! sr)q% '%u %1$= "
r)C3"** & ! 2
( 4(KqC* $ k r)
$" ?'"!"
"}~' "1* )C$' # 1
Kq *(0"ykzr)#
' % %'"( 0
}~ # D v$ "
* "% v*1}** ~$! "
4 '1 }% ** ~)(
)$ ' 0'?$
' * ("
'"1"! v %vn "
"% k4*)
% &$ 2! (
%)
2 } ~*"%(*(K}{
% = 2v%vv
"3v %v"(
k( v % %)
' "~) k
Amador García-Carrasco
,8;
*$u(% u(4 % )C 5
M!"$$0!1(+!)8;7/"q
"*!r) %1 2KqE(r)C
'!"GK8G87"$ 0'?)$&*!
' "" F2' %)' "$
5%$ (%)C%
# $ '(
%1"q0%1r"(" " $
% u~ $ ~)q1 (
$1" 1)4# $ !
ur) !" a% 5( %
+)F/K'" ( % !)$
! $ ' "( $
!1 ( )E *!'
!"$# F}% ~&
=! $ 4#"%"($
%%2" !"$ k
)#" '2q 2= u$
r)q *(
2="(( *!2 1u
2=# "! 1' $
%5 !
! 0'? " 2n"$
#1 $ %"0'? *("
4 ' ')q! =(
# r)* *("$vv
* !$!1*!**
! 2)4k1$'='v &va'
M }~ $0 k" $!$k)
% !%& 4 '&1"
}* D='~" (% = '
! ! }'k$~)$
#&Fn* *
"($!' $}*~) &
2}2~$ 2' 5kKq
*!2=%" 0r)* "
(" !%1! =* "!)
*$}# % ~*!)*! %"
2"$"2"*!1'"$ !
t )21 # %! "(1
!# =) 1%"
C'$ *$ #)B"K}C
! 0u$ '~) # $=
$*' "($ %$ !)C$"
" 2$ =}%~ !)
,8I
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
" *k'$% %
** )0
%" * ) 1
% !&"%$* '
"($*42Ka* ? " $
2#m "'$*4 "
%"%$Kq$& %r)
u( } ~* Kq
)>($r) !%"
= *!) 0'?
% ) 2 } ' (2~
$!)M! " "% " "* )1Kq
'=r"$a* ?)C
')* %"1 $
20'?*!"'="0" 1!2
($!)&){'%$ }!2'$~
} ~"' ){' $
" !* )C$" 1 "$
!2" %2!$
=* ) !)! ( )1
F!-1} a! ~)
%"' "%1( )$' %
'(!='!& "( &"%1)C
}' ~"}!~=)qBv*v!
''r)( !"'"%$'=*1'
" k } #$%1
% #~ 1! '#1)
0'?!* ) !F"B"
=! t )}3B~ #
& ){'"2)C}(~ )
! '" %"% }*~" ")
1" " "%$' " )
1!*(1 0>"
% = (' ! )B!& } %3~"
$ }! ~" $% " !
# }= *~*% )C! "
! "$!%2%
%( )C'%| =*!
)E4%! )"" '
0)Bk }t~k$&'
$v tk
}~v *) $ !''
v$ 2%" }!~$ 1
vD' ' ) $ ' % =
=) }2%~ }~& #"
Amador García-Carrasco
,8G
%' $ ' ) 2%% "2%
2%"(% '2%) # 1"%
4"$ $ $
2"" " 2$ ( "
') ="t2}! ~K! ( '"!
) B'' '!!
* "'2ka* ? $"$}
% %)F "!%"!(~)&
k&%$0'?"'& 2" }1%~
( 2)*"= 2
2'(( 1)
" (
%#}$"$~"(k #
3 ( # '% (# " *
$M v %v"$1
}= (% ~"*$ * 3
' " $ !1 !
# )B* '"k%(
3"% " * = (K
q{ $3 !!%"&!r)
B'!$ # }~)
''D)3D?'(&Kq(
)xMr)% 'r)0'?
'v %5 * v
0 ) )!H
# )C*!1( '
}~ 2(*2% "
!)( ) ! k
2)C$'0'?1'
*%"'"'="4=" 22
$ (k)C # "%>"
K}2 &"'"'~v$= !
