El futuro del IVA en las importaciones: problemas, soluciones e incertidumbres
| Autor | José Manuel Macarro Osuna |
| Páginas | 213-256 |
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP435
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu
rtqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu"
Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc
(#∋)∃∗∋#+94−0/3&∃+!∋%&∋#6+
73∀8∃#∗∀0/0+(/5.∋+0∃+Λ./8∀0∃
Hgejc"fg"tgegrek„p<"32/29/423;"
Hgejc"fg"cegrvcek„p<"53/29/423;
TGUWOGP<
Nc"cevwcn"tgiwncek„p" fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqt vcekqpgu"fg" dkgpgu"rtgugpvc"owejqu" {"fkxgtuqu"
rtqdngocu0"Nc" WG" jc" oqfkhkecfq" nc" pqtocvkxc" KXC." eqttkikgpfq" owejqu" fg" nqu" gttqtgu"
gzkuvgpvgu0"Ug"jc" gnkokpcfq"nc" gzgpek„p"fgn" KXC"c"ncu"korqt vcekqpgu"fg"guecuq" xcnqt."swg"
uwrqpc"wpc"korqtvcpvg"kphtceek„p"fg"pgwvtcnkfcf"hkuecn0"Cfgoƒu."ug"oqfkhkecp"nqu"jgejqu"
korqpkdngu"gzkuvgpvgu"gp"ncu"xgpvcu"c"eqpuwokfqtgu"fg"rtqfwevqu"korqtvcfqu."korwnucpfq"
nqu" tgiogpgu"gurgekcngu" fg" xgpvcpknnc" ¿pkec0" Wpc" fg" ncu" pqxgfcfgu" oƒu" nncocvkxcu" gu"
gn"rcrgn" fg" uwlgvq" rcukxq" swg"ug" xc" c" qvqtict"c" ncu" kpvgthcegu" gngevt„pkecu" swg"hceknkvgp"
fgvgtokpcfcu" gpvtgicu"fg" dkgpgu." gtkikfipfqncu" eqoq" eqpvtkdw{gpvgu" encxg" fgn" ukuvgoc0"
Vq f c u " g u v c u " t g h q t o c u . " u k p " g o d c t i q . " r n c p v g c p " c n i w p c u " f w f c u " u q d t g "uw"ecrcekfcf"fg"
tguqnxgt "cniwpqu "fg"nqu"ht cwfgu"oƒ u"tgngxcp vgu"cn"KXC"gp"nc u"korqt vcekq pgu0
Rcncdtc u"encxgKXC."korqtvcekqpgu."cfwcpcu."xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec."kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec0"
CDUVTCEV<
Vjg"ewttgpv"XCV"tgiwncvkqp"qh"korqtvcvkqpu"qh"iqqfu"rtgugpvu"ugxgtcn"cpf"fkhhgtgpv"rtqdngou0"
Vjg"GW"jcu"oqfkhkgf"vjg"XCV"tgiwncvkqpu."cogpfkpi"uqog"qh"vjg"gzkuvkpi"okuvcmgu0"Vjg"nqy/
xcnwg"eqpukipogpv"tgnkgh."vjcv"ecwugu"c" oclqt"kphtcevkqp"qh" hkuecn"pgwvtcnkv{."yknn"dg"tgoqxgf0"
Hwtvjgtoqtg."vjg"gzkuvkpi"vczcdng"gxgpvu"hqt"fkuvcpeg"ucngu"qh"korqtvgf"iqqfu"vq"eqpuwogtu"
jcxg"dggp"cogpfgf."cpf"vjg"ueqrg"qh"vjg"qpg/uvqr/ujqr"yknn"dg"ykfgpgf"vq"kpenwfg"vjgo0"
Qpg"qh"vjg"oquv"tgoctmcdng"ejcpigu"tgncvgu"vq"gngevtqpke"kpvgthcegu"vjcv"yknn"dgeqog"vczcdng"
uwdlgevu"yjgp"vjg" hceknkvcvg"urgekhke" fgnkxgtkgu"qh" iqqfu."ocmkpi" vjgo"c" eqtpgtuvqpg"qh"vjg"
pgy"u{uvgo0"Pgxgtvjgnguu."cnn"vjgug"tghqtou"tckug"uqog"fqwdvu"cdqwv"vjgkt"ecrcekv{"qh"uqnxkpi"
uqog"qh"vjg"oquv"tgngxcpv"htcwf"ecugu"kp"XCV"qh"korqtvu0"
Mg{"yqtfuXCV."korqt vcvkqpu."ewuvqou."qpg/uvqr/ujqr."gngevtqpke"kpvgthceg0
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
436
UWOCTKQ+Ζ6+>3∋0−%%∀Η3β+./+3∃%∃∗∀0/0+0∃+/)#∋3&/#+.∋∗+Ι#∋5.∃∆/∗+0∃#∀8/0∋∗+0∃+./+#∃Χ−./%∀Η3+0∃+./∗+
∀∆Ι∋#&/%∀∋3∃∗+∃3+ ∃.+>Β96+Ψ6+?.+ )∀3+0∃+ −3/+0∀∗&∋#∗∀Η3+ 0∃.+∆∃#%/0∋+∀3&∃#3∋β+ ./+∃.∀∆∀3/%∀Η3+
0∃+./+∃Υ∃3%∀Η3+/+./∗+∀∆Ι∋#&/%∀∋3∃∗+0∃+∃∗%/∗∋+8/.∋#6+Ν6++#∃8∋.−%∀Η3+0∃+./∗+∀∆Ι∋#&/%∀∋3∃∗+
/+%∋3∗−∆∀0∋#∃∗6+Ν6Ζ6+73+ 3−∃8∋+1∃%1∋+ ∀∆Ι∋3∀5.∃+4+−3+ %/∆5∀∋+0∃+ %∋3)∀Χ−#/%∀Η3+0∃.+ >Β96++
Ν6Ψ6+Ο∃Χ./∗+0∃+.∋%/.∀Σ/%∀Η3+0∃+./∗+8∃3&/∗+/+0∀∗&/3%∀/+0∃+5∀∃3∃∗+∀∆Ι∋#&/0∋∗+4+∗−+%∋∆Ι/&∀5∀.∀0/0+
%∋3+∃.+1∃%1∋+∀∆Ι∋3∀5.∃+0∃+∀∆Ι∋#&/%∀∋3∃∗6+Ν6Ν6+ 0∃+8∃3&/3∀../+α3∀%/+
Ι/#/+./∗+/3∗/%%∀∋3∃∗+∀3&∃#3/%∀∋3/.∃∗6+Ν6Ν6Ζ6+73+#ΦΧ∀∆∃3+∃∗Ι∃%∀/.+0∃+8∃3&/3∀../+α3∀%/+Ι/#/+
./∗+8∃3&/∗+/+0∀∗&/3%∀/+0∃+5∀∃3∃∗+∀∆Ι∋#&/0∋∗6+Ν6Ν6Ψ6+ ?.+#ΦΧ∀∆∃3+/.&∃#3/&∀8∋+/+./+8∃3&/3∀../+
α3∀%/+Ι/#/+./+0∃%./#/%∀Η3+∗∀∆Ι.∀)∀%/0/+0∃.+>Β9+∃3+∀∆Ι∋#&/%∀∋3∃∗6+_6+
)−&−#∋β+./∗+∀3&∃#)/%∃∗+∃.∃%Η3∀%/∗6+_6Ζ6+73/+#∃Χ−./%∀Η3+4/+∃Υ∀∗&∃3&∃+Ι/#/+./+∀3&∃#∆∃0∀/%∀Η3+
∃.∃%Η3∀%/+∃3+./+ Ι#∃∗&/%∀Η3+0∃+∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗6+ _6Ψ6++∃Υ&∃3∗∀Η3+0∃+./+ ∗−Π∃%∀Η3+/+./∗+ ∀3&∃#)/%∃∗+
∃.∃%Η3∀%/∗+Ρ−∃+)/%∀.∀&∃3+0∃&∃#∆∀3/0/∗+∃3∃Χ/∗+0∃+5∀∃3∃∗6+_6Ν6;+Ε∀∆Ι.∀)∀%/%∀∋3∃∗+)∋#∆/.∃∗+
4+ ∗−∗&/3%∀/.∃∗+ Ι/#/+ ./∗+ ∀3&∃#)/%∃∗+ ∃.∃%Η3∀%/∗+ Ρ−∃+ ∗∃/3+ %∋3∗∀0∃#/0/∗+ ∗−Π∃&∋+ Ι/∗∀8∋6++
ε6+Λ/∗+%−∃∗&∀∋3∃∗+Ρ−∃+Ι./3&∃/+./+∗−Π∃%∀Η3+0∃+ ./∗+∀3&∃#)/%∃∗+ ∃.∃%Η3∀%/∗+4+ ./+8∃3&/3∀../+
α3∀%/+Ι/#/+∀∆Ι∋#&/%∀∋3∃∗+γΨ:6+ς6+:∋3%.−∗∀∋3∃∗
30" KPVTQFWEEKðPC"PGEGUKFCF"FG"CHTQPVCT"NQU"
RTQDNGOCU"FGTKXCFQU"FG"NC"TGIWNCEKðP"FG"NCU"
KORQTVCEKQPGU"GP"GN"KXC"3
Nc"tgiwncek„p"fg"nc"vtkdwvcek„p"rqt"KXC"fg"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"dkgpgu"vcpikdngu"
gp"vtcpuceekqpgu"tgcnk¦cfcu"eqp"eqpuwokfqtgu"Þpcngu"rtgugpvc"korqtvcpvgu"hwgp/
vgu"fg"rtqdngocu"fg" ow{"fkuvkpvc"pcvwtcng¦c"4 0" Nqu"tgekgpvgu"guvwfkqu"tgcnk¦cfqu"
rqt"nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"{"rqt"qvtqu"qticpkuoqu"jcp"rwguvq"fg"ocpkÞguvq"swg"
nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC."gp"nq"tghgtgpvg"c"guvcu"vtcpuceekqpgu."jc"guvcdngekfq"wp"ukuvgoc"
swg"tguwnvc"ow{"eqornglq"fg"ectc"c"nqu"wuwctkqu"guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"Wpk„p"{"swg."
cfgoƒu."guvƒ" ukgpfq" qdlgvq" fg"htcwfg" {" cdwuq" ocukxq"rqt" rctvg" fg"nqu" uwok/
pkuvtcfqtgu"fg" vgtegtqu" rcugu0" Rctc"oquvtct"nqu" rtqdngocu"igpgtcfqu"rqt"guvc"
pqtocvkxc"xcoqu"c"guvtwevwtctnqu"gp"hwpek„p"fg"nqu"fkuvkpvqu"tgiogpgu"KXC"swg"
ug"crnkecp"{"fg"nc"qdnkicek„p"fg"vtkdwvcek„p"cfwcpgtc"swg"ug"guvcdngeg"rctc"guvg"
vkrq"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"50
Nc"rtkogtc"ewguvk„p"swg"uwrqpg"wpc"fkuvqtuk„p"fg"itcp"tgngxcpekc"rctc"gn"rtkpek/
rkq"fg"pgwvtcnkfcf"Þuecn"swg"fgdg"tgikt"gn"korwguvq"gu"nc"gzgpek„p"swg"gzkuvg"rctc"
ncu"gpvtgicu" fg" guecuq"xcnqt0"Nqu"fcvqu"swg" ocpglc" nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"eqoq"
3" Guvg" ctvewnq" jc" ukfq" tgcnk¦cfq" eqoq" fgucttqnnq" fgn" Rtq{gevq"fg" RIE423:/2;;55:/D/K22"
ÑFguchqu"vtkdwvctkqu"gp"gn"pwgxq"eqpvgzvq"gwtqrgq"g"kpvgtpcekqpcn/
tkqtÒ."eqttgurqpfkgpvg"cn"Rtqitcoc"Guvcvcn"fg"K-F-k"fg"Igpgtcek„p"fg"Eqpqekokgpvq"fgn"Okpkuvgtkq"fg"
Ekgpekc."Kppqxcek„p"{"Wpkxgtukfcfgu0
4" Ewcpfq"cnwfcoqu"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"tgcnk¦cfcu"eqp"eqpuwokfqtgu"hkpcngu"pqu"tghgtktgoqu"
c"ncu"fkuvkpvcu"rqukdknkfcfgu"geqp„okecu"fg"guvcu"vtcpuceekqpgu"eqpvgpkfcu"fgpvtq"fgn"jgejq"korqpk/
dng"ÑkorqtvcekqpguÒ" fg"nc" pqtocvkxc"KXC dkgpgu"vcpikdngu" tgcnk¦cfcu"rqt" wpc"gortguc"fg"
wp"vgtegt"vgttkvqtkq"eqp"fguvkpq"c"eqpuwokfqtgu"hkpcngu."fktgevcogpvg"vtcpurqtvcfqu"c"nqu"okuoqu."cu"
eqoq"vtcpuceekqpgu"tgcnk¦cfcu"rqt"gortguctkqu"q"rtqhgukqpcngu"guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"Wpk„p"Gwtqrgc"swg"
xgpfcp"rtqfwevqu"korqtvcfqu"fg"hwgtc"fgn"ogtecfq"kpvgtpq"c"fkejqu"wuwctkqu"eqowpkvctkqu0"
5" UYF*4238+"59;" hkpcn." fg" 3"fg"fkekgodtg" fg" 4238." Ñ:∋∆∆∀∗∗∀∋3+Ε&/))+ θ∋#π∀3Χ+ !∋%−∆∃3&β+
>∆Ι/%&+9∗∗∃∗∗∆∃3&+ 9%%∋∆Ι/34∀3Χ+ &1∃+ 0∋%−∆∃3&+ (#∋Ι∋∗/.∗+)∋#+ /+ :∋−3%∀.+ !∀#∃%&∀8∃ϑ+ /+ :∋−3%∀.+ >∆Ι.∃;
∆∃3&∀3Χ+Ο∃Χ−./&∀∋3+/30+/+ :∋−3%∀.+Ο∃Χ−./&∀∋3+∋3+=∋0∃#3∀∗∀3Χ+ Β9,+)∋#+%#∋∗∗;5∋#0∃#+γΨ:+∃;%∋∆∆∃#%∃Ò."
rr0"36/390"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP437
eqpugewgpekc"fg"guvc"gzgpek„p"uqp"rtgqewrcpvgu."rwgu"owguvtcp"wp"etgekokgpvq"
gzrqpgpekcn"Ïoƒu" fg"wp"522'Ï"fg" guvg"vkrq"fg" korqtvcekqpgu"60" Nqu"rtqdngocu"
eqpuvcvcfqu"pq"fgtkxcp"¿pkecogpvg"fg"nc"fguxgpvclc"eqorgvkvkxc"swg"gzrgtkogp/
vcp"ncu"gortgucu"eqowpkvctkcu"rqt"gn"jgejq"fg"vgpgt"swg"eqorgvkt"eqp"rtqfwevqu"
korqtvcfqu" ukp" KXC0" Nqu" guvwfkqu" owguvtcp" gn" cdwuq" swg" ug" guvƒ" jcekgpfq" fg"
guvc"gzgpek„p."c"vtcxfiu"fg"eqpfwevcu"vcngu"eqoq"kphtcxcnqtct"rtqfwevqu"fg"oc{qt"
rtgekq"q"fgenctct"nc"korqtvcek„p"fg"qvtqu"fg"dclq"xcnqt"{"pq"nqu"tgcnogpvg"vtcpu/
rqtvcfqu"rctc"rqfgt"ceqigtug"c"guvc"gzgpek„p"fgn"KXC0"
Gn"ugiwpfq"dnqswg"fg" vtcpuceekqpgu" swg" vkgpg" wpc" rtqdngoƒvkec" rctvkewnct" gu"gn"
tghgtgpvg"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"swg"vkgpgp"wp"xcnqt"uwrgtkqt"cn"octecfq"rctc"nc"gzgp/
ek„p."rgtq"swg"pq"cnecp¦cp"gn"korqtvg"opkoq"pgeguctkq"rctc"vgpgt"swg"ucvkuhcegt"
nqu"fgtgejqu" cfwcpgtqu." swg" gu" fg" 372" Û0" Nc"eqpÞiwtcek„p"fgn"jgejq"korqpkdng"
fgn"KXC"tghgtgpvg"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"jceg"swg"guvcu"qrgtcekqpgu"tguwnvgp"gurgekcn/
ogpvg"eqornglcu"rctc"nqu"eqpuwokfqtgu"Þpcngu0"Rqt"wp"ncfq."rqtswg"nqu"wuwctkqu"
swg"cfswkgtgp"ncu"ogtecpecu"korqtvcfcu"ug"eqpxkgtvgp"gp"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"fgn"ko/
rwguvq"{."eqp"gnnq."fgwfqtgu"fg"nc"qdnkicek„p"vtkdwvctkc"rtkpekrcn0"Jc{"swg"tgeqtfct"
swg"nc"eqpÞiwtcek„p"fgn"KXC"eqoq"wp"korwguvq"swg"tgecg"hqtocnogpvg"uqdtg"ncu"
xgpvcu."ceqorc‚cfq"fg"nc"tgrgtewuk„p"qdnkicvqtkc"uqdtg"gn"cfswktgpvg."swg"eqpuk/
iwg"swg"geqp„okecogpvg"hwpekqpg"eqoq"wp"itcxcogp"uqdtg"gn"eqpuwoq."vkgpg"gn"
qdlgvkxq"fg"nkdtct"c"nqu"eqpuwokfqtgu"Þpcngu"fg"qdnkicekqpgu"vtkdwvctkcu"ocvgtkcngu"
{"hqtocngu0"Gp"gn"ecuq"fg"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"dkgpgu."guvg"qdlgvkxq"pq"ug"eworng."
{"gn"KXC"fgdg"ugt"ucvkuhgejq"rqt"gn"cfswktgpvg."kpenwuq"ewcpfq"guvg"pq"ugc"gortg/
uctkq"q"rtqhgukqpcn."gp"gn"oqogpvq"fg"nc"gpvtcfc"fgn"rtqfwevq"gp"gn"vgttkvqtkq"WG0"
Fkejq"rciq"rwgfg"jcegtug"fg"ocpgtc"gngevt„pkec"c"vtcxfiu"fg"nc"ygd"fg"nc"Cigpekc"
Vtkdwvctkc."uk"dkgp"vcodkfip"gu"rqukdng"eqpÞct"nc"nkswkfcek„p"{"gn"rciq"fgn"korwguvq"cn"
qrgtcfqt"rquvcn"q"fgn"vtcpurqtvg"Ïgortguc"fg"eqttgqu"q"ogpuclgtcÏ."swg"ng"eqdtc"
cn"wuwctkq"gn"KXC"{"wp"ectiq"cfkekqpcn"rqt"nqu"equvgu"fg"iguvk„p0"
Gn"vgtegt"eqplwpvq"fg"qrgtcekqpgu"ugtc"gn"fg"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"xcnqt"wpkvctkq"uw/
rgtkqt"c"372"Û."swg"swgfctcp"uwlgvcu"vcpvq"c"KXC"eqoq"c"nqu"korwguvqu"cfwcpgtqu0"
Nc"iguvk„p"fg"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"ocvgtkcngu"{"hqtocngu"fgtkxcfcu"fgn"KXC"uqp"ukoknctgu"
c"ncu"fg"dkgpgu"fg"ogpqu"fg"372Û0"Nc"rtkpekrcn"fkhgtgpekc"gu"gn"kpetgogpvq"fg"eqo/
rnglkfcf"fg"nc"vtcpuceek„p."cn"vgpgt"swg"ucvkuhcegtug"nqu"itcxƒogpgu"ctcpegnctkqu"{"
swg"rwgfg"vgpgt"swg"tgcnk¦ctug"wpc"fgenctcek„p"cfwcpgtc"eqorngvc0"
Gp"hwpek„p" fg" guvqu" vtgu" itwrqu." nc"Eqokuk„p" Gwtqrgc" jc" xgpkfq" kfgpvkÞecpfq"
ewcvtq"eqpfwevcu"fg"htcwfg"{"fg"cdwuq"fg"nc"tgiwncek„p"fgn"KXC"uqdtg"ncu"korqt/
vcekqpgu"fkhgtgpvgu0"Fqu"fg"gnncu"uqp"tghgtgpvgu"c"wpc"xcnqtcek„p"fgnkdgtcfcogpvg"
gtt„pgc"fg"nqu"rtqfwevqu"c"korqtvctrctc"ceqigtug"c"nc"gzgpek„p"fg"dkgpgu"
fg"guecuq"xcnqt"{"qvtc"rctc"pq"uqdtgrcuct"gn"nokvg"fg"372Û"fg"qdnkicek„p"cfwcpg/
tc"{"rqfgt"gxkvct"nc"uwlgek„p"c"ctcpegngu."cu"eqoq"tgfwekt"gn"KXC"fgenctcfq"cn"dclct"
gn"rtgekq"fg"nc"korqtvcek„p0"Nc"vgtegtc"ugtc"tghgtgpvg"c"wpc"fgenctcek„p"kpeqttgevc"
fgn"vkrq"fg"korqtvcek„p."ecnkÞeƒpfqnc"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"gpvtg"eqpuwokfqtgu"q"fg"
wpc"korqtvcek„p"fg"rtqfwevqu"fg"owguvtc."vtcpuceekqpgu"nkdtgu"fg"KXC0"Nc"¿nvkoc."
6" VCZWF142351FG1556."G["Uvwf{"hqt"vjg"Eqookuukqp."9∗∗∃∗∗∆∃3&+∋)+&1∃+/ΙΙ.∀%/&∀∋3+/30+∀∆;
Ι/%&+∋)+&1∃+Β9,+∃Υ∃∆Ι&∀∋3+)∋#+∀∆Ι∋#&/&∀∋3∗+∋)+∗∆/..+%∋3∗∀Χ3∆∃3&∗6+2∀3/.+Ο∃Ι∋#&."oc{q"fg"42370
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
438
{"swg"jc"ukfq"ecwuc"fg"rtgqewrcekqpgu"rctc"xctkqu"GGOO."gu"wp"htcwfg"eqpuku/
vgpvg"gp"nc"gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu"fgufg"cnocegpgu"ukvwcfqu"gp"nc"WG"swg"uqp"vtcvcf qu "
fqnqucogpvg"eqoq"korqtvcekqpgu"nkdtgu"fg"KXC"70"
Nqu"fkhgtgpvgu" guvwfkqu"uqdtg"nc"rfitfkfc" tgecwfcvqtkc"gp"korqtvcekqpgu"tgxgncp"
ncu"fkogpukqpgu" fgn"rtqdngoc"cn"swg" pqu" gphtgpvcoqu0"Nc"Eqokuk„p" Gwtqrgc."c"
rctvkt"fg"wp"guvwfkq"tgcnk¦cfq"rqt"Fgnqkvvg"8."kpenwuq"cfokvkgpfq"swg"uwu"guvkoc/
ekqpgu"uqp"eqpugtxcfqtcu."cwogpvc"eqpukfgtcdngogpvg"nqu"fcvqu"fg"guvwfkqu"cp/
vgtkqtgu"9 0"Gp"guvg"vtcdclq"ug"qdugtx„"swg"nc"rfitfkfc"tgecwfcvqtkc"fg"KXC"cpwcnk¦c/
fc"rqt"nc"hcnvc"fg"ewornkokgpvq"gu"fg"78;"oknnqpgu"fg"gwtqu"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"
gzgpvcu."{"fg" 40365"oknnqpgu"fg"gwtqu"gp"dkgpgu"pq"gzgpvqu"rgtq"swg"pq"vkgpgp"
swg"rcict"fgtgejqu"fg"cfwcpc": 0"Qvtcu"kpxguvkicekqpgu"tgcnk¦cfcu"rqt"gn" Ugpcfq"
htcpefiu."q"nqu"kphqtogu"fg"nc"Cfokpkuvtcek„p"vtkdwvctkc"dtkvƒpkec."rncpvgcp"ekhtcu"fg"
htcwfg"c¿p"oc{qtgunc"kpuvkvwek„p"icnc"cÞtoc"wp"itcfq"fg"kpewornkokgpvq"egtec/
pq"cn"97'"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"; ."okgpvtcu"swg"JOTE"cÞto„"wpc"rfitfkfc"
tgecwfcvqtkc"cpwcn"fg"30722"oknnqpgu"uqnq"gp"gn"Tgkpq"Wpkfq"32 0"
Rqt"¿nvkoq."swgtgoqu"oquvtct"nqu"tguwnvcfqu"fg"wp"guvwfkq"tgcnk¦cfq"rqt":∋Ι∃31/;
Χ∃3+?%∋3∋∆∀%∗"fqpfg"cpcnk¦ctqp"5:7"owguvtcu"tgcngu"fg"eqortcu"vtcpuhtqpvgtk¦cu"
tgcnk¦cfcu"rqt"kpvgtpgv."vqfcu"uwlgvcu"{"pq"gzgpvcu"fg"KXC."{"vtcpurqtvcfcu"nc"okvcf"
c"vtcxfiu"fg" ncu"eqorc‚cu"fg"ugtxkekqu"rquvcngu"{"nc"qvtc"okvcf"rqt"gortgucu"fg"
ogpuclgtc"wtigpvg"33 0"Wpc"rctvg"fg"nqu"gpxqu"Ï3:5Ï"pq"cnecp¦cdc"gn"xcnqt"opkoq"
7" Nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"crwpvc"swg"vcpvq"Tgkpq"Wpkfq"eqoq"Cngocpkc"jcp"kphqtocfq"uqdtg"
guvg"vkrq"fg" cdwuqu."{"nc"Eqtvg" Gwtqrgc"fg"Cwfkvqtgu" jc"crtgokcfq"c" nc"Wpk„p" Gwtqrgc"c"swg" uqnw/
ekqpg"guvg"rtqdngoc."fcfq"swg"guvctc"rqpkgpfq"c"nqu"gortguctkqu"ewornkfqtgu"fg"uwu"qdnkicekqpgu"
vtkdwvctkcu"gp"wpc"rqukek„p"fg"fguxgpvclc"eqorgvkvkxc"swg"guvctc"qduvcewnk¦cpfq"uw"rtqrkc"gzkuvgpekc0"
UYF*4238+"59;"Hkpcn."∋Ι6+%∀&6."r0"390
8" Fgnqkvvg." Guvwfkq" rctc" nc" Eqokuk„p" uqdtg" ÑΛΙ&∀∋3∗+ )∋#+ ∆∋0∃#3∀∗∀3Χ+ Β9,+ )∋#+ %#∋∗∗;5∋#0∃#+
?;:∋∆∆∃#%∃"2∀3/.+Ο∃Ι∋#&Ω+fg"qevwdtg"fg"4237."{"swg"guvƒ"fkxkfkfq"gp"vtgu"fqewogpvqu"fkuvkpvqu."swg"
ug"rwgfg"gpeqpvtct"gp"1&&Ι∗β∴∴∃%6∃−#∋Ι/6∃−∴&/Υ/&∀∋3ϖ%−∗&∋∆∗∴Ι−5.∀%/&∀∋3∗∴∗&−0∀∃∗;∆/0∃;%∋∆∆∀∗∗∀∋3ϖ
∃3"Guvqu"fcvqu"guvƒp"gp"gn"ugiwpfq"kphqtog"ÑCpcn{uku"qh"equvu."dgpghkvu."qrrqtvwpkvkgu" cpf" tkumu" kp"
tgurgev"qh"vjg"qrvkqpu"hqt"vjg"oqfgtpkucvkqp"qh"vjg"XCV"curgevu"qh"etquu/dqtfgt"g/EqoogtegÒ."rr0"483"
{"uu0
9" Gn"ekvcfq"guvwfkq"fg"G["uqdtg"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"rgswg‚c"ewcpvc"guvkocdc"gn"kpewornkokgp/
vq"vqvcn"fgn"KXC"gp"korqtvcek„p"gp"wp"47'0"ΛΙ6+%∀&6
:" Ncu"guvkocekqpgu"fg"kpewornkokgpvq"gp"qrgtcekqpgu"vtcpuhtqpvgtk¦cu"tgcnk¦cfcu"eqp"eqpuw/
okfqtgu"hkpcngu."vcpvq" fg"korqtvcekqpgu" eqoq"fg" vtcpuceekqpgu"kpvtc/WG."cuegpfgtc"c"oƒu"fgn"72'"
fgn"KXC"swg"fgdgtc"fgxgpictug"{"tgecwfctug0"Fgnqkvvg."Kphqtog"vgtegtq"uqdtg"ÑCpcn{uku"qh"equvu."dgpg/
hkvu."qrrqtvwpkvkgu"cpf"tkumu]É̲Ò."∋Ι6+%∀&6."r0"4840
;" Ufipcv"Eqookuukqp"fgu"hkpcpegu"*4237+."Ng"G/Eqoogtegqrqukvkqp"rwt"wpg"VXC"rc{fig""nc"
uqwteg."rr0"49/56."ug"rwgfg"gpeqpvtct"gp
1&&Ιβ∴∴µµµ6∗∃3/&6)#∴)∀.∃/0∆∀3∴2∀%1∀∃#∗∴>∆/Χ∃∗∴#∃0/%&∀∋3ϖ∆−.&∀∆∃0∀/∴Ψ[Ζε∴Ψ[Ζε;!∋%−∆∃3&∗ϖ
Ι0)∴Ψ[Ζε[]Ζϖ∃ϖ%∋∆∆∃#%∃6Ι0)"
32" Jgt"Oclguv{"Tgxgpwg"("Ewuvqou."2−.)∀.∆∃3&+λ∋−∗∃+!−∃+!∀.∀Χ∃3%∃+Ε%1∃∆∃ϑ+38"fg"oct¦q"fg"
4238."rr0"5/60"Ug"rwgfg"gpeqpvtct"gp
1&&Ι∗β∴∴µµµ6Χ∋86−π∴Χ∋8∃#3∆∃3&∴−Ι.∋/0∗∴∗4∗&∃∆∴−Ι.∋/0∗∴/&&/%1∆∃3&ϖ0/&/∴)∀.∃∴ε[ςΖ[∴2−.)∀.;
∆∃3&ϖλ∋−∗∃ϖ!−∃ϖ!∀.∀Χ∃3%∃ϖΕ%1∃∆∃ϖ;ϖλ=Ο:ϖ%∋3∗−.&/&∀∋36Ι0)"
33" Nqu"rcugu" fg" rtqxgpkgpekc" fg"nqu"gpxqu" hwgtqp Ecpcfƒ." Ejkpc." Guvcfqu" Wpkfqu."Kpfkc"{"
Lcr„p." {" nqu" GGOO" fg" korqtvcek„p"Cngocpkc." Gurc‚c." Htcpekc." Rcugu" Dclqu." Rqnqpkc."Tgkpq" Wpkfq"{"
Uwgekc0"Nqu" dkgpgu"ew{qu" gpxqu" hwgtqp"cpcnk¦cfqu" gtcp"dkgpgu"uwlgvqu" c"ctcpegngu"{" pq"gzgpvqu" fg"
KXC"Ïtqrc."¦crcvqu."ocngvcu"{"gswkrcokgpvq"fgrqtvkxqÏ."rqt"nq"swg"pq"ug"eqpvtqnctqp"dkgpgu"eqp"xcnqt"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP439
rctc"fgxgpict"ctcpegngu"cfwcpgtqu"Ï372"ÛÏ."{"nc"qvtc"Ï424Ï."u"guvcdc"uwlgvc"c"fkejq"
vtkdwvq0"Nqu"tguwnvcfqu"uqp"fgoqngfqtgu"rctc"nqu"gpxqu"rqt"eqttgq"rquvcn"eqpxgp/
ekqpcnn"pqtocn"ewornkgtqp"
eqp"uwu"qdnkicekqpgu"KXC"gp"rtqfwevqu"swg"pq"vgpc"qdnkicek„p"fg"rcict"fgtgejqu"
fg"cfwcpc."gxcfkgpfq"gn"rciq"fgn"korwguvq"gn"87'"fg"fkejcu"vtcpuceekqpgu0"Gp"gn"
ecuq"fg"ncu"gortgucu"fg"ogpuclgtc"wtigpvg"gn"tguwnvcfq"gtc"gn"eqpvtctkq."eqp"wp"
ewornkokgpvq" fgn" ;:'"34 0" Guvqu"fcvqu" owguvtcp"wp"kpewornkokgpvq" igpgtcnk¦cfq"
gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"vtcpurqtvcfcu"rqt"qrgtcfqtgu"rquvcngu."ektewpuvcpekc"swg"ug"
citcxc"eqp"gn"fcvq"rtqrqtekqpcfq"rqt"nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"swg"gn"rqtegpvclg"fg"
korqtvcekqpgu"swg"ug"fgucttqnnc"rqt"guvg"ogfkq"fg"vtcpurqtvg"gu"gn"92'0"
Nqu" guecpfcnququ" fcvqu" fg" kpewornkokgpvq" {" ncu" fkuvkpvcu" eqpfwevcu" igpgtcnk/
¦cfcu"fg" cdwuq" {"htcwfg" fgn" tfiikogp"KXC"fg" ncu" korqtvcekqpgu" eqp"fguvkpq" c"
eqpuwokfqtgu"jcp"ukfq"ncu"oqvkxcfqtcu"fg" nc" tghqtoc" swg" guvwfkctgoqu"3 5 0"Ncu"
ogfkfcu"swg"xcoqu"c"cpcnk¦ct"c"eqpvkpwcek„p"vkgpgp"wp"fqdng"qdlgvkxq"uwuvcpekcn"
{"wp"vgtegtq"rtqegfkogpvcn0"Gp"rtkogt"nwict."gu"pgeguctkq"korgfkt"swg"qrgtcfqtgu"
fg"rcugu"{"vgttkvqtkqu"vgtegtqu"rwgfcp"eqorgvkt"gp"oglqtgu"eqpfkekqpgu"vtkdwvc/
tkcu"swg"ncu"gortgucu"gwtqrgcu."rqt"gn"tkguiq"fg"swg"guvc"fguxgpvclc"eqorgvkvkxc"
fkÞewnvg"gn" fgucttqnnq" geqp„okeq0" Gp" ugiwpfq."ncu" rtƒevkecu" htcwfwngpvcu" guvƒp"
uwrqpkgpfq"wpc"rfitfkfc"tgecwfcvqtkc"ew{c"gnkokpcek„p"uwrqpftc"wpc"hwgpvg"fg"
tgewtuqu"dƒukec"rctc"nqu"GGOO0"Rqt"¿nvkoq."ug"rtgvgpfg"cxcp¦ct"gp"nc"ukornkÞec/
ek„p"fg"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"swg"vkgpgp"swg"ewornkt"nqu"wuwctkqu"fg"nc"Wpk„p"rctc"
rqfgt"tgcnk¦ct"vcngu"vtcpuceekqpgu0"Nc"eqpugewek„p"fg"guvcu"ogvcu"tguwnvc"fg"xkvcn"
korqtvcpekc"rctc"gn"hwpekqpcokgpvq"fgn"ogtecfq"kpvgtkqt"{"nc"geqpqoc"fg"nc"WG0
40" GN"HKP"FG"WPC"FKUVQTUKðP"FGN"OGTECFQ"KPVGTPQC"
GNKOKPCEKðP"FG"NC"GZGPEKðP"C"NCU"KORQTVCEKQPGU"FG"
GUECUQ"XCNQT
Nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC"36 "guvtwevwtc"gn"hwpekqpcokgpvq"fgn"korwguvq"gp"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"kp/
vgtpcekqpcngu"fg"ocpgtc"fkuvkpvc"c"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"kpvgtkqtgu0"Guvcdngeg"eqoq"jgejq"
kpvtpugeq"kphgtkqt"c"44Û0"Eqrgpjcigp"Geqpqokeu."?;%∋∆∆∃#%∃+>∆Ι∋#&∗+∀3&∋+?−#∋Ι∃β+Β9,+/30+:−∗&∋∆∗+
,#∃/ &∆ ∃3&."*Cwvqtgu"Dcucnkueq."D0."Ycjn."L0."Qmjqno."J0+0"Ug"rwgfg"gpeqpvtct"gp
1&&Ι∗β∴∴µµµ6%∋Ι∃31/Χ∃3∃%∋3∋∆∀%∗6%∋∆∴043∴#∃∗∋−#%∃∗∴(−5.∀%/&∀∋3∴Ι−5.∀%/&∀∋3(!;
2∴⊥∴Ν_⊥∴Ζ_ςΨ]⊥ς[⊥∴∃;%∋∆∆∃#%∃;∀∆Ι∋#&∗;∀3&∋;∃−#∋Ι∃ϖ8/&;/30;%−∗&∋∆∗;∃/&∆∃3&6Ι0)"
34" Ncu" eqpenwukqpgu" uqp" rctgekfcu" gp" gn" ecuq" fgn" rciq"fg" nqu" fgtgejqu" ctcpegnctkqu." rwgu"
ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"rqt" eqttgq"rquvcn"ewornkgtqp"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"ocvgtkcngu"gp" wp"69'"fg" nqu"ecuqu."