> $ &v( } (%~"B! KqB
%"*k' r)"("! 0"
!& 1)y z
"} $ *!' !~)$1
"$"2 1"
)yEz$1)$*=! '
)0'?$1%(k%"(>Kq(
"(ux("!C?r)C3Kq'=(C?((
& r)& %*?)
(' !# )}% =~)
1F " =*
%( !)x$1((B%a* ?vx*1
,8-
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
'(v(*" *! (' 4 v
} ~v ( Kq >2
0 =#* 4 (! )
% $( 1 4 %5 ) "
32K} m!%% 3"1"2"
u)C1*$C''~)C 5Kq
0 r)' %)} *&
3" & ~)BKq "3"('"
r) 4 )0! (" * )
$*' " '* )0'?"
M%"*5(%1)01 $ a%%1)'=&
$*" 5 )2" !=
"2 $ % ' =)
*! # &" %2$} ~) $
!& 4%%)" )F" &% m
# &" " " % "
*=%! !4K}% $ # "¤
& ~)$&% '" )
B""# *' '0)
" ) $5 #! K
' (2%( )q3"$(2
21 )1!%=)5***%
(ur)a%"$ *%"($=" "*
)B"'" $ "$ =
="' (* $
' %1 )qB3 ' "*(!r)C
=k'$=' &0'?"%&
% " %0)q! ('=r)
(! ' %B)
F "$
" } (%~ '
" "( ' 2=
(%)0'?!& ) =F
"(1* K$ #a 1) (
!"}2~$=(*')'
}! ~$ 2 *(" % 1"
!' "($ ! ! } (%~)
"? ?'( 1"* '"$
k (32= %44"2
( ($ "
$" 0'?" %) 2
! "M=)
1 $*!k *
$$ '%)( %" $
Amador García-Carrasco
,8H
4 $ )
! '1"(&!$! (*"
3 ) !%" $
!) ! % # $
( ) ' "( "4 )
*Ba%" * (
$ % )B%$a%''"(? ?'"
"$0 '}* 2~2 )0Kqa"
3"% 14% #''")x>
* **= r) "
! ' "}'~0'?$*2%)$"
"B* %"1=!"!"%$
? ?'" % #! ) 0"(*
$* **u * **)1
' "}!~)}=~*$ "
$2(*= $ 2)k a* ?$
!=( 2 ) }F~"B*!* "
%a%)$ 3(=K
} *'~)0'? "
21)'= " &
&$ &! "(! 1"
) '} ~' #
1( } ~"")
!}0 ~"$ =# "*1
! 2( # $ =!
)0'? *" =!}2
#~( %""(" ? ?'(
2#1"$& }1 ~"} ~)$ }
* D='~B !" ' $4
*2$ * ) !'&"
!%" **)" "
*! %**)
C1 5}F~"( )F0*0%"
F%"$ 1}! 2="2%~
=nK}u"%" *(! $0u~)
*!" % K}0 %%)))~"
}a 6**6 ~)CBKq*!!)s*
r)0(!"(*=!1?'"$
$$'))C1"
%"$ !2* )4 1% "
!%"($10'?$=%"
$ 0 %$)x 1
} (%~ ! # C '
! "' Kqx0 1r)q
r"2=)q0!r)&0'?
,87
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
1 >} $!% ''~)&
2=" !} !~) ( !%
)0*!%Kq%r"
'"$ !'' ' ' )q !$
(r)%5 u1 )C
2% 1K} (4 $ &
~)C4(2="Kq *
* =(12r)C %x'
%* "' "*)' 2
* !1"$*3)C}$
~% 1 2%)C%
B"2 } 0~ "$
!1!"a& " 0% 1
* u(& }y((% * z %
#u}( %2~) (
'2) 4 2"'
" " $5 %
*(!% )
' 0" !"