okgpvtcu"swg"ncu"fg"nc"ogpuclgtc"wtigpvg"gtcp"ewornkfqtcu"ecuk"gp"nc"vqvcnkfcf"Ï;;'Ï0"Eqrgpjcigp"
Geqpqokeu."?;%∋∆∆∃#%∃+>∆Ι∋#&∗+∀3&∋+?−#∋Ι∃β+Β9,+/30+:−∗&∋∆∗+,#∃/&∆∃3&."∋Ι6+%∀&6."r0"60
35"Nc"pwgxc"tgiwncek„p"rctvg"fg"nc"rtqrwguvc"fg"nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc."rctc"ew{c"hqtowncek„p"
ug"eqpv„"eqp"Eqpuglq"uqdtg"Vtkdwvcek„p"Cfwcpgtc0"Gn" vgzvq"crtqdcfq"rqt"gn"Eqpuglq"gu" htwvq"fg" 39"
tgwpkqpgu"fgn"θ∋#π∀3Χ+(/#&4+∋3+,/Υ+ν−∃∗&∀∋3∗"*YRVS+"{"5"tgwpkqpgu"fg"2∀∗%/.+9&&/%1Φ∗."{"hwg"fkuewvkfc"
rqt"gn"λ∀Χ1+ ∋3+,/Υ+>∗∗−∃∗"gp"8"lwpkq"{"49" qevwdtg"fg"4239."gzcokpcpfq"jcuvc"34"
tgrgvkekqpgu"fg"vgzvqu"fg"eqortqokuq0"Gp"5"YRVS"ug"kpxkv„"cn"θ∋#π∀3Χ+Ι/#&4+∋3+&1∃+:−∗&∋∆∗+73∀∋3∗"c "
rctvkekrct0"Fqewogpvq"423812592"*EPU+."GEQHKP":;:0"Fg"52"fg"qevwdtg"fg"4239."r0"50
36" Fktgevkxc"422813341EG"fgn"Eqpuglq."fg"4:"fg"pqxkgodtg"fg"4228."tgncvkxc"cn"ukuvgoc"eqo¿p"
fgn"korwguvq"uqdtg"gn"xcnqt"c‚cfkfq."gp"cfgncpvg"Fktgevkxc"KXC"q"FKXC0"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
43:
korqpkdng"kpfgrgpfkgpvg"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"{"fgenctc"gzgpvcu"ncu"gzrqtvcekqpgu"3 7 0"Nc"
uwlgek„p"fg"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu."ukp"godctiq."gu"qdlgvq"fg"pwogtqucu"gzegrekqpgu0"Gn"
ctv0"365"fg"nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC"guvcdngeg"wpc"ugtkg"fg"gzgpekqpgu."vcpvq"fg"oqvkxq"vfiepkeq"
Ïcrctvcfq"30f+"uqdtg"korqtvcekqpgu"swg"rtgegfcp"gpvtgicu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"gzgp/
vcuÏ"eqoq"hwpfcogpvcfcu"gp"nc"pcvwtcng¦c"geqp„okec"fg"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"uwlgvcu"cn"
korwguvq."swg"uqp"ncu"swg"pqu"qewrcp0"Gn"crctvcfq"30d+"jceg"tghgtgpekc"c"ncu"gzgpekq/
pgu"swg"ug"jcp"kpvtqfwekfq"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"gp"qvtcu"Fktgevkxcu"{."eqpetgvcogpvg."
gp"nc"Fktgevkxc":513:31EGG"38 ."swg"hwg"uwuvkvwkfc"rqt"nc"xkigpvg"Fktgevkxc"422;13541EG."
{"swg"chgevc"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"fgÞpkvkxcu"fg"dkgpgu"39 0"
Guvc"Fktgevkxc"kpvtqfweg"wpc"ugtkg"fg"uwrwguvqu"fg"gzgpek„p"ow{"jgvgtqifipgqu."
swg"tgurqpfgp"vcpvq"c"ukvwcekqpgu"fg"ectƒevgt"pq"eqogtekcn"eqoq"c"ecuqu"hwpfc/
ogpvcfqu"gp"wpc"n„ikec"fg"ukornkÞect"fgvgtokpcfcu"qrgtcekqpgu"{"fg"gxkvct"swg"
nqu"equvgu" cfokpkuvtcvkxqu"rwgfcp"ugt" uwrgtkqtgu"c"nqu"kpitguqu"tgecwfcvqtkqu"3 : 0"
Gp"gn"rtkogt"dnqswg"gpeqpvtcoqu"nc"korqtvcek„p"fg"dkgpgu"rgtuqpcngu"rgtvgpg/
ekgpvgu"c" nqu"rctvkewnctgu"swg"rtqegfgp" fg"vgtegtqu"rcugu"q"vgttkvqtkqu."ugc"rqt"
vtcuncfq"fg"tgukfgpekc"jcekc"nc"Wpk„p."rqtswg"ug"gpxgp"eqp"qecuk„p"fg"ocvtkoq/
pkq"q"jgtgpekc."q"rqtswg"ug"vtcvg"fgn"ocvgtkcn"fg"nqu"guvwfkcpvgu"swg"ug"vtcuncfcp"
c"guvwfkct" c" nc" WG" vgorqtcnogpvg0"Vcodkfip"ug"kpvtqfweg" wpc" gzgpek„p"rctc"ncu"
korqtvcekqpgu"fg"dkgpgu"eqp"Þpgu"fg"rtqoqek„p"eqogtekcn."ukp"xcnqt"guvkocdng"q"
hwpek„p"rwdnkekvctkc0"Fgpvtq"fg"guvg"dnqswg"fg"qrgtcekqpgu"swg"kpvtqfwegp"dkgpgu"
fgpvtq"fgn"vgttkvqtkq"fg"nc"Wpk„p"ukp"swg"gzkuvc"wp"kpvgtfiu"gokpgpvgogpvg"eqogt/
ekcn"rqftcp"ekvctug"vcodkfip"ncu"gzgpekqpgu"eqpvgpkfcu"gp"ncu"Fktgevkxcu"422819;1
EG"3; " {"Fktgevkxc"42291961EG"4 2 0"Nc" rtkogtc"guvcdngeg"nc"gzgpek„p"fgn" KXC"rctc"nqu"
rgswg‚qu"gpxqu"fg"dkgpgu"ukp"ectƒevgt"eqogtekcn"swg"pq"vgpicp"wp"xcnqt"uwrg/
tkqt"c"67"Û"4 3 0"Rqt"uw"rctvg."nc" Fktgevkxc"fg"4229"jceg" tghgtgpekc"c" nqu"dkgpgu"swg"
37" Gn"ctv0" 368030c+" fg"nc" Fktgevkxc"KXC"chktoc"swg" ÑNqu" Guvcfqu"okgodtqu" gzkoktƒp" ncu"qrgtc/
ekqpgu"ukiwkgpvguncu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu" gzrgfkfqu"q" vtcpurqtvcfqu"hwgtc"fg" nc"Eqowpkfcf." rqt"gn"
rtqrkq"xgpfgfqt"q"rqt"ewgpvc"fg"fiuvgÒ0
38" Fktgevkxc":513:31EGG"fgn"Eqpuglq."fg"4:"fg"oct¦q"fg"3;:50
39" Fktgevkxc"422;13541EG"fgn" Eqpuglq."fg" 3;"fg" qevwdtg"fg" 422;."swg" fgnkokvc"gn" ƒodkvq"fg"
crnkecek„p"fgn"ctvewnq"365."ngvtcu"d+"{"e+."fg"nc"Fktgevkxc"422813341EG"gp"nq"tghgtgpvg"c"nc"gzgpek„p"fgn"
korwguvq"uqdtg"gn"xcnqt"c‚cfkfq"fg"cniwpcu"korqtvcekqpgu"fghkpkvkxcu"fg"dkgpgu0
3:" Gzkuvg"qvtq"itcp"p¿engq"fg"dkgpgu"ew{c"korqtvcek„p"ug"fgenctc"gzgpvc"gp"guvc"Fktgevkxc."ukp"
swg"gzkuvc"wp"rcvt„p"swg"rwgfc"fgvgtokpct"gn"oqvkxqfgufg"wtpcu"hwpgtctkcu"c"nwdtkecpvgu"fg"xgjew/
nqu."dkgpgu"rctc"qticpkuoqu"dgpfihkequ."korqtvcekqpgu"fg"rtqfwevqu"citeqncu"{"fg"uwuvcpekcu"swokecu"
q"korqtvcekqpgu"swg"fgtkxgp"fg"ekgtvcu"tgncekqpgu"kpvgtpcekqpcngu0
3;" Fktgevkxc"422819;1EG"fgn"Eqpuglq."fg"7"fg"qevwdtg"fg"4228."tgncvkxc"c"ncu"htcpswkekcu"crnkec/
dngu"c"nc"korqtvcek„p"fg"ogtecpecu"qdlgvq"fg"rgswg‚qu"gpxqu"ukp"ectƒevgt"eqogtekcn" rtqxgpkgpvgu"
fg"vgtegtqu"rcugu0
42" Fktgevkxc"42291961EG"fgn"Eqpuglq." fg"42"fg" fkekgodtg"fg"4229."tgncvkxc"c"nc"htcpswkekc" fgn"
korwguvq"uqdtg"gn"xcnqt"c‚cfkfq"{"fg"nqu"korwguvqu"gurgekcngu"fg"ncu"ogtecpecu"korqtvcfcu"rqt"xkc/
lgtqu"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"vgtegtqu"rcugu0
43"Ug"jcp"fgvgevcfq"ecuqu"gp"swg"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"gpvtg"eqpuwokfqtgu"rqt"fgdclq"fgn"wodtcn"
fg"67Û"ug"jcp"wucfq"eqoq"ogfkq"rctc"gxcfkt"gn"ewornkokgpvq"fg"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"fgn"korwguvq."eqoq"
gp"gn"ecuq"fg"fgvgtokpcfcu"rƒikpcu"ygd"guvcfqwpkfgpugu"swg" rgtokvgp"c"eqpuwokfqtgu"fg"nc"WG"hklct"
fktgeekqpgu"rquvcngu"cogtkecpcu."fgufg"ncu"swg"fgurwfiu"ug"tggpxkctcp"nqu"dkgpgu"eqoq"wpc"vtcpuceek„p"
gpvtg"rctvkewnctgu0"Ukp"godctiq."nqu"guvwfkqu"owguvtcp"gn"ectƒevgt"fgurtgekcdng"fg"nc"tgecwfcek„p"rgtfk/
fc"gp"guvg"vkrq"fg"eqpfwevcu0"VCZWF142351FG1556."G["Uvwf{"hqt"vjg"Eqookuukqp."∋Ι6+%∀&6."rr0"67."8;0
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP43;
rwgfgp"kpvtqfwekt" nqu"ekwfcfcpqu"eqowpkvctkqu"fg"uwu" xkclgu" hwgtc"fg"nc"WG0"Nc"
gzgpek„p"fg"KXC"ugtƒ"fg"522Û"rqt"rgtuqpc"gp"vtcpurqtvg"vgttguvtg"{"fg"652"Û"rctc"
xkclgu"rqt"oct"{"cktg."ukp"rgtlwkekq"fg"swg"gzkuvc."eqoq"vcodkfip"qewttg"gp"gn"ecuq"
fg"nqu"gpxqu"pq"eqogtekcngu."wp"nokvg"ewcpvkvcvkxq"rctc"dkgpgu"eqoq"gn"vcdceq"q"
ncu"dgdkfcu"cneqj„nkecu0
Gn"Vvwnq"KX"fg"nc"Fktgevkxc"422;13541EG"guvcdngeg"wpc"gzgpek„p"igpgtcn"rctc"ncu"
korqtvcekqpgu"fg"guecuq"xcnqt0"Guvc"gzegrek„p"cn"itcxcogp"hwg"kpvtqfwekfc"gp"nc"
ekvcfc"Fktgevkxc"fg"3;:5"eqoq"wpc"hqtoc"fg"ukornkÞect"gn"oqxkokgpvq"vtcpuhtqp/
vgtk¦q"fg"dkgpgu"ewcpfq"c¿p" gzkuvcp"dcttgtcu"eqogtekcngu"gpvtg"Guvcfqu"okgo/
dtqu0"Gp"wp"oqogpvq"gp"gn"swg"gn"eqogtekq"gngevt„pkeq"c¿p"pq"ug"jcdcp"igpgtc/
nk¦cfq."guvc"gzgpek„p"uwrqpc"vcodkfip"wp"ogfkq"fg"gxkvct"wpc"ectic"gzegukxc"rctc"
ncu"cfwcpcu"fg"nqu"GGOO"swg"nngxctc"c"uqrqtvct"wpqu"equvgu"cfokpkuvtcvkxqu"swg"
pq"ug"xkgtcp"eqorgpucfqu"eqp"wpc"tgecwfcek„p"ceqtfg."fcfq"gn"dclq"xcnqt"fg"nqu"
dkgpgu"chgevcfqu"4 4 0"Gn"ctv0"45"fg"nc"Fktgevkxc"422;13541EG"guvcdngeg"nc"qdnkicek„p"
fg"gzkokt"fg"KXC"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"dkgpgu"eqp"xcnqt"inqdcn"pq"uwrgtkqt"c"32"
Û0"Guvc" gzgpek„p" pq" ug" crnkec" c" nqu" rtqfwevqu" cneqj„nkequ." rgthwogu" {" eqnqpkcu."
vcdceq"gp"tcoc"{"ocpwhcevwtcfq0"Fgufg"3;;:"ug"jc"guvcdngekfq"nc"rqukdknkfcf"fg"
swg"gn" xcnqt"eqpukfgtcfq"ÑguecuqÒ"c"ghgevqu" fg" nc"gzgpek„p"rwfkgtc"ugt" gngxcfq"
rqt"ecfc"GO"jcuvc"44"Û"45 0"Nc"qrek„p"fg"uwdkt"guvg"wodtcn"swg"gzkog"fg"itcxcogp"
KXC"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"jc"ukfq"crnkecfc"rqt"nc"oc{qt"rctvg"fg"GGOO."ukgpfq"nc"
qrek„p"igpgtcnk¦cfc" gn" guvcdngekokgpvq" fg" nc" dcttgtc"oƒzkoc"fg"44Û"4 6 0" Lwpvq" c"
guvc."vcodkfip"ug"rgtokvg"c"nqu"GGOO"fgekfkt"gzenwkt"fg"nc"gzgpek„p"c"nqu"dkgpgu"
swg"ugcp"korqtvcfqu"gp"gn"octeq"fg"wpc"xgpvc"rqt"eqttgurqpfgpekc."nq"swg"ko/
rnkectc"gnkokpct"nc"gzegrek„p"gp"nc"oc{qt"rctvg"fg"uwrwguvqu0"
Uk"jcegoqu"wp"cpƒnkuku"rtgnkokpct"fgufg"wp"rncpq"vg„tkeq."ukp"vgpgt"gp"ewgpvc"fc/
vqu"fg"uw"ghgevkxc"wvknk¦cek„p."guvc"gzgpek„p"uwrqpg"wpc"enctc"kphtceek„p"fgn"rtkp/
ekrkq"fg"pgwvtcnkfcf"Þuecn"47 0"Igpgtc"wpc"xgpvclc"eqorgvkvkxc"rctc"nqu"qrgtcfqtgu"
guvcdngekfqu"hwgtc"fgn" vgttkvqtkq"KXC."swg" rqftƒp" uwokpkuvtct" uwu" rtqfwevqu" ukp"
uqrqtvct"wp"itcxcogp"swg"u" fgdgtƒp"chtqpvct"ncu"gortgucu"gwtqrgcu0"Ug"cnvgtc"
nc"vqoc"fg"fgekukqpgu"geqp„okecu"vcpvq"fg"eqpuwokfqtgu"eqoq"fg"rtqfwevqtgu0"
Nqu"rtkogtqu"vgpftƒp"cnvgtpcvkxcu"fg"rtqfwevqu"uwuvkvwvkxqu"eqp"rtgekqu"fkuvkpvqu."
44" Gp"gn"guvwfkq"tgcnk¦cfq" rctc"nc"Eqokuk„p"rqt"G["ug"rwgfg"eqortqdct"gn"equvg"fg"rtqeguct"
wpc"korqtvcek„p"gp"hwpek„p"fg"uw"uwlgek„p"c"KXC"{"c"ctcpegngu"q"pq0"Cu."gn"equvg"rctc"nqu"qrgtcfqtgu"
gp"ecuq"fg"gzgpek„p"fg"KXC"{"fg"fgtgejqu"fg"korqtvcek„p."gu"fgekt."rctc"dkgpgu"fg"xcnqt"inqdcn"kphgtkqt"
c"32144"Û." ugtc"fg"4.56"Û0"Guvg"korqtvg"cuegpfgtc"c":.;8"Û" gp"gn"uwrwguvq"fg"uwlgek„p"c"KXC"{"pq" c"
ctcpegngu."dkgpgu"fg"xcnqt"uwrgtkqt"c"44"g"kphgtkqt"c"372"Û."{"c";.43"Û"rctc"nc"uwlgek„p"c"codqu"vtkdwvqu0"
Ug"rwgfg"qdugtxct."rqt"vcpvq."swg"gn"kpetgogpvq"fgn"equvg"guvƒ"tgncekqpcfq"eqp"nqu"vtƒokvgu"cfwcpgtqu"
swg"fgdgp"tgcnk¦ctug"{"swg."rqtegpvwcnogpvg."rwgfgp"uwrqpgt"wp"oc{qt"rguq"rctc"rtqfwevqu"fg"xc/
nqt"kphgtkqt0"VCZWF142351FG1556."G["Uvwf{"hqt"vjg"Eqookuukqp."∋Ι6+%∀&6."rr0"67
45"Guvc"qrek„p"jc"ukfq"cfqrvcfc"rqt"Gurc‚c"gp"gn"ctvewnq"56"fg"nc"Ng{"913;;4." fg"4:"fg" fk/
ekgodtg."fgn"Korwguvq"uqdtg"gn"Xcnqt"C‚cfkfq."gp"cfgncpvg"NKXC"q"Ng{"fgn"KXC0"
46" VCZWF142351FG1556."G["Uvwf{"hqt"vjg"Eqookuukqp."∋Ι6+%∀&6."r0":
47" Jgoqu"fghkpkfq"gn" rtkpekrkq"fg" pgwvtcnkfcf"hkuecn" eqoq"Ñgn"rtkpekrkq"lwtfkeq"rqt"gn" swg"nc"
vtkdwvcek„p"pq"fgdg"chgevct"c"nc"vqoc"fg"fgekukqpgu"geqp„okecu"swg"chtqpvgp"nqu"fkuvkpvqu"uwlgvqu"swg"
cev¿gp"gp"gn"ogtecfqÒ0"OCECTTQ"QUWPC."L0"O0."?.+(#∀3%∀Ι∀∋+0∃+Κ∃−/.∀0/0+2∀∗%/.+∃3+∃.+>Β9."Vjqouqp"
Tgwvgtu/Ctc p¦cfk."Ek¦wt"Ogpqt."4237 ."r0"790
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
442
gp"wpc" ecvgiqtc"fg"dkgpgu."nqu" fg"tgfwekfq"xcnqt."gp" nqu"swg"nc"xctkcdng"rtgekq"
uwgng"cfswktkt"wpc"korqtvcpekc"fgvgtokpcpvg0"Nqu"ugiwpfqu."rqt"uw"rctvg."rqftƒp"
xgtug"kpegpvkxcfqu"c"vtcuncfct"uwu"qrgtcekqpgu"q."cn"ogpqu."uwu"egpvtqu"fg"xgpvc"q"
fg"gpxq."c"nwictgu"hwgtc"fgn"vgttkvqtkq"fg"crnkecek„p"KXC."rctc"rqfgt"dgpgÞekctug"
fg"guvc"gzgpek„p"{"fg"fkejc"eqorgvgpekc"rtkxkngikcfc0"
Nqu"fcvqu"fgowguvtcp"guvc"rfitfkfc"fg"eqorgvkvkxkfcf"fg"ncu"gortgucu"fg"nc"WG"{"
nc"oglqt"rqukek„p"eqorgvkvkxc"fg"nqu"qrgtcfqtgu"fg"vgttkvqtkqu"vgtegtqu0"Cu."ug"jcp"
eqpuvcvcfq" etgekokgpvqu" gzrqpgpekcngu" fg" korqtvcekqpgu" fg" fgvgtokpcfqu" rtq/
fwevqu"fg"dclq"equvg"fg"rcugu"vgtegtqu."eqoq"nkdtqu."tgxkuvcu."vctlgvcu"fg"tgicnq."
gve"48 0" Qvtq" glgornq"swg"owguvtc" nqu"ghgevqu"fg" guvc" gzgpek„p"gu" gn" tgncvkxq"c"nc"
xgpvc"fg"EFu."FXFu"{"xkfgqlwgiqu"gp"gn"Tgkpq"Wpkfq0"Ncu"cwvqtkfcfgu"vtkdwvctkcu"
dtkvƒpkecu"ug"rgtecvctqp"fg"swg"nc"xgpvc"fg"guvqu"rtqfwevqu"ug"ctvkewncdc"c"vtcxfiu"
fg"uw"gpxq"fgufg"cnocegpgu"gp"ncu"Kuncu"fgn"Ecpcn."Lgtug{"{"Iwgtpug{0"Gn"rtgekq"fg"
guvqu"rtqfwevqu"ug"ocpvgpc"ukgortg"gp"gn"nokvg"fg"nc"gzgpek„p"fg"KXC"c"rgswg‚cu"
korqtvcekqpgu."qdnkicpfq"c"nqu"qrgtcfqtgu"c"fgunqecnk¦ctug"rctc"rqfgt"eqorgvkt0
Guvg"cpƒnkuku"eqpegrvwcn"fg"nc"kphtceek„p"fg"pgwvtcnkfcf"Þuecn"rwgfg"eqttqdqtctug"
eqp"nqu"tguwnvcfqu"swg"jcp"qdvgpkfq"nqu"fkuvkpvqu"guvwfkqu"uqdtg"nc"ocvgtkc"49 0"Nc"
guvkocek„p"fg"etgekokgpvq"fg"guvg"vkrq"fg"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"cuekgpfg"c"oƒu"fg"
wp"522'"gp"37"c‚qu."uk"dkgp"nqu"guegpctkqu"oƒu" rgukokuvcu"jcdnctcp"fg"ecuk"wp"
:22'"fg"kpetgogpvq"4 : 0"Ukiwkgpfq"gn"guvwfkq"eqpugtxcfqt."guvq"kornkectc"swg"gp"
4237"gn"p¿ogtq"fg"gpxqu"ceqikfqu"c"guvc"gzgpek„p"hwg"fg"366"oknnqpgu"fg"dkgpgu"
gpvtcpfq"gp"gn"ogtecfq"kpvgtpq"ukp"swgfct"itcxcfqu"rqt"KXC0"Gn"eƒnewnq"fgn"KXC"pq"
tgecwfcfq"fgdkfq"c"guvc"gzgpek„p"gu"vcodkfip"rtgqewrcpvg0"Oƒu"fg"757"oknnqpgu"
fg"gwtqu" fglcfqu"fg"kpitguct"gp" 4235." c‚q" gp"swg"nc"Wpk„p" guvcdc" kpogtuc"gp"
nc"tgekgpvg"etkuku"geqp„okec." guvkocpfq"swg"nc" ecpvkfcf"fg"4233."swg"ugtc"oƒu"
rctgekfc"c"nc"cevwcn."rqftc"jcdgt"cnecp¦cfq."gp"ncu"guvkocekqpgu"oƒu"rgukokuvcu."
ecuk";22"oknnqpgu"fg"gwtqu."eqttgurqpfkgpvgu"c"wp"xqnwogp"fg"pgiqekq"uwrgtkqt"
c"60722"oknnqpgu"fg"gwtqu0"Guvqu"fcvqu"owguvtcp"swg"ncu"fgekukqpgu"fg"eqortc"fg"
nqu"korqtvcfqtgu"eqowpkvctkqu."gp"gn"oqogpvq"gp"swg"nc"eqpvtcvcek„p"c"fkuvcpekc"
jc"tguwnvcfq"ugt"vcp"gÞec¦"{"ugpeknnc"eqoq"nc"pcekqpcn."ug"guvƒp"xkgpfq"cnvgtcfcu"
rqt"guvc"gzegrek„p"c"nc"nkdtg"eqorgvgpekc"{"nc"pgwvtcnkfcf"Þuecn0
Ukp"godctiq."lwpvq"c"nqu"fqu"itcpfgu"rtqdngocu"xkuvqu"Ïnc"kphtceek„p"fg"pgwvtc/
nkfcf"Þuecn"{"nc"rfitfkfc"tgecwfcvqtkcÏ."nc"gzgpek„p"fgn"KXC"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"
guecuq"xcnqt"rtgugpvc"wpc"vgtegtc"eqpugewgpekc"rgtpkekquc"fg"itcp"korqtvcpekc
eqpfwevcu"fg"cdwuq"{"htcwfg"4 ; 0"Pq"uqp"rqequ"nqu"GGOO"swg"jcp"fgpwpekcfq"gn"
48" VCZWF142351FG1556."G["Uvwf{"hqt"vjg"Eqookuukqp."∋Ι6+%∀&6."rr0"73"{"uu0"Gn"guvwfkq"jcdnc"eqp/
etgvcogpvg"fgn"etgekokgpvq"fgn"522'"gp"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"nkdtqu"c"Ejkpc"swg"ug"jc"fcfq"gp"Gunqxgpkc."
gn"etgekokgpvq"fg"vctlgvcu"fg"tgicnq"uwk¦cu"{"ejkpcu"gp"Cngocpkc"q"gn"kpetgogpvq"fgufg"gn"48'"cn"9:'"
gp"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"tgxkuvcu"gp"Fkpcoctec0"
49"Nqu"fcvqu"swg"xcoqu"c"rtgugpvct"c"eqpvkpwcek„p"guvƒp"gzvtcfqu"fgn"fqewogpvq"fg"vtcdclq"
fg"nc"Eqokuk„p"UYF*4238+"59;"hkpcn."∋Ι+%∀&6."{"fgn"ekvcfq"kphqtog"G["Uvwf{"hqt"vjg"Eqookuukqp."∋Ι6+%∀&6
4:" Eqoq"eqpvtcuvg."gn"etgekokgpvq"fgn"RKD"fg"nc"Wpk„p"Gwtqrgc"rctc"fkejq"rgtkqfq"fg"37"c‚qu"
hwg"fgn"72'0
4;" Gn"Vtkdwpcn"fg"Ewgpvcu"Gwtqrgq."gp"uw"Kphqtog"Gurgekcn"p³"341423;."ÑEqogtekq"gngevt„pkeq
swgfcp"rqt"tguqnxgt"owejcu"fg"ncu"fkhkewnvcfgu"fg"nc"tgecwfcek„p"fgn"KXC"{"nqu"fgtgejqu"fg"cfwcpcÒ."
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP443
cdwuq"gzkuvgpvg"fg"guvc"gzgpek„p."ctiwogpvcpfq"swg"uw"gzkuvgpekc"gorwlc"c"ncu"
gortgucu"pcekqpcngu"c"nc" fgunqecnk¦cek„p"hwgtc"fg" nc"WG."q" swg"ug"rtqfwec" wpc"
htciogpvcek„p"fg" nqu"gpxqu"rctc"rqfgt"ceqigtug"c"guvc" gzgpek„p0"Gn"ecuq"rtq/
vqvkrq"gu"gn"gzrgtkogpvcfq"rqt"nc"xgpvc"fg"tgxkuvcu"gp"Fkpcoctec0"Rgug"c"swg"ncu"
tgxkuvcu"ug"kortkocp"{"gncdqtcdcp"gp"nc"WG."gtcp"gzrqtvcfcu."nkdtgu"fg"KXC."c"ncu"
Kuncu"fg"Cncpf."gp"Pqtwgic."rctc"rquvgtkqtogpvg"ugt"tgkorqtvcfcu"dgpgÞekƒpfq/
ug"fg"nc"gzgpek„p"KXC"rqt"pq"uwrgtct"nc"dcttgtc"fg"nqu"44"Û0"
Nc" Eqokuk„p" Gwtqrgc" pq" uqnq" jc" eqpuvcvcfq" ektewpuvcpekcu" cdwukxcu."ukpq" swg"
vcodkfip" jc" fgpwpekcfq" gn" wuq" htcwfwngpvq" fg" guvc" gzgpek„p0" Nc" Eqokuk„p" jc"
cÞtocfq"swg" rtqfwevqu"fg"itcp" xcnqt"eqoq"∗∆/#&Ι1∋3∃∗"{"&/5.∃&∗"xkgpg"eqpu/
vcpvgogpvg"okpwuxcnqtcfqu"q"ocn"fguetkvqu"gp"ncu"fgenctcekqpgu"cfwcpgtcu"rctc"
rqfgt"dgpgÞekctug" fg"guvc"gzgpek„p"5 2 0" Cfgoƒu."guvc"gzgpek„p" jc"ecwucfq"vco/
dkfip"fkurctkfcfgu"gpvtg"nqu"rtqrkqu"GGOO"fgdkfq"c"nc"fkhgtgpvg"hqtoc"fg"eƒnewnq"
fgn"korqtvg"swg"fgdg"swgfct"rqt"fgdclq"fgn"nokvg."q"rqt"uw"fkhekn"eqorcvkdknk/
fcf"eqp"fgvgtokpcfqu"tgiogpgu"gurgekcngu."eqoq"gn"fg"tgectiq"fg"gswkxcngpekc"
gzkuvgpvg"gp"Gurc‚c"53 0"
Jc{"swg"vgpgt"gp"ewgpvc"swg"gn"ctvewnq"45"fg"nc"Fktgevkxc"422;13541WG"guvcdngeg"
nc"rqukdknkfcf"fg"swg"nqu"GGOO"gnkokpgp"guvc"gzgpek„p"rctc"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"
dkgpgu"gpxkcfqu"rqt"eqttgurqpfgpekc0"Guvq."c"rtkqtk."rqftc"uqnwekqpct"cniwpqu"fg"
nqu"rtkpekrcngu"rtqdngocu"eqogpvcfqu0"Guvc"hwg"nc"uqnwek„p"cfqrvcfc"rqt"gn"Tgkpq"
Wpkfq."swg" uwrtkok„" nc" gzgpek„p" rctc"gpxqu"rqt"eqttgurqpfgpekc"rtqegfgpvgu"
fg"ncu"Kuncu"fgn"Ecpcn0"Nc"eqpugewgpekc"hwg"gn"Þp"fgn"fguxq"fg"ncu"xgpvcu"c"vtcxfiu"
fg"fkejqu"vgttkvqtkqu0"Ukp" godctiq."qvtqu"kpvgpvqu"ukoknctgu"pq"vwxkgtqp"nqu"oku/
oqu"tguwnvcfqu0"Dfinikec"jk¦q"wuq"fg"nc"ekvcfc"rqukdknkfcf."gnkokpcpfq"nc"gzgpek„p"
rctc"vqfqu"nqu"gpxqu"rqt"eqttgurqpfgpekc0"Gn"tguwnvcfq"hwg"swg"nc"gortgucu"swg"
ug"dgpgÞekcdcp"fg"nc"gzgpek„p"ug"fgunqecnk¦ctqp"c"qvtqu"GGOO."qdnkicpfq"c"ncu"
cwvqtkfcfgu"dgnicu"c"tgkpvtqfwekt"nc"gzgpek„p"fg"ocpgtc"rngpc"54 0" Ukoknctgu"eqp/
enwukqpgu"ug"cnecp¦ctqp"gp"Htcpekc"55 0
Vqfqu"guvqu"oqvkxqu"jcp"nngxcfq"c"swg"gn"Eqpuglq"fg"nc"WG"jc{c"fgekfkfq"gnkok/
pct"rqt"eqorngvq"nc" gzgpek„p"fg"nqu"rtqfwevqu"fg" guecuq"xcnqt0"Gn"ctvewnq"5"fg"
nc"Fktgevkxc" 4239146771WG"5 6 "eqpÞtoc"nc"uwrtguk„p"fgn"Vvwnq"KX"fg"nc"Fktgevkxc"
422;13541EG."swg"gu"nc"swg"tgiwnc"guvc"gzgpek„p"gp"uwu"ctvu0"45"{"460"Vcn"gnkokpc/
rr0"52/56."gzrqpg"ncu"eqpenwukqpgu"fg"wp"guvwfkq"uqdtg"nc"korqtvcek„p"fg"dkgpgu"fg"guecuq"xcnqt"fqp/
fg."fg"97"korqtvcekqpgu"eqpvtqncfcu."gp"57"g"gnncu"ug"jcdc"cdwucfq"fg"fkejc"gzgpek„p0"
52" Gwtqrgcp"Eqookuukqp."2/%&+Ε1∃∃&6+=∋0∃#3∀∗∀3Χ+Β9,+)∋#+∃;%∋∆∆∃#%∃β+ν−∃∗&∀∋3∗+/30+93∗µ∃#∗."
3"fkekgodtg"4238."r0"50"
53" Xficpug"ncu"Eqpuwnvc"ÏXkpewncpvgÏ"fg"nc"FIV"X2564/3:."fg"4:"fg"oct¦q"{"X2:92/3:."fg":"fg"
hgdtgtq."{"gn"eqogpvctkq"tgcnk¦cfq"rqt"IðOG¥"CTCIðP."F0.":/#&/+,#∀5−&/#∀/6+Ο∃8∀∗&/+0∃+ΛΙ∀3∀Η3ϑ"p³"5;."
423:0
54" G["Uvwf{"hqt"vjg"Eqookuukqp."∋Ι6+%∀&6"r0"340
55" UYF"*4238+"59;"hkpcnÉ."∋Ι6+%∀&6+r0"43."gp"nc"swg"ug"chktoc"swg"nqu"rtqdngocu"fg"pq"ewornk/
okgpvq"ug"xgtƒp"kpetgogpvcfqu"uk"guvc"gzgpek„p"pq"ug"chtqpvc"fgufg"wpc"„rvkec"WG0"
56" Fktgevkxc"*WG+"423914677"fgn"Eqpuglq."fg"7"fg"fkekgodtg"fg"4239."rqt"nc" swg"ug"oqfkhkecp"
nc"Fktgevkxc"422813341EG"{"nc"Fktgevkxc"422;13541EG"gp"nq"tghgtgpvg"c"fgvgtokpcfcu"qdnkicekqpgu"tgu/
rgevq"fgn"korwguvq"uqdtg"gn"xcnqt"c‚cfkfq"rctc"ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"{"ncu"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"
dkgpgu0
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
444
ek„p"gpvtctƒ"gp"xkiqt"c"rctvkt"fg"4243"57 0"Eqoq"cÞtoc"nc"Eqokuk„p"58."gn"jgejq"fg"
gzvgpfgt"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"c"eqpuwokfqtgu"{"nc"cornkcek„p"
fgn"rnc¦q"fg"fgenctcek„p"fgn"KXC"c"wp"ogu"fgdgtƒp"gxkvct"swg"nc"gnkokpcek„p"fg"
guvc"gzgpek„p"uwrqpic"wp"kpetgogpvq"fg"ecticu"cfokpkuvtcvkxcu"swg"eqncrug"ncu"
cfwcpcu"fg"nqu"GGOO"5 9 0"Pqu" eqpitcvwncoqu" rqt" nc" tghqtoc" fg" guvc" pqtocvkxc"
swg"jc"fg"kpetgogpvct"nc"pgwvtcnkfcf"Þuecn"fgn"korwguvq"{"eqpvtkdwkt"c"gnkokpct"nc"
fguxgpvclc"eqorgvkvkxc"rctc"nqu"cigpvgu"geqp„okequ"fg"nc"WG"5: ."oƒu"vgpkgpfq"gp"
ewgpvc"nqu"rtgqewrcpvgu"fcvqu"fg"htcwfg"{"fgn"ocn"hwpekqpcokgpvq"fg"nqu"eqpvtq/
ngu"cfwcpgtqu"gngevt„pkequ"5 ; 0"Gp"gn"owpfq"fgn"eqogtekq"inqdcn"jceg"owejq"swg"
fgl„"fg" vgpgt"ugpvkfq"wpc" pqtocvkxc"swg"rtkxkngikctc"nqu" rtqfwevqu"fg"vgtegtqu"
rcugu"gp"fgvtkogpvq"fg"nqu"rtqrkqu"62 0"
57"Fcfq"swg"nc"gnkokpcek„p"fg"nc"gzgpek„p"pq"ug"xc"c"rtqfwekt"jcuvc"fkejc"hgejc."ug"jc"fg/
dkfq"cfcrvct" nc"pqtocvkxc" cfwcpgtc"rctc" swg."jcuvc" gpvqpegu"{" vgpkgpfq"gp"ewgpvc" swg"nqu" GGOO"
jcp"rqfkfq"cevwcnk¦ct"rtgxkcogpvg"uwu"ukuvgocu"cfwcpgtqu."nc"kpvtqfweek„p"fg"ogtecpecu"fg"guecuq"
xcnqt" rwgfc" ugiwkt" tgcnk¦ƒpfqug" eqoq" jc" xgpkfq" rtqfwekfipfqug0" Fg" cewgtfq" eqp" gn" ctv0" 36307" fgn"
Tgincogpvq"Fgngicfq"*WG+"423714668."fg"4:"fg"lwnkq"fg"4237."nc"fgenctcek„p"fg"vcngu"dkgpgu"rctc"uw"
fgurcejq"gp"nkdtg"rtƒevkec"ug"jceg" ogfkcpvg"uw"rtgugpvcek„p" fktgevc"gp"cfwcpc" *gz"ctv0" 35;"E„fkiq"
Cfwcpgtq"fg"nc"Wpk„p+0"Cpvg"gn"ecodkq"swg"xc"c"rtqfwektug"gp"nqu"ukuvgocu"pcekqpcngu"fg"korqtvcek„p."