(&" "$%"#&"
"!& 5*"$ %"
%5 *!" ) )}(
*1) ('%| =5!){#(
4 ~) ($
#" % k&%" $*( "$
* % %
%' = )} ~ 4"'$
7I"!:8!8I8-(
"} "!(1"(
'! ( )" 4 "2
$ '" 1(F
}% ~)
C1%}* D='~"
51(1%) "*' * "$
!" '!% ="(
$ "' 1:!&
0'?*% " #DKq *1"
r)q&"*r"$
n' &%( k
'( 1 ){ *(2} ~
*>$(( $' '
)x{&# 0'? 14" )!"
'% "=-."}> 1
14"(!'~) 3& '%
Amador García-Carrasco
,,.
' t% &)C(20'?"
!' K} *(0"~)} ~
)C ! 2 " '%
$ $!$
)40"2(&0'?)( *
#*( $ !)!}*
* ~ ! =4 "( (
4"!= k % !
! M= )qB%*! % !)>2r"
D" )C3q%r)K}u
%'%2"*! %~)q>(!
kur)q*( $ # r)C''Kq
#r)0'?*!1 33"(
!)$!& " "1
#)>($1*2%(" '
15%)B* "2' (% D)
C %#= 3*"2 (* 1F)
q*0r "D*)C*!1
! " $2 = 1)C
D% 0 " & Kq
% sr)y>$10'?% z0Kq0
$ *r" ( 14"q 'u
$v$1 "0'?F !Dv
k*!1$ ' r)q* 0u
F 1 0(!* r) #=
()C%Kq *5
(" # 'r)
2 "M ?"(4$2* ! )B(
2 ' }1 ~ *2% " $
! " % () " !%"
$ % !Kq# r)
q!* # %
)1"!r) ' B"(" !
> ) "! " KqC
* )C (0r"4 !F) '
)0 " !)!*
% 4#1)}0*!$*!~)C
% % "# )C ) 1
! & " }#?~(
) '2 $ # "
%)C$*(* =# "2 (
2#a!!K} ' ' '~)
$! k BKq *! u
# ! u ! ( ' 2 '
,,8
Dostoievski: Justicia y Dios. Re exiones ético-estéticas
!1!'u1 * " 2! 4$
} '~2) "** "
% 1"!uq2% $$* #m
$# % $ 2 2=%r)
$(# !$1 ) )*(
#% *)$1 ="
& !(# (#*)qx{&
!$&*! #2
$r)qy$&''z#!3r)
'" !" #)
% ="% }'3~)
# ! )
y$& # z$)" #%
( (*u k )
>( $*! 1* )
0&}! #~)}!~)x%**
!"'" =)C"
% 2'" " 2 )
y'$21! ( % 3 z
! )
B" "}~)qx&y{&
&"*z1"&$ uy$& z?
1" 1 uxM "!&r)
" (} ~)C1
#1Kqx 1$ '1)
D='4#"'r)C''Kqy
$&$zrq$ #0r)$ "
!" "$1" ) K
qy{&*! 0( zr($0'?"!
"! " !"'&
2"%$ "$*(&"
)q$"1r" tk $
4!& %%1)C$! # "
%(%"} $* ~) $
(* "(4 KqB3 20r)
y$& B'z$0(2 1
)% k(#&" $
)0' "?'"1*! "
)q0%ur)CB*!!1!}>!'~"
$ }>*~"$1 #!2=
# )$$}*! '~! )q*
"k r)F 2(' )*
"!= $ )qy1(''
Amador García-Carrasco
,,,
0 z* 0" !2
)*!! 0(5 )xF'0(
%1' x0r) =) %1"
'"ka ==Kqy''zx *! r)
}k~)C'')qy{&10 kzy$&
( (=zr) k' "$
# ! k"! ' !
' *% )#} $~% ( %'
*" $= 2% )}'
*!~">%" $* (
42 #%)C Kq*1'"
u('* ~)} "! %
~"!)}'%~) 0
!v('v0"#(%1)F(
')' *(0"$" "2
= )*($*= )>( kK}s ~"
F*"$!2)q>(* r) 4"
(&K} 4 ~)C tk "
$ %5 *($2*2"2
"} ~ )F)
*% &K )B"$ ' *
* ) " " }2~k"
(}#~" %!K* 1"*1
} k ~)# 2 $'==
' " $ ' $&#"*
#1# $!)
Plura legant vacui.
Para continuar leyendo
Solicita tu prueba