gn"Tgincogpvq"Fgngicfq"*WG+" 423;13365."fg"36" fg"oct¦q"fg" 423;."jc"oqfkhkecfq" fkejq"ctv0"36307"
rtqnqpicpfq"guvc"rqukdknkfcf"jcuvc"nc"ekvcfc"hgejc"fg"42430"
58" EQO*4238+"979"hkpcn."fg"3"fg"fkekgodtg"fg"4238."Rtqrwguvc"fg"Fktgevkxc"fgn"Eqpuglq"rqt"nc"
swg"ug"oqfkhkecp"nc"Fktgevkxc"422813341EG"{"nc"Fktgevkxc"422;13541EG"gp"nq"tghgtgpvg"c"fgvgtokpcfcu"
qdnkicekqpgu"tgurgevq"fgn"korwguvq"uqdtg"gn"xcnqt"c‚cfkfq"rctc"ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"{"ncu"xgp/
vcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu0"r0"34
59" Wp"guvwfkq"fg"Eqrgpjcigp" Geqpqokeu"fg" 33"fg" qevwdtg"fg" 4239."vkvwncfq" ÑGhhgevu"qh"tg/
oqxkpi"vjg" XCV"fg" Okpkoku" qp" G/Eqoogteg"KorqtvuÒ."cfxkgtvg" fg" rqvgpekcngu" ghgevqu" rgtpkekququ"
rqt"nc" gnkokpcek„p" fg" guvc"gzgpek„p0" Eqpetgvcogpvg" chktoc"swg"ecwuctƒ" equvgu" fgurtqrqtekqpcfqu"
gp"nc"kpfwuvtkc"fg" rcswgvgtc."gp"ncu"cfwcpcu" {"gp"ncu"gortgucu"fg"xgpvcu"gngevt„pkecu."{"swg"fkejqu"
uqdtgequvgu"ugtcp"uqrqtvcfqu"rqt"nqu"eqpuwokfqtgu"hkpcngu0"Gpvgpfgoqu"swg"nc"korngogpvcek„p"fg"
ukuvgocu"kphqtoƒvkequ"swg"c{wfgp"c"ncu"cfwcpcu"fg"nqu"GGOO"c"vtcvct"nc"fgenctcek„p"fg"nqu"rtqfwevqu"
swg."eqoq"xgtgoqu."pq"vgpftƒp"swg"nkswkfct"gn"korwguvq"gp"gn"oqogpvq"fg"nc"korqtvcek„p."ukpq"rqu/
vgtkqtogpvg"gp"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec."gu"guvtkevcogpvg"pgeguctkq"rctc"swg"gn"ukuvgoc"pq"ug"eqncrug0"
5:" Nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"jc"chktocfq"swg"nc"gnkokpcek„p"fg"guvc"gzgpek„p"rwgfg"vgpgt"wp"ko/
rcevq"kpkekcn"gp"hqtoc"fg"kpetgogpvq"fg"rtgekqu"rgtq"swg."gp"gn"nctiq"rnc¦q."fgdgtc"fct"nwict"c"wpc"
tgfweek„p"fg"rtgekqu"fgdkfq" cn"kpetgogpvq"fg" eqorgvgpekc"gp"nqu" ugevqtgu"fg"rtqfwevqu"fg" guecuq"
xcnqt0"UYF"*4238+"59;"hkpcn."∋Ι6+%∀&6ϑ"rr0"6;/720
5;" Tguwnvcp"nncocvkxcu"ncu"eqpenwukqpgu" fgn"Vtkdwpcn"fg"Ewgpvcu" Gwtqrgq"tgncvkxcu"cn"ocn" hwp/
ekqpcokgpvq"fg" nqu" ukuvgocu"gngevt„pkequ" fg" fgurcejq"cfwcpgtq" fg" nqu"GGOO"swg" jcp" guvwfkcfq0"
Eqpenw{g"swg"rgtokvgp"tgcnk¦ct"fgenctcekqpgu"fg"korqtvcek„p"fqpfg"ug"uqnkekvg"nc"htcpswkekc"cfwcpgtc"
rctc"gpxqu"D4E"kpenwuq"ewcpfq"gn"xcnqt"kpvtpugeq"uwrgtg"nqu"372"Û."q"ewcpfq"ugcp"rtqfwevqu"cneqj„/
nkequ0"Kphqtog"Gurgekcn"p³"341423;."∋Ι6+%∀&0."rr0"54/550"
62" Uk"dkgp"uqoqu"eqpuekgpvgu"fg"swg"nc"rgtukuvgpekc"fg"cniwpcu"gzgpekqpgu."eqoq"nc"fg"gpxqu"
gpvtg"rctvkewnctgu"fg" ogpqu"fg" 67"Û." rwgfg"ugiwkt" ukgpfq"wvknk¦cfc" fg"hqtoc" htcwfwngpvc."nqu" fcvqu"
owguvtcp"swg"guvcoqu" cpvg"wpc" ewguvk„p"tgukfwcn0"Gn"kphqtog"fg" G["ekvcfq" nq"ecnkhkec" fg"ukvwcekqpgu"
Ñcpgef„vkecuÒ."gp"ncu"swg"ncu"xgpvcu"fg"rtqfwevqu"guvcfqwpkfgpugu"ug"gpxcp"c"fqokeknkqu"rctvkewnctgu"
rctc"swg."fgufg"gnnqu."ug"gpxgp"eqoq"korqtvcekqpgu"gpvtg"rctvkewnctgu0"Vcodkfip"ug"fguvcec"nc"gzkuvgp/
ekc"fg"htcwfg"fg"fgvgtokpcfcu"gortgucu"Ejkpcu"swg"iguvkqpcp"xgpvcu"eqoq"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"guecuq"
xcnqt"rgtq"nqu"dkgpgu"ug"gpewgpvtcp"{c"gp"cnocegpgu"fgn"Tgkpq"Wpkfq0"Guvqu"vkrqu"fg"htcwfg"pq"ug"fg/
dgp"c"nc"gzkuvgpekc"fg"nc"gzgpek„p"fg"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"guecuq"xcnqt."ukpq"fktgevcogpvg"c"nc"qewnvcek„p"
q"pq"fgenctcek„p"fgn"korwguvq."fgdkgpfq"ugt"vtcvcfqu"eqoq"vcn0"G["Uvwf{"hqt"vjg"Eqookuukqp."∋Ι6+%∀&6"
r0"8;0
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP445
50" NC"TGXQNWEKðP"FG"NCU"KORQTVCEKQPGU"C"EQPUWOKFQTGU
5030" W蚤"蚤派嚢琶巴"納嚢之納巴"能覗把巴蚤能廼農嚢"罵"派蚤"之乃覗廼能巴"埜嚢"之巴蚤悩能濃派覇乃之能這蚤"埜嚢農"KXC
Gn"ctv0" 3:" fg"nc" NKXC." vtcurqpkgpfq" gn" ctv0" 52" FKXC." guvcdngeg"eqoq" jgejq" ko/
rqpkdng"nc"kpvtqfweek„p"gp"gn"vgttkvqtkq"fg"nc"WG"fg"dkgpgu"swg"pq"guvfip"gp"nkdtg"
rtƒevkec"{" fg" cswgnnqu"rtqegfgpvgu" fg" vgtegtqu" vgttkvqtkqu" fgpvtq" fgn" vgttkv qtkq"
cfwcpgtq"fg"nc"Wpk„p"6 3 0"C"fkhgtgpekc"fg"ncu"cfswkukekqpgu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu."swg"
uqnq"rwgfgp"ugt"tgcnk¦cfcu"rqt"gortguctkqu"q"rtqhgukqpcngu."gn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"fg"
ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"gu"nc"rgtuqpc"swg"tgcnk¦c"nc"korqtvcek„p"*ctv0":80Wpq"NKXC+."gu"
fgekt."pq"ug"fkhgtgpekc"gp"hwpek„p"fg"nc"pcvwtcng¦c"lwtfkec"fg"nc"rgtuqpc"swg"tgcnk/
¦c"gn"jgejq"korqpkdng0"Cn"eqpvtctkq"fg"nq"swg"qewttg"gp"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"kpvgtkqtgu"
q"gp"ncu"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"rtqegfgpvgu"fg"gortguctkqu"{"rtqhgukqpcngu"fg"qvtqu"
GGOO."nqu"rctvkewnctgu"swg"tgcnkegp"wpc"korqtvcek„p"xcp"c"ugt"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"fgn"
korwguvq."eqp"kpfgrgpfgpekc"fg"swg"rwgfcp"gpectict"c"wp"tgrtgugpvcpvg"cfwc/
pgtq"swg"ewornc"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"ctcpegnctkcu"{"fg"KXC"eqttgurqpfkgpvgu0"
Ukp"godctiq."c"rctvkt"fg" 4243"nc"tgiwncek„p"fg" ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"xc"c" uwhtkt"wp"
itcp"ecodkq."rwgu"ug"jcp"kpvtqfwekfq"oqfkÞecekqpgu"swg"rwgfgp"jcegt"swg"guvg"
jgejq"korqpkdng"fglg"fg"crnkectug"c"wpc"ugtkg"fg"dkgpgu"kpvtqfwekfqu"gp"gn"vgttk/
vqtkq"KXC0"Nc"Fktgevkxc"423914677"guvcdngeg"wp"pwgxq"jgejq"korqpkdng"fgpqok/
pcfq"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg" dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"fg"vgtegtqu"vgttkvqtkqu"q" vgtegtqu"
rcugu"6 4 0" Rgug" c" vtcvctug"fg" wpc" kpvtqfweek„p" fg" dkgpgu"fgpvtq"fgufg" rcugu" q"
vgttkvqtkqu"vgtegtqu."guvg"pwgxq"eqpegrvq"ug"gpewcftc"fgpvtq"fgn"Ecrvwnq"tgncvkxq"
c"ncu"gpvtgic"fg" dkgpgu."eqpetgvcogpvg"gp" gn"ctv0"360604"fg"nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC0"Uwu"
gngogpvqu"ectcevgtuvkequ"uqp"nqu"swg"ukiwgp<
Ð" "Ug"vtcvc"fg"wp"ÑuwokpkuvtqÒ"fg"dkgpgu."fgdkgpfq"gpvgpfgtug"eqoq"wpc"gpvtg/
ic"fg"dkgpgu"gp"gn"ugpvkfq"fgn"rtkogt"crctvcfq"fgn"ctv0"36"FKXC."gu"fgekt."wpc"
vtcpuokuk„p"fgn"rqfgt"fg"fkurqukek„p"uqdtg"wp"dkgp"eqtrqtcn0"Fkejc"vtcpu/
okuk„p."rctc"swg"ug"eqpukfgtg"gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu"fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"ctv0"403"
FKXC."fgdg"ugt"tgcnk¦cfc"rqt"wp"gortguctkq"q"rtqhgukqpcn"gp"gn"glgtekekq"fg"
uw"cevkxkfcf"geqp„okec0
63" Fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"ctv0"4;"fgn"Vtcvcfq"fg"Hwpekqpcokgpvq"fg"nc"Wpk„p" Gwtqrgc"*VHWG+."nqu"
dkgpgu"gp" nkdtg"rtƒevkec"uqp" cswgnnqu" rtqegfgpvgu"fg" vgtegtqu"rcugu"tgurgevq" fg"nqu" swg" ug"jc{cp"
ewornkfq"ncu" hqtocnkfcfgu"fg" korqtvcek„p" gp"cfwcpc0"Jc{" swg"tgeqtfct" swg."c" ghgevqu" fgn"KXC." ncu"
korqtvcekqpgu"vcodkfip"kornkecp"nc"kpvtqfweek„p"fg"dkgpgu"gp"gn"vgttkvqtkq"fg"crnkecek„p"fgn"korwguvq"
swg"rtqxgpicp"fg"wpc"rctvg"fg"wp"GO"swg"pq"guvfi"fgpvtq"fgn"vgttkvqtkq"cfwcpgtq"fg"nc"Wpk„p"ÏEgwvc"
{"OgnknncÏ."{"vcodkfip"fg"wp"nwict"fgpvtq"fg"nc"Wpk„p"Cfwcpgtc."fgpqokpcfq"vgttkvqtkq"vgtegtq."eqoq"
rqt"gl0"ncu"Kuncu"Ecpctkcu0"
64" Uk"dkgp"ug" vtcvc"fg" wpc"gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu"{"pq"fg" wpc"korqtvcek„p."nc"Eqokuk„p" Gwtqrgc."
gp"uw" EQO*423:+" :43" hkpcn." fg" 33" fg" fkekgodtg"fg" 423:." fgpqokpc" ukornkhkecfcogpvg" cn" tfiikogp"
gurgekcn"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"guvcu"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"eqoq"Ñtfiikogp"fg"ko/
rqtvcek„pÒ"*ctv0"79"5∀∗+0"Rqt"gnnq."gp"cfgncpvg"pqu"tghgtktgoqu"c"guvg"jgejq"korqpkdng"kpfkuvkpvcogpvg"
eqoq"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E"q"eqoq"xgpvcu"D4E"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu0"Gn"vfitokpq"cpinqucl„p"D4E"gu"gn"
cet„pkoq"tgncvkxq"c"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"5−∗∀3∃∗∗+&∋+%∋3∗−∆∃#∗."gu"fgekt."fg"gortguctkqu"c"eqpuwokfqtgu0
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
446
Ð" "Nqu"dkgpgu" fgdgp"ugt"gpxkcfqu"fgufg"wp" vgttkvqtkq" vgtegtq"q" wp" vgtegt"rcu"
eqp"fguvkpq"c"wp"enkgpvg"ukvwcfq"gp"wp"GO0"Nc"gzrgfkek„p"fgdg"ugt"tgcnk¦cfc"
rqt"gn"rtqxggfqt"q" rqt" uw"ewgpvc" q." eqoq"opkoq." swg" gn" xgpfgfqt"jc{c"
kpvgtxgpkfq"gp" gnnc"fg"ocpgtc" kpfktgevc0"Uqnq"ug" jceg"tghgtgpekc"c"nc"nqecnk/
¦cek„p"kpkekcn"{"Þpcn"fg"nqu"dkgpgu."rgtq"pq"c"nc"wdkecek„p"fgn"rtqxggfqt."rqt"
nq"swg"guvcoqu"cpvg"wp"jgejq"korqpkdng"swg"rwgfg"tgcnk¦ct"vcpvq"wp"uwlgvq"
rcukxq"guvcdngekfq"eqoq"pq"guvcdngekfq"gp"gn"vgttkvqtkq"KXC0
Ð" "Gn"fguvkpcvctkq"fg"nc"gpvtgic"fgdg"ugt"wp"eqpuwokfqt"Þpcn"Ïukp"eqpfkek„p"fg"
uwlgvq"rcukxqÏ."q"wp"uwlgvq"rcukxq"q"rgtuqpc"lwtfkec"ukp"eqpfkek„p"fg"uwlgvq"
rcukxq"ewcpfq"uwu"cfswkukekqpgu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"fg"dkgpgu"pq"guvfip"uwlg/
vcu"fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"ctv0"503"FKXC"65 0"
Ð" "Ug"gzenw{g"gzrtgucogpvg"fg"guvg"eqpegrvq"ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"ogfkqu"fg"vtcpu/
rqtvg"pwgxqu"{"nqu"dkgpgu"gpvtgicfqu"rtgxkq"oqpvclg"q"kpuvcncek„p0
Eqoq"ug"rwgfg"qdugtxct."nc"glgewek„p"fg"guvg"jgejq"korqpkdng"vcodkfip"kornkectc"nc"
tgcnk¦cek„p"fg"wpc"korqtvcek„p."fcfq"swg"ug"guvƒp"kpvtqfwekgpfq"gp"gn"vgttkvqtkq"fg"
crnkecek„p"fgn"korwguvq"dkgpgu"fg"vgtegtqu"vgttkvqtkqu"q"rcugu0"Ncu"tgincu"fg"nqecnk¦c/
ek„p"fg"nc"pwgxc"gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu"{"nc"etgcek„p"fg"wpc"gzgpek„p"gurgeÞec"korgfk/
tƒp"swg"ug"rtqfw¦ec"wpc"fqdng"korqukek„p"fgn"korwguvq"gp"wpc"okuoc"vtcpuceek„p0
Gu"pgeguctkq"rtqhwpfk¦ct"oƒu"gp"gn"tgswkukvq"fg"nc"kpvgtxgpek„p"fgn"rtqxggfqt"gp"
gn"vtcpurqtvg"fgn"dkgp0"Nc"pqtoc"eqpvgornc"fkuvkpvqu"itcfqu"fg"kpvgtxgpek„p"fgn"
xgpfgfqt"gp"fkejc"gzrgfkek„p."fgufg"nc"vqvcn" qticpk¦cek„p"fg" guvc"rqt"uw"rctvg"
jcuvc"uw"kpvgtxgpek„p"¿pkecogpvg"fg"ocpgtc"kpfktgevc0"Ukp"godctiq."pq"ug"rtq/
rqtekqpc"gzrnkecek„p"cniwpc"uqdtg"swfi"fgdg"gpvgpfgtug"rqt"fkejc"rctvkekrcek„p"
kpfktgevc0"Gn" Eqokvfi"KXC."gp" uw" tgwpk„p"p³"326."nqu" fcu" 6"{"7"fg" lwpkq" fg"4237."
crtqd„"wpcu"fktgevtkegu"uqdtg"gn"oqfq"gp"swg"fgdgtc"kpvgtrtgvctug"guvg"eqpegr/
vq0"C"Þpcngu"fg"423:."nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"jc"rncpvgcfq"wpc"tghqtoc"fgn"Tginc/
ogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"4:414233"fqpfg"cÞtoc"nc"pgegukfcf"fg"fgÞpkt"guvg"eqpegrvq"
fg"kpvgtxgpek„p"kpfktgevc"{."rctc"gnnq."rtqrqpg" kpvtqfwekt"vcngu"fktgevtkegu" gp"wp"
pwgxq"ctv0"7"5∀∗" fgn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"6 6 0" Guvc"kpkekcvkxc"jc"ukfq" crtqdcfc"
rqt"gn" Eqpuglq"fg"nc" Wpk„p"gp"nc"tgwpk„p" fgn"GEQHKP"fg" 34"fg"oct¦q"fg" 423;."
swg"swgfc" c" nc" gurgtc" fg"nqu"fkevƒogpgu"fgn"Eqokvfi"Geqp„okeq" {" Uqekcn" {" fgn"
Rctncogpvq"Gwtqrgq"rctc"rqfgt"ugt"crtqdcfc"fg"ocpgtc"fgÞpkvkxc"6 7 0
65" Gpvgpfgoqu"swg"ug"tghkgtg"cn"crctvcfq"d"fg"fkejq"ctv0"503."{c"swg"gn"crctvcfq"fgenctc"nc"pq"
uwlgek„p"cn"KXC"fg"fgvgtokpcfcu"qrgtcekqpgu"pq"gp"hwpek„p"fgn"cfswktgpvg"ukpq"fg"nc"vtcpuceek„p"gu/
rgehkec0"Cu."ug"gpvgpfgtƒp"swg"rwgfgp"ugt"fguvkpcvctkqu"fg"guvg"jgejq"korqpkdng"nqu"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"
q"rgtuqpcu"lwtfkecu"swg"pq"nq"ugcp"swg"guvfip"ceqikfqu"cn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"fg"citkewnvwtc."icpcfgtc"
{"rguec"{"cswgnnqu"swg"tgcnk¦cp"gzenwukxcogpvg"qrgtcekqpgu"swg"pq"fcp"fgtgejq"c"fgfweek„p"fgn"KXC"
uqrqtvcfq0"Jc{" swg"vgpgt" gp"ewgpvc" swg"ncu" cfswkukekqpgu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu" pq"uwlgvcu" c"KXC"guvƒp"
gzrtgucogpvg"nkokvcfcu"cn"korqtvg"fg"320222Û."{"swg"rcucfq"fkejq"wodtcn"vcpvq"nqu" uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"
eqoq"ncu"rgtuqpcu" lwtfkecu"swg" pq"nq"ugcp"{"swg" eworncp"ncu" cpvgtkqtgu"eqpfkekqpgu" rcuctƒp"c"xgt"
uwlgvcu"c" KXC"uwu"cfswkukekqpgu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu." fgdkgpfq"guvct" kfgpvkhkecfcu" eqp"wp" PKH/KXC"*ctv0"
436030d+"{"fglcpfq"fg"rqfgt"ugt"fguvkpcvctkqu"fg"guvcu"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu0
66" EQO*423:+":43"hkpcn."fg"33"fg"fkekgodtg"fg"423:."Rtqrwguvc"fg"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"
fgn"Eqpuglq"rqt"gn"swg"ug"oqfkhkec"gn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"*WG+"p0³"4:4142330"
67" Vcpvq"nc"EQO*423:+":43"hkpcn"eqoq"nc"EQO*423:+":3;"hkpcn."codcu"fg"33"fg"fkekgodtg"fg"
423:."swg"rtqrqpgp" tghqtoct."tgurgevkxcogpvg."gn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"4:414233"{"nc"Fktgevkxc"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP447
Ug"hqtowncp"ewcvtq"rqukdngu"ukvwcekqpgu"gp"swg"ug"eqpukfgtc"ewornkfq"gn"tgswk/
ukvq"fg"nc"rctvkekrcek„p"gp"gn"vtcpurqtvgEwcpfq"gn" rtqxggfqt"uwdeqpvtcvg" gn"
vtcpurqtvg"c"wp"vgtegtq"swg"ugc"gn"swg"tgcnkeg"nc"gpvtgic"hukec"cn"enkgpvg="d+"ewcpfq"
ugc"wp"vgtegtq"gn"swg"ug"gpectiwg"fg"nc"gzrgfkek„p"rgtq"gn"rtqxggfqt"cuwoc"vqfc"
q"rctvg"fg"nc"tgurqpucdknkfcf"rqt"nc"gpvtgic"hukec"fg"nqu"rtqfwevqu"cn"enkgpvg="e+"
ewcpfq"gn"rtqxggfqt"hcevwtg"{"eqdtg"cn"enkgpvg"ncu"vcucu"fg"vtcpurqtvg"{"ncu"tgokvc"
rquvgtkqtogpvg"cn" vgtegtq" swg" qticpkeg" nc" gzrgfkek„p=" f+" Ñewcpfq"gn" rtqxggfqt"
eqpvtkdw{c"rqt"ewcnswkgt"ogfkq"c"nqu"ugtxkekqu"fg"gpvtgic"fg"wp"vgtegtq"cn"enkgpvg."
rqpic"gp"eqpvcevq"cn"enkgpvg"{"cn"vgtegtq"q"hceknkvg"fg"ewcnswkgt"qvtc"hqtoc"cn"vgt/
egtq"nc"kphqtocek„p"pgeguctkc"rctc"nc"gpvtgic"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"cn"eqpuwokfqtÒ0"
Gn"rƒttchq"Þpcn"fg"guvg"ctvewnq"rtqrwguvq"fglc"enctc"ewƒn"xc"c"ugt"gn"¿pkeq"uwrwguvq"
gp"swg"pq"ug"xc"c"eqpukfgtct"swg"gzkuvc"kpvgtxgpek„p"kpfktgevc<"ewcpfq"gn"enkgpvg"
vtcpurqtvg"fin"okuoq"nqu"dkgpgu"w"qticpkeg"nc"gpvtgic"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"eqp"wp"vgtegtq"
{"gn"rtqxggfqt"pq"kpvgtxgpic"pk"eqpvtkdw{c"fg"pkpiwpc"ocpgtc"gp"nc"qticpk¦cek„p"
fg"nc"gzrgfkek„p0"Ecdg" rncpvgctug"uk"gp" wpc"korqtvcek„p"D4E" ceqtfcfc"c"vtcxfiu"
fg"kpvgtpgv."fg"cewgtfq"eqp"nc"qrek„p"f+."dcuvctc"eqp"swg"gn"rtqxggfqt."wpc"xg¦"
ug"jc{c"eqpenwkfq"nc" qrgtcek„p." tgfktkikgtc" c" wpc" rcpvcnnc" fqpfg" ug" rgtokvkgtc"
ceegfgt"cn"enkgpvg"c"gpncegu"c"ncu"ygdu"fg"ncu"gortgucu"fg"vtcpurqtvg"q"ogpuclgtc"
swg"rwgfcp"tgcnk¦ct"nc"gzrgfkek„p0"Gpvgpfgoqu"swg"gpvtctc"fgpvtq"fg"nc"rwguvc"
gp"eqpvcevq"fg"ncu"rctvgu."ukgpfq"uw"kpvgtxgpek„p" kpfktgevc0" Nc"cornkvwf"fg" nqu"
vfitokpqu"fg"Ñrwguvc"gp"eqpvcevqÒ"q"fg"eqpvtkdwek„p"Ñrqt"ewcnswkgt"ogfkqÒ"jceg"
swg"ug" gzenw{c"nc"crnkecek„p" fg"guvqu"jgejqu" korqpkdngu"¿pkecogpvg"ewcpfq" gn"
vtcpurqtvg"ug"qticpkeg"fg"ocpgtc"kpfgrgpfkgpvg"{"eqorngvc"rqt"gn"cfswktgpvg0"
5040" T嚢濃農乃杷"埜嚢"農巴之乃農能芭乃之能這蚤"埜嚢"農乃杷"琶嚢蚤波乃杷"乃"埜能杷波乃蚤之能乃"埜嚢"廼能嚢蚤嚢杷"
能覗把巴覇波乃埜巴杷"罵"杷派"之巴覗把乃波能廼能農能埜乃埜"之巴蚤"嚢農"納嚢之納巴"能覗把巴蚤能廼農嚢"埜嚢"
能覗把巴覇波乃之能巴蚤嚢杷
Nc"etgcek„p"fg"wp"pwgxq"vkrq"fg"gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu"swg"ug"crnkswg"c"ncu"korqtvc/
ekqpgu"D4E"fgdc"guvct"ceqorc‚cfq"fg"nc"kpvtqfweek„p"fg"tgincu"fg"nqecnk¦cek„p"
gurgeÞecu"rctc"guvcu"qrgtcekqpgu0"Jc{"swg"vgpgt"gp"ewgpvc"swg"nc"crctkek„p"fg"
guvcu"xgpvcu" c" fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"pq"jc"uwrwguvq" wpc" gnkokpcek„p"
fgn"jgejq"korqpkdng"ÑkorqtvcekqpguÒ"gp"gn"korwguvq0"Rqt"gnnq."vtcvctgoqu"eqplwp/
vcogpvg"ncu"pwgxcu"tgincu"fg"nqecnk¦cek„p"eqp"nqu"ogecpkuoqu"swg"ug"kpvtqfwegp"
KXC."jcp"ukfq"vtcvcfqu"rqt"gn"Eqpuglq"gp"fkejc"tgwpk„p"fg"34"fg"oct¦q"fg"423;."jcdkgpfq"crtqdcfq"
nc"oc{qt"rctvg"fg"nqu"rncpvgcokgpvqu"fg" nc"Eqokuk„p" gp"gn" Fqewogpvq"GEQHKP" 499."UV" 94671423;."
fg":"fg"oct¦q"fg"423;0"Eqoq"xgtgoqu."ug" cxcp¦c"pqvcdngogpvg"gp"cswgnnqu"curgevqu"gp"nqu"swg"nc"
pqtocvkxc"crtqdcfc"c"hkpcngu"fg"4239"jcdc"fglcfq"oƒu"fwfcu."eqoq"guvg"eqpegrvq"fg"kpvgtxgpek„p"
ÑkpfktgevcÒ"gp"gn"vtcpurqtvg"cu"eqoq"nc"oc{qt"rctvg"fg"ncu"ewguvkqpgu"tgncvkxcu"c"nc"kpvgtxgpek„p"fg"ncu"
kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"gp"ncu"xgpvcu"D4E"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu0"Guvc"tghqto c"tgu rqpfg"c"n cu"fwfcu"gz/
rtgucfcu"rqt"gn"rtqrkq"Eqpuglq."gp"nc"tgwpk„p"fgn"GEQHKP"fg"52"fg"pqxkgodtg"fg"423:."Fqewogpvq"p³"
;;:."UV"369;813139."fqpfg"chkto„"swg."fg"pq"rqfgtug"cfqrvct"ncu"ogfkfcu"fg"fgucttqnnq"pgeguctkcu"
rctc"korngogpvct"gn"tfiikogp"fg" korqtvcekqpgu"D4E"{" ncu"fkurqukekqpgu"uqdtg"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"
cpvgu"fg"4243."ug" crnc¦ctc"vqvcn"q" rctekcnogpvg"guvc"pqtocvkxc0"Uk"dkgp" ncu"pqtocu"eqogpvcfcu" c¿p"
pq"jcp"ukfq"qdlgvq"fg"crtqdcek„p"fghkpkvkxc."guvwfkctgoqu"cswgnncu"ewguvkqpgu"swg"rctgegp"cnecp¦ct"
oc{qt"eqpugpuq"{"xgtgoqu"uwu"kornkecekqpgu0"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
448
gp"nc"pqtocvkxc"KXC"rctc"gxkvct"nc"fqdng"vtkdwvcek„p0"Tgeqtfgoqu"swg"ncu"korqt/
vcekqpgu."fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"ctv0"82"FKXC."ug"gpvgpfgtƒp"ghgevwcfcu"gp"gn"GO"rqt"
gn"swg"ug"kpvtqfw¦ec"gn"dkgp"gp"gn"vgttkvqtkq"KXC0"
Ukp"godctiq."fcfq"swg"ncu"pwgxcu"xgpvcu"D4E"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"uqp"eqpukfg/
tcfcu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"fgdgoqu"cvgpfgt"c"nc"wdkecek„p"fg"guvcu"qrgtcekqpgu0"
Nc"tginc"igpgtcn."guvcdngekfc"gp"gn"ctv0"54"FKXC."gu"swg"wp"uwokpkuvtq"fg"dkgpgu"
qdlgvq"fg"vtcpurqtvg" ug" gpvgpfgtƒ"tgcnk¦cfq"gp"gn" nwict" fgufg" gn"swg"rctvc" nc"
gzrgfkek„p."gu"fgekt."vtkdwvctƒ"gp"qtkigp0"Ukp"godctiq."gn"ugiwpfq"rƒttchq"fgn"rtq/
rkq"ctv0"54"FKXC"guvcdngeg"wpc"gzegrek„p"tgncvkxc"c"ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"ewcpfq"
gn"kpkekq"fgn"vtcpurqtvg"ug"gpewgpvtg"gp"wp"rcu"q"vgttkvqtkq"vgtegtq."gu"fgekt."rctc"
gpvtgicu"swg"ukicp"c"wpc" korqtvcek„p0" Gp" vcn"ecuq."ewcpfq"nc" korqtvcek„p" ugc"
tgcnk¦cfc"rqt"gn" rtqxggfqt."swg"ugtƒ"eqpukfgtcfq"uwlgvq"rcukxq"fg"nc"okuoc"Ï∃Υ"
ctv0"423"FKXCÏ."nc"uwdukiwkgpvg"gpvtgic"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"swg"gn"xgpfgfqt"tgcnkeg"c"nqu"
enkgpvgu"Ïq"c"rtqxggfqtgu"uwegukxqu"swg"rquvgtkqtogpvg"gpvtgiwgp"cn"fguvkpcvc/
tkq"ÞpcnÏ"ug"gpvgpfgtƒ"tgcnk¦cfc"gp"gn"GO"fg"korqtvcek„p."eqp"kpfgrgpfgpekc"fg"
nc"wdkecek„p"fg"nqu"eqortcfqtgu0"
C"rctvkt" fg" 4243." gn" ctv0" 55" fg" nc" Fktgevkxc"KXC"cndgtictƒ" fqu" pwgxcu" tgincu" fg"
nqecnk¦cek„p"fg"ncu"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu."fkhgtgpekcpfq"gp"hwp/
ek„p"fg"uk"gn" GO"fg"fguvkpq"fgn"vtcpurqtvg"gu"gn"okuoq"gp"gn"swg" ug"rtqfweg"nc"
kpvtqfweek„p"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"gp"gn"vgttkvqtkq"KXC"q"pq"6 8 0"Gp"gn"ecuq"fg"swg"gn"vtcpu/
rqtvg"fg" nc"xgpvc"c"fkuvcpekc"fg" dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"Þpcnkeg"gp"gn"okuoq" Guvcfq"
okgodtq"gp"gn"swg"ug"rtqfweg"nc"korqtvcek„p"fg"nqu"okuoqu."gn"hwvwtq"ctv0"550e+"
kpvtqfweg"wpc"pwgxc"xctkcpvg0"Guvcdngeg"swg"nc"nqecnk¦cek„p"fg"fkejc"korqtvcek„p"
D4E"ugtƒ"gn"GO"fg"fguvkpq"fgn"vtcpurqtvg"ukgortg"swg"gn"KXC"fg"fkejc"gpvtgic"fg"
dkgpgu"ug"fgenctg"eqphqtog"cn"pwgxq"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"swg"ug"
etgctƒ"rctc"guvg"vkrq"fg"qrgtcekqpgu"69 0"Cu."uk"nc"korqtvcek„p"D4E"ug"fgenctc"gp"nc"
xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"eqttgurqpfkgpvg"vgpftcoqu"fqu"qrgtcekqpgu"uwlgvcu"c"KXC"gp"gn"
okuoq"GOxgpvc"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"{"wpc"korqtvcek„p0"Rctc"
gxkvct"swg"ug"rtqfw¦ec"guvc"fqdng"vtkdwvcek„p"ug"kpvtqfweg"wpc"tginc"swg"hwpfc/
ogpvc"vqfq"gn"pwgxq"ukuvgoc"eqpuvtwkfqug"fgenctcp"gzgpvcu"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"
fg"dkgpgu" swg"jc{cp"fcfq"nwict" c"wpc"xgpvc"c" fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"
ukgortg"swg"ncu"ugiwpfcu"jc{cp"ukfq"fgenctcfcu"eqphqtog"cn"pwgxq"tfiikogp"fg"
xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E"6: 0"
Rctc" ceqigtug" c" nc"gzgpek„p" c" nc"korqtvcek„p"jc" fg" cetgfkvctug" cpvg"nc"cfwcpc"
fgn"GO"fg"gpvtcfc"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"nc"wvknk¦cek„p"fg"guvg"tfiikogp"gurgekcn0"Rctc"gnnq."
fgdgtƒ"hceknkvctug"c"fkejc"cfwcpc."c"oƒu"vctfct"ewcpfq"ug"rtgugpvg"nc"fgenctcek„p"
fg"korqtvcek„p."gn"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"gurgekcn"swg"ug"jc{c"cukipcfq"c"nqu"
uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"swg"ug"fgp"fg"cnvc"gp"gn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"fg"xgpvcu"D4E"fg"dkgpgu"
68" Pq"ug"crnkectƒp"guvcu"tgincu"fg"nqecnk¦cek„p"c"ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"tgeqikfcu"gp"gn"ctv0"57"
FKXC."swg"vcodkfip"ugtƒ"oqfkhkecfc"c"rctvkt"fg"4243."{"swg"cnwfg"c"nqu"dkgpgu"fg"qecuk„p."qdlgvqu"fg"
ctvg."eqngeek„p"q"cpvki¯gfcfgu"{"c"nqu"ogfkqu"fg"vtcpurqtvg"fg"qecuk„p0"
69" Nc"vgtokpqnqic"cpinquclqpc"rctc"fgpqokpct"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"gu"∋3∃;∗&∋Ι;∗1∋Ι."gp"cfg/
ncpvg"QUU0
6:"Hwvwtq"ctv0"365030e05∀∗+"FKXC."gp"xkiqt"c"rctvkt"fg"42430"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP449
korqtvcfqu"q"c"nqu"kpvgtogfkctkqu"swg"cev¿gp"rqt"uw"ewgpvc"6; 0"Rqt"vcpvq."crqtvcp/
fq"gn"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"gurgeÞeq"fg"guvc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"nc"korqtvcek„p"
guvctƒ"gzgpvc"{"nc"¿pkec"qrgtcek„p"uwlgvc"{"pq"gzgpvc"ugtƒ"nc"xgpvc"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"
dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu." swg"ug"nqecnk¦ctƒ" gp"gn"okuoq"GO"fqpfg" cecdc"gn"vtcpurqt/
vg"{"ug"tgcnk¦c"nc"korqtvcek„p0" Guvg" ukuvgoc" rtgugpvc" korqtvcpvgu" xgpvclcu" rctc"
rtqxggfqt"{" enkgpvg0" Rctc"gn"rtkogtq."rqtswg"uqnq"gzkuvktƒ"wpc" qrgtcek„p" rqt" nc"
swg"fgdgtƒ"nkswkfctug"gn"korwguvq."swg"ugtƒ"fgenctcfc"rquvgtkqtogpvg"gp"gn"QUU."
rwfkgpfq"ceqigtug" gn"gpxq"c" wp")/∗&;/%π+gp" cfwcpc"cn"pq" vgpgt"swg"rcict"gn"
KXC"c"nc"korqtvcek„p"Ï{."eqoq"xgtgoqu."vcorqeq"ctcpegngu"7 2 Ï0"Guvq"ng"rgtokvktƒ."
cfgoƒu."fkurqpgt"fgn"KXC"jcuvc"gn"Þp"fgn"rgtkqfq"fg"nkswkfcek„p"fg"nc"xgpvcpknnc"
¿pkec"73 0" Tgurgevq" cn" eqpuwokfqt." ug" eqpukiwg" swg" fglg" ugt" eqpukfgtcfq" uwlgvq"
rcukxq" fg" wpc" korqtvcek„p." tgec{gpfq" ncu" qdnkicekqpgu" vtkdwvctkcu" gp" gn" uwok/
pkuvtcfqt"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"{"pq"gp"gn"cfswktgpvg0"Gp"vfitokpqu"tgecwfcvqtkqu"pq"jc{"
cnvgtcek„p"cniwpc."rwgu"gn" rtqfwevq"fgn"KXC"fgxgpicfq" gp"nc"qrgtcek„p" ugiwktƒ"
eqttgurqpfkgpfq"cn"GO"fg"eqpuwoq0
Gp"ecuq"fg"swg"ug"tgcnk¦ctc"wpc"korqtvcek„p"D4E"gp"nc"swg"nc"kpvtqfweek„p"fg"nqu"
dkgpgu"ug"rtqfwlgug"gp" nc"cfwcpc"fgn"GO"fg"fguvkpq"fgn"vtcpurqtvg"{"ug" qrvctc"
rqt"pq"fgenctct"fkejc"qrgtcek„p"c"vtcxfiu"fg"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"eqttgurqpfkgpvg."q"
pq"rwfkgtc"jcegtug"rqt"ugt"gn"xcnqt"fgn"dkgp"uwrgtkqt"c"372Û."nc"tginc"fgn"ctv0"550e+"
pq"ugtc"fg"crnkecek„p"740"Gpvtctcp"gp"lwgiq"ncu"tgincu"igpgtcngu"fg"nqecnk¦cek„p"fg"
ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"{"nc"ukornkÞecek„p"swg"uwrqpg"gn"pwgxq"ukuvgoc"pq"qrgtc/
tc0"Uk"gn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"fg"nc"korqtvcek„p"hwgtc"gn"rtqxggfqt"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"{"pq"gn"
eqpuwokfqt"Þpcn."ug"rtqfwektcp"fqu"qrgtcekqpgu"uwlgvcu"{"pq"gzgpvcu"c"KXC
korqtvcek„p"{"wpc"xgpvc"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu."nqecnk¦cfc"fg"cewgtfq"
eqp"gn"ugiwpfq"rƒttchq"fgn"ctv0"54"FKXC"75 0"Rqt"gn"eqpvtctkq."uk"gn"swg"fgenctctc"nc"
korqtvcek„p"hwgtc"gn"enkgpvg"Þpcn."nc"gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu"ug"gpvgpfgtc"pq"uwlgvc"c"
KXC."cn"guvct"nqecnk¦cfc"gp" gn" vgttkvqtkq"vgtegtq"fgn"swg"rctvg"gn"vtcpurqtvg."rwgu"
6;" DCN"gpvkgpfg" swg" nc"gnkokpcek„p" fg" nc"gzgpek„p"KXC"c" nqu" rtqfwevqu"fg" guecuq" xcnqt"{" nc"
wvknk¦cek„p"fg"guvg"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"rtqxqectƒ"swg"ncu"cfwcpcu" tgekdcp" wpc"ecpvkfcf" fg"p¿ogtq"fg"
kfgpvkhkecek„p"fg"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"gp"vkgorq"tgcn"swg"pq"ugtƒp"ecrcegu"fg"iguvkqpct"ocpwcnogpvg0"
Rqt"gnnq."eqpenw{g"nc"pgegukfcf"fg"swg"ug"cfcrvgp" ncu"kphtcguvtwevwtcu"cfwcpgtcu"rctc"rqfgt"tgcnk¦ct"
guvc"vctgc"fg"ocpgtc"ghkekgpvg0"DCN."C0."ÑVjg"ejcpikpi"ncpfuecrg"qh"vjg"GW"XCVV"Rcemcig"
cpf"Fghkpkvkxg"XCV"U{uvgoÒ."?−#∋Ι∃/3+,/Υ/&∀∋3ϑ+Xqn 0"7;."p ³"4∴5."423;."r0"990
72" Nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"¿pkecogpvg"gu"crnkecdng"rctc"rtq/
fwevqu"eqp"wp"xcnqt"kphgtkqt"c"372Û."gu"fgekt."rctc"cswgnnqu"swg"guvƒp"gzgpvq"fgn"rciq"fg"ctcpegngu"c"
nc"korqtvcek„p0"Cu."nc"fgenctcek„p"fg"wpc"qrgtcek„p"rqt"gn"QUU"fg"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E"kornkec"swg"pq"
gzkuvgp"qdnkicekqpgu"ocvgtkcngu"c"ucvkuhcegt"gp"cfwcpc0"Uqdtg"nc"wvknkfcf"fg"guvg")/∗&;/%π."UYF*4238+"
59;"Hkpcn."∋Ι6+%∀&6ϑ+r0"5:
73" Nc"itcp"xgpvclc"fgn"pwgxq"ukuvgoc"ug"rtqfweg"rctc"gpxqu"fg"dkgpgu"fg"vgtegtqu"vgttkvqtkqu"
{"rcugu"gp"nqu"swg"gn"korqtvcfqt"gu"gn"eqpuwokfqt"hkpcn0"Gp"gn"uwrwguvq"eqpvgpkfq"gp"gn"ugiwpfq"rƒ/
ttchq"fgn"ctv0"54"FKXC."gp"gn"swg"gn"rtqxggfqt"gu"gn"korqtvcfqt"{"rquvgtkqtogpvg"tgcnk¦c"wpc"gpvtgic"fg"
dkgpgu."gn"ukuvgoc"fg"fkhgtkokgpvq"fgn"KXC"c"nc"korqtvcek„p"gzkuvgpvg"gp"Gurc‚c."tgiwncfq"gp"gn"ctv0"96"
fgn"Tgincogpvq"KXC."vcodkfip"igpgtc"guvqu"ghgevqu"dgpghkekququ"rctc"nc"nkswkfg¦"fg"nqu"xgpfgfqtgu."{c"
swg"rwgfgp"rqurqpgt"gn"rciq"fgn"KXC"c"nc"korqtvcek„p"c"uw"fgenctcek„p"ogpuwcn"igpgtcn0
74" Gp"gn" rt„zkoq" crctvcfq" xgtgoqu" swg" nc" Fktgevkxc"423914677" jc" kpvtqfwekfq" wp" tfiikogp"
cnvgtpcvkxq"swg"ukornkhkec"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"swg"pq"ugcp"fgenctcfcu"c"vtcxfiu"fgn"QUU0
75"Ug"eqpukfgtc"korqtvcfqt."fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"ctv0":8040c+"NKXC."cn"fguvkpcvctkq"fg" nqu"dkgpgu"
korqtvcfqu0
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
44:
ug"crnkectc" nc" tginc" igpgtcn" fgn" ctv0" 54" FKXC0"Nc"¿pkec" qrgtcek„p" uwlgvc" ugtc" nc"
korqtvcek„p"tgcnk¦cfc"rqt"gn"eqpuwokfqt."swg"fgdgtƒ"ewornkt"eqp"uw"qdnkicek„p"
vtkdwvctkc"cpvg"nc"cfwcpc"fgn"rcu"fg"fguvkpq"fgn"vtcpurqtvg0"
Nc"ugiwpfc"tginc"fg"nqecnk¦cek„p"rctc"ncu"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"
ug"kpvtqfwektƒ"gp"gn"hwvwtq"crctvcfq"d+"fgn"ctv0"55"FKXC"{"ug"crnkec"c"nqu"ecuqu"gp"
swg"nqu"dkgpgu" ug" korqtvgp"gp"wp"rcu"fg" nc" WG" fkuvkpvq" fg" cswfin" cn" swg" guvqu"
xcp"Þpcnogpvg"fktkikfqu0"C"fkhgtgpekc"fgn"ecuq"cpvgtkqt."eqpvgpkfq"gp"gn"ctv0"550e+"
FKXC."guvcu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"ug"gpvgpfgtƒp"tgcnk¦cfcu"gp"gn"GO"gp"gn"swg"cecdg"
gn"vtcpurqtvg."gu"fgekt."gp"gn"fguvkpq"Þpcn"fg"nc"gzrgfkek„p0"Cu."ewcpfq"ug"rtqfw¦/
ec"wpc"xgpvc"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"gp"guvcu"eqpfkekqpgu"vgpftgoqu."
rqt"wp"ncfq."wpc"korqtvcek„p"gp"gn"GO"gp"gn"swg"ug"kpvtqfw¦ecp"ncu"ogtecpecu"
gp"gn"vgttkvqtkq"KXC"{."rqt"qvtq."wpc"gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu"c"fkuvcpekc"korqtvcfqu"gp"
gn"GO"fg"fguvkpq0"
Gp"guvg"ugiwpfq"uwrwguvq"nc"nqecnk¦cek„p"fg"nc"korqtvcek„p"D4E"pq"fgrgpfg"fg"
uw"fgenctcek„p"c"vtcxfiu"fg"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"q"pq0"Gp"vqfq"ecuq"nc"xgpvc"D4E"fg"
dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"ug"xc"c"gpvgpfgt"tgcnk¦cfc"gp"gn"GO"fg"fguvkpq"76 0"Ukp"godctiq."
nc"wvknk¦cek„p"fgn"pwgxq"tfiikogp"gurgekcn" ugtƒ"gugpekcn"rctc"fgvgtokpct" nc"vtkdw/
vcek„p"eqplwpvc"fg"nc"qrgtcek„p0"Uk"pq"ug"wvknk¦c"gn"QUU"ug"rtqfwektƒp"fqu"jgejqu"
korqpkdngu"fkuvkpvqu nc"korqtvcek„p"gp"gn"GO" fg" kpvtqfweek„p"fg"nqu"dkgpgu" gp"
gn"vgttkvqtkq"KXC"{" nc" xgpvc" fg" dkgpgu" korqtvcfqu"gp"gn" GO" fg" fguvkpq"7 7 0" Rqt" gn"
76" Nc"pwgxc"tgfceek„p"fgn"ctv0"55"FKXC"gnkokpctƒ"gn"cevwcn"ugiwpfq"crctvcfq"fg"fkejq"ctvewnq."
swg"hqtoc" rctvg" fgn"tfiikogp" fg"xgpvcu"c" fkuvcpekc" gp"xkiqt0"Fkejq" ctv0" 5504"fg"nc" Fktgevkxc."swg" ug"
crnkectƒ"jcuvc"4243."guvcdngeg"swg."gp"ncu"xgpvcu"swg"rtqxgpicp"fg"vgtegtqu"vgttkvqtkqu"q"rcugu"{"ew{q"
fguvkpq"ugc" fkuvkpvq"fgn" GO"gp" swg"nqu"korqtvg" gn"rtqxggfqt."gn" vtcpurqtvg"fg"nc" gpvtgic"fg" dkgpgu"
ug"gpvkgpfg" kpkekcfq"gp" gn"rcu" fg"korqt vcek„p0"Cn" gpvgpfgt"swg" gn"vtcpurqtvg"ug" kpkekc"gp" gn"GO"fg"
korqtvcek„p."ug" crnkectc"nc"tginc"fg"vtkdwvcek„p" gp"fguvkpq" ctvkewncfc"gp" gn"rtkogt" crctvcfq"fgn"ctv0"
55"FKXC0"Cu."guvg"ugiwpfq"crctvcfq"fgn"ctv0"55"rgtfgtc"uw"wvknkfcf"gp"gn"oqogpvq"gp"swg"ug"fghkpc"
fg"ocpgtc"kpfgrgpfkgpvg"nc"xgpvc"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu."{"oƒu"vgpkgpfq"gp"ewgpvc"swg"nc"
tginc"fg"nqecnk¦cek„p"swg"ug"ng"crnkec"ewcpfq"gn"GO"fg"fguvkpq"ugc"fkxgt uq"fgn"fg"nc"korqt vcek„p"gu"nc"
okuoc"swg"nc"swg"ug"crnkec"c"ncu"xgpvcu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu
vtcpurqtvg0"Fg"jgejq."nc"rtqrwguvc"fg"nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"pq"rtgxgc"etgct"ncu"tgincu"fg"nqecnk¦cek„p"
gurgehkecu"swg"jgoqu"eqogpvcfq0"Rqt"gn"eqpvtctkq."uqnq"rncpvgcdc"kpvtqfwekt"wp"ugiwpfq"rƒttchq"gp"
gn"ctv0"5504"swg"ug"crnkectc"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E"swg"vwxkgtcp"eqoq"fguvkpq"gn"GO"fg"kpvtqfweek„p"
fg"nqu"dkgpgu."rwgu"nc"tginc"gzkuvgpvg"gp"gn"5504"vgpftc"wp" ghgevq"ukoknct"c"nc"ogfkfc"cfqrvcfc"gp"gn"
hwvwtq"550d"FKXC."vtkdwvct" gp"gn"GO"fg"nngicfc" fgn"vtcpurqtvg0" Ecdg"tgeqtfct"swg" ncu"xgpvcu"kpvtceq/
owpkvctkcu"c"fkuvcpekc" eqpvctƒp"eqp"wp" wodtcn"fg"vtkdwvcek„p"gp"qtkigp" fg"320222Û."swg" pq"ugtƒ" fg"
crnkecek„p"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E."ewguvk„p"swg"vcodkfip"eqpvgorncdc"nc"rtqrwguvc"fg"nc"Eqokuk„p0"
Eqpukfgtcoqu"swg"nc"qrek„p"cfqrvcfc"crqtvc"owejc"oƒu"enctkfcf"cn"vgzvq"pqtocvkxq"swg"nc"rtqrwgu/
vc"gp"nc"EQO*4238+"979"hkpcn0"
77"Jc{"swg"vgpgt"gp"ewgpvc"nc"gzkuvgpekc"fgn"tfiikogp"cfwcpgtq"64."swg"rgtokvg"swg"gn"korqt/
vcfqt"uqnkekvg"wpc"gzgpek„p"fgn"KXC"c"nc"korqtvcek„p"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"swg"xc{cp"c"ugt"vtcpurqtvcfqu"c"qvtq"
GO"gp"wpc"gpvtgic"kpvtceqowpkvctkc"fg"dkgpgu"gpvtg"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu0"Gn"Vtkdwpcn"Gwtqrgq"fg"Ewgpvcu"
jc"etkvkecfq"gp"xctkcu"qecukqpgu" nc"guecug¦"fg"eqpvtqngu" fg"guvg"tfiikogp"cfwcpgtq"{" nc"gzkuvgpekc"fg"
htcwfg"cuqekcfq"cn"okuoq"rqt"uw"wvknk¦cek„p"gp"vtcpuceekqpgu"D4E0"Vtkdwpcn"fg"Ewgpvcu"Gwtqrgq."Kphqt/
og"p³"3514233"Ï"½Uktxg"gn"eqpvtqn"fgn"tfiikogp"cfwcpgtq"64"rctc"gxkvct"{"fgvgevct"nc"gxcuk„p"fgn"KXCA."g"
Kphqtog"p³"341423;."∋Ι6+%∀&6"r0"68Vtkdwpcn"eqpuvcv„"swg"gzkuvc"gn"tkguiq"fg"swg"nqu"dkgpgu"korqtvc/
fqu"gp"xktvwf"fgn"tfiikogp"cfwcpgtq"64"ug"ocpvwxkgtcp"gp"wp"cnocefip"gp"nc"WG"jcuvc"gn"oqogpvq"fg"
nc"cfswkukek„p"rqt"rctvg"fg"wp"eqpuwokfqt"{"uw"eqttgurqpfkgpvg"gpvtgic"gp"pqodtg"fgn"rtqxggfqt"fg"
wp"vgtegt"rcu"ukp"rcict"gn"KXC"rqt"guvg"gpxqÒ0
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP44;
eqpvtctkq."uk"ug"fgenctc"nc"qrgtcek„p"c"vtcxfiu"fgn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn."nc"korqtvcek„p"
guvctƒ" gzgpvc." swgfcpfq" nc" korqtvcek„p" D4E" eqoq" ¿pkec" qdnkicek„p" vtkdwvctkc"
swg"fgxgpictƒ"KXC0"
Cu."nc"pwgxc"pqtocvkxc"fgdg"eqpvgornctug"eqoq"wp"eqplwpvq"hqtocfq"rqt"pwg/
xcu"tgincu"fg"nqecnk¦cek„p"fg"ncu"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu."wp"tfi/
ikogp"gurgekcn"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"swg"hceknkvg"ncu"fgenctcekqpgu"fg"guvcu"qrgtc/
ekqpgu"Ïswg"gu"qrekqpcn" {"pq"ug"crnkec"c" dkgpgu"fg"xcnqt"uwrgtkqt"c"372"ÛÏ." {"nc"
gzgpek„p"c"nc"korqtvcek„p"fg"vcngu"rtqfwevqu"swg"ug"kpvtqfweg"cn"wvknk¦ct"gn"QUU0"
Guvg"ukuvgoc"vkgpg"korqtvcpvgu"curgevqu"rqukvkxqu."{c"swg"ictcpvk¦c"nc"korqukek„p"
gp"fguvkpq." gnkokpcpfq" qdnkicekqpgu" vtkdwvctkcu"rctc"nqu"eqpuwokfqtgu" Þpcngu" {"
ukornkÞecpfq."gp"itcp"ogfkfc."gn"ewornkokgpvq"fg"nqu"fgdgtgu"swg"cuwocp"nqu"
uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"swg"tgcnkegp"guvcu"pwgxcu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu0"
Rqt"¿nvkoq."nc" crnkecek„p"fgn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"rctc"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"
korqtvcfqu"vkgpg"wpc"kornkecek„p"cfkekqpcn"fg"itcp"tgngxcpekc0"Fcfq"swg"eqpnngxc"
nc"gzgpek„p"fgn"jgejq"korqpkdng"ÑkorqtvcekqpguÒ."gn"fgxgpiq"fg"nc"qrgtcek„p"pq"
ugiwktƒ"ncu"tgincu"guvcdngekfcu"gp"gn"ctv0"92"fg"nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC."swg "nq"Þlc tc"gp" gn"
oqogpvq"gp"swg"ug"rtqfweg"fkejc"korqtvcek„p0"Rqt"gnnq."nc"Fktgevkxc"423914677"
kpvtqfweg"wpc"tginc"fg"fgxgpiq"gurgeÞeq"rctc"ncu"xgpvcu"D4E"fg"dkgpgu"korqt/
vcfqu"swg"ug"fgenctgp"gp"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec0"Gn"ctv0"58;"Ρ−∀30∃%∀∃∗+fg"nc"Fktgevkxc"
KXC"guvcdngeg"swg"uw"fgxgpiq"Ñug"rtqfwektƒ"{"gn"korwguvq"ug"jctƒ"gzkikdng"gp"gn"
oqogpvq"fg"nc"gpvtgicÒ0"Guvc"pwgxc"tginc"ukiwg"nc"pqtoc"igpgtcn"rctc"gn"eqplwp vq "
fg"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"guvcdngekfq"gp"gn"ctv0"85"FKXC0"Nc"pqxgfcf"ug"gpewgpvtc"gp"
nc"gzrnkecek„p"cfkekqpcn"swg"eqpvkgpg"gn"ctv0"58;"Ρ−∀30∃%∀∃∗+ewcpfq"cÞtoc"swg"ug"
eqpukfgtctƒ"tgcnk¦cfc"fkejc"gpvtgic"Ñgp"gn"oqogpvq"gp"gn"swg"ug"jc{c"cegrvcfq"
gn"rciqÒ0"
Guvc"hqtowncek„p"kpvtqfweg"wp"pwgxq"oqogpvq"vgorqtcn"fkuvkpvq"fg"nqu"jcdkvwcn/
ogpvg"wucfqu" rqt"nc"pqtocvkxc"KXC"jcuvc" cjqtc0"Uk"dkgp"gn" oqogpvq" fgn" eqdtq"
fgn"rtgekq"ug" guvcdngeg" eqoq" tginc" fg"fgxgpiq"cpvkekrcfq"gp" gn" ctv0"87" FKXC."
pq"gzkuvg"wpc"gurgekÞecek„p"rtgekuc"fg"swfi"fgdg"gpvgpfgtug"rqt"cegrvcek„p"fgn"
rciq0"Rqt"gnnq."gpvgpfgoqu"swg"uw"eqpetgek„p" vgorqtcn"fgdg"ugt"tguwgnvc"gp"nc"
pqtocvkxc"fg"fgucttqnnq"fg"nc" Fktgevkxc"KXC0"Nc"Eqokuk„p" Gwtqrgc"jc"gncdqtcfq"
wpc"rtqrwguvc"swg" fgucttqnnc"guvg"eqpegrvq."cvgpfkgpfq"cn"oqogpvq"gp"swg"gn"
uwlgvq"rcukxq"fcfq"fg"cnvc"gp"gn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn."q"nc"rgtuqpc"swg"cev¿g"rqt"uw"
ewgpvc."tgekdcp" Ñnc" eqpÞtocek„p"fgn"rciq."gn"ogpuclg"fg" cwvqtk¦cek„p" fg" rciq"
q"wp"eqortqokuq"fg"rciq"fgn"enkgpvg."nq"swg"qewttc"rtkogtq."jc{c"ukfq"tgekdkfq"
rqt"q"rqt"ewgpvc"fgn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"swg"jcic"wuq"fgn"tfiikogp"fg"korqtvcek„p"kp/
fgrgpfkgpvgogpvg"fgn"oqogpvq"gp"swg"ug"tgcnkeg"gn"rciq"ghgevkxq"fg"fkpgtqÒ"78 0"
Jc{"swg"ektewpuetkdkt"guvg"rncpvgcokgpvq"c"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"swg"ug"rwgfgp"fgenc/
tct"rqt"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec."gu"fgekt."xgpvcu"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"c"eqpuwokfqtgu"
eqp"wp"xcnqt"kphgtkqt"c"372Û0"Nc"tgfceek„p"eqogpvcfc"rctgeg"guvct"rgpucpfq"gp"
eqpvtcvcekqpgu"∋3.∀3∃."gp"ncu"swg"gzkuvg"wp"kpvgtogfkctkq"gngevt„pkeq"fg"rciq"swg"
rwgfg"tgcnk¦ct"gn"eqdtq."dnqswgct"gn"korqtvg"gp"nc"ewgpvc"fgn"enkgpvg"q"eqortqdct"
78" Rtqrwguvc"fg"tghqtoc"fgn"ctv0"83"&∃#+fgn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"4:414233."gp"uw"xgtuk„p"
crtqdcfc"rqt"gn"GEQHKP"gn":"fg"oct¦q"fg"423;0
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
452
nc"gzkuvgpekc"fg"ucnfq"uwÞekgpvg"rctc"tgcnk¦ct"gn"rciq"{"rqfgt"gpxkct"cn"rtqxggfqt"
nc"eqpÞtocek„p"fgn"fizkvq"fg"nc"qrgtcek„p0"
Rctgeg"enctq"swg"guvc"tginc"gurgekcn"ugtƒ"crnkecdng"ewcpfq"fgtkxg"fg"wpc"fkuqekc/
ek„p"vgorqtcn"fg"nc"cegrvcek„p"fgn"rciq"{"gn"cdqpq"ghgevkxq."{c"swg."fg"rtqfw/
ektug"guvg"¿nvkoq."ug"fgxgpictc"gn"jgejq"korqpkdng0"Ecdtc"rncpvgctug"gn"fgxgpiq"
fg"guvcu" gpvtgicu" fg" dkgpgu" korqtvcfqu" ewcpfq" nc" cegrvcek„p"fgn" rciq" hwgug"
rquvgtkqt"c" nc" gpvtgic"fgn"dkgp0"Fcfq"swg"guvcoqu" jcdncpfq" fg" korqtvcekqpgu"
D4E."pq"rctgeg"ow{"rtqdcdng"swg"wp"rtqxggfqt"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"xgpfc"c"
nqu"enkgpvgu"ukp"vgpgt."cn"ogpqu."wp"eqortqokuq"fg"rciq"fg"guvqu0"Pq"qduvcpvg."
fg"fctug"guvc"ukvwcek„p."gpvgpfgoqu"swg"nc"eqpÞiwtcek„p"fgn"ctv0"58;"Ρ−∀30∃%∀∃∗"
guvcdngeg"gn"oqogpvq"fg"cegrvcek„p"fgn"rciq"eqoq"gurgekÞecek„p"fg"nc"gpvtg/
ic."fcfq"swg"ug"xc"c"rtqfwekt."gp"nc"oc{qt"rctvg"fg"qecukqpgu."eqp"cpvgtkqtkfcf"
c"guvc0" Fg" rtqfwektug" rquvgtkqtogpvg."gpvgpfgoqu"swg" gn" fgxgpiq"fgn"KXC"ug"
rtqfwektƒ"eqp"nc"gpvtgic."ukiwkgpfq"nc"tginc"igpgtcn"rctc"ncu"xgpvcu"fg"dkgpgu"{"nc"
htcug"kpkekcn"fgn"rtqrkq"ctv0"58;"Ρ−∀30∃%∀∃∗0"
5050" N巴杷"蚤派嚢琶巴杷"覇嚢濃狽覗嚢蚤嚢杷"埜嚢"琶嚢蚤波乃蚤能農農乃"伯蚤能之乃"把乃覇乃"農乃杷"波覇乃蚤杷乃之之能巴蚤嚢杷"
能蚤波嚢覇蚤乃之能巴蚤乃農嚢杷
Cevwcnogpvg."nqu"tgiogpgu"gurgekcngu"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"qrgtcp"gzenwukxcogpvg"
gp"nc"vtkdwvcek„p"KXC"fg"nqu"ugtxkekqu"VDG"*ugtxkekqu"rqt"xc"gngevt„pkec."fg"vgngeq/
owpkecekqpgu."vgngxkuk„p"{"tcfkqfkhwuk„p+0"Uw" dwgp"hwpekqpcokgpvq."vcpvq"fgufg"
wpc"„rvkec"vg„tkec"eqoq"gp"uwu"tguwnvcfqu"ghgevkxqu."jc"rtqxqecfq"swg"ncu"cwvq/
tkfcfgu"gwtqrgcu" nq"eqpukfgtgp"eqoq"wpc" fg" nqu"guvƒpfctgu"swg"fgdg" korgtct"
gp"nc" gxqnwek„p"fgn"korwguvq0" Nc"Fktgevkxc"423914677"nq"gtkig"eqoq" nc"encxg"fg"
d„xgfc"fg"nc" tgecwfcek„p"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"eqp"eqpuwokfqtgu."vcpvq"
fgpvtq"fg"nc"Wpk„p"Gwtqrgc"eqoq"gp"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"swg"rtqxgpicp"fg"vgtegtqu"
vgttkvqtkqu"q"rcugu0"Rqt"uw"rctvg."nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"jc"rncpvgcfq"uw"korngogp/
vcek„p"vcodkfip"gp"vtcpuceekqpgu" kpvtceqowpkvctkcu" gpvtg" uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"Ï5−∗∀;
3∃∗∗+&∋+5−∗∀3∃∗∗"q"D4DÏ"79 0
C"rctvkt"fg"4243."lwpvq"eqp"nqu"pwgxqu"jgejqu"korqpkdngu"eqogpvcfqu."nc"Fktge/
vkxc"KXC"vcodkfip"kpeqtrqtctƒ"pwgxqu"tgiogpgu"gurgekcngu"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"Ïq"
cornkctƒ"gn"cnecpeg"fg"nqu"gzkuvgpvguÏ"rctc"ukornkÞect"nc"fgenctcek„p"fg"fgvgtok/
pcfcu"vtcpuceekqpgu"kpvgtpcekqpcngu0"Gn"rtkogt"ecodkq"tgug‚cdng"gu"gn"tgncvkxq"cn"
ƒodkvq"fg" crnkecek„p" fgn" cevwcn" tfiikogp"gurgekcn" rctc" ugtxkekqu" VDG"rtguvcfqu"
rqt"uwlgvqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"WG."tgiwncfq"gp"nqu"ctvu0"57:"5∀∗"{"uu0"fg"nc"Fk/
tgevkxc"KXC0"Guvg"rgtokvg"swg"cswgnnqu"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"swg"pq"vgpicp"uw"ugfg"fg"
fktgeek„p"ghgevkxc"pk"wp"guvcdngekokgpvq"rgtocpgpvg"gp"nc"WG"rwgfcp"rtguvct"nqu"
ekvcfqu"ugtxkekqu"VDG"c"nqu"eqpuwokfqtgu"fg"nqu"fkuvkpvqu"GGOO"ukp"pgegukfcf"fg"
79" Nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc."gp" uw"EQO*423:+"54;"hkpcn."rtqrqpg"oqfkhkect"nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC"cnvg/
tcpfq"gn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"swg"gpvtctƒ"gp"xkiqt"gp"4243"rctc"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"D4E"
kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"{"uwuvkvwktnq"rqt"wp"∋3∃;∗&∋Ι;∗1∋Ι"igpgtcn" rctc"vqfcu"ncu" qrgtcekqpgu"fg"xgpvc"fg"
dkgpgu"{"ugt xkekqu."vcpvq"D4D"eqoq"D4E."tgcnk¦cfcu"rqt" uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu"gp" gn"GO" fg"
vtkdwvcek„p"fg"fkejcu"qrgtcekqpgu"{"swg"pq"vgpic"eqpukfgtcek„p"fg"uwlgvq"rcukxq"egtvkhkecfq0"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP453
kfgpvkÞectug"gp"vqfqu"gnnqu"7:0"C"rctvkt"fgn"3"fg"gpgtq"fg"4243"guvc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"
rctc"qrgtcfqtgu"gzvtc/WG" xc"c"ecodkct" uwuvcpekcnogpvg"uw"cnecpeg." {c"swg"fglc"
fg"guvct" nkokvcfc"c"nqu" ugtxkekqu" VDG0"Gn"pwgxq"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"rqftƒ" wvknk¦ctug"
rctc"fgenctct" vqfcu" ncu" rtguvcekqpgu" fg" ugtxkekqu" swg" ug" eqpukfgtgp" nqecnk¦cfcu"
gp"wp"GO."swg"ugcp"tgcnk¦cfcu"rqt"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"WG"{"swg"
vgpicp"eqoq"fguvkpcvctkqu"rgtuqpcu"ukp"eqpfkek„p"fg"uwlgvq"rcukxq"7; 0"
Gu"eqpxgpkgpvg"tgeqtfct"nqu"fcvqu"fg"gortgucu"kpuetkvcu"gp"gn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"fg"
ugtxkekqu"VDG"gzvtc/WGg/
ucu"swg"ug"ceqikgtqp"c"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"kpvtc/WG"82 0"Nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"lwuvkÞec"
guvc"rgqt"ceqikfc"fgn"tfiikogp"gzvtc/WG"gp"nc"ecpvkfcf"fg"gortgucu"swg"ug"vgpcp"
swg"kfgpvkÞect"rqt"cni¿p"oqvkxq"gp"wp"GO"c"ghgevqu"fgn"KXC"Ïswg"c"rctvkt"fg"423;"
rqftƒp"wvknk¦ct"guvc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkecÏ"{"gp"nc"kpvgtogfkcek„p"fg"ncu"itcpfgu"rncvc/
hqtocu"gngevt„pkecu0"Pq"qduvcpvg."nqu"fcvqu"fgowguvtcp."c"pwguvtq"rctgegt."swg"gn"
fizkvq"fg"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"jc"tgukfkfq"rtkpekrcnogpvg"gp"ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"fgpvtq"
fg"nc"Wpk„p"{"swg"ug"ukiwgp"pgegukvcpfq"ogfkfcu"cfkekqpcngu"rctc"gxkvct"nc"hcnvc"
fg"fgenctcek„p"fg"guvqu"ugtxkekqu"ewcpfq"ugcp"rtguvcfqu"fgufg"hwgtc"fg"nc"WG"83 0
Ν6Ν6Ζ6+ +73+#ΦΧ∀∆∃3+∃∗Ι∃%∀/.+0∃+8∃3&/3∀../+α3∀%/+Ι/#/+./∗+8∃3&/∗+/+
0∀∗&/3%∀/+0∃+5∀∃3∃∗+∀∆Ι∋#&/0∋∗
Nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"gzvtc/WG"ukt xg"rtkpekrcnogp/
vg"eqoq"ogfkq"ukornkÞecfq"fg"ewornkokgpvq"gp"wp"uqnq"GO"fg"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"
vtkdwvctkcu"fg"vqfcu"ncu"xgpvcu"jgejcu"gp"nc"WG0"Gn"ecuq"fgn"pwgxq"tfiikogp"fg"gp/
vtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu."eqoq"jgoqu"eqogpvcfq."gu"fkxgtuq0"Pq"ug"guvtwe/
vwtc"¿pkecogpvg" eqoq" wpc"ukornkÞecek„p"fg"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu" hqtocngu" c" vtcxfiu"
fgn"QUU."ukpq"swg"ug"eqnqec"eqoq"rkg¦c"encxg"fgn"ukuvgoc."cn"gxkvct"swg"gzkuvc"wpc"
fqdng"korqukek„p"ecwucfc"rqt"nc"rnwtcnkfcf"fg"jgejqu"korqpkdngu"swg"chgevcp"c"
wpc"xgpvc"D4E"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu0"Nc"gzgpek„p"c"nc"korqtvcek„p"swg"eqpnngxc"
nc"wvknk¦cek„p"fgn"QUU."cfgoƒu."vkgpg"gn"qdlgvkxq"fg"nkdgtct"fg"qdnkicekqpgu"vtkdw/
vctkcu"c"nqu"eqpuwokfqtgu"Þpcngu"ewcpfq."fg"cewgtfq"eqp"nc"pqtocvkxc"KXC."hwgtcp"
eqpukfgtcfqu"nqu"korqtvcfqtgu"fg"nqu"rtqfwevqu"cfswktkfqu0"Rctvkgpfq"fg"guvqu"
7:" Wpq"fg"nqu"ecodkqu"tgngxcpvg"swg"kpvtqfweg"nc"Fktgevkxc"423914677"gu"swg."c"rctvkt"fg"423;."
ogfkcpvg"wpc"oqfkhkecek„p"fgn"ctv"57:"dku"rwpvq"3."ug"jcdknkvc"c"nqu"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu"gp"
nc"WG"rgtq"swg"guvfip"kfgpvkhkecfqu"c"ghgevqu"fgn"KXC"gp"cni¿p"GO"c"ceqigtug"c"guvg"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"
gzvtc/WG."ewguvk„p"swg"cpvgu"pq"ngu"guvcdc"rgtokvkfq0"
7;" Gn"ctv0"67" fg" nc" Fktgevkxc"KXC"guvcdngeg"eqoq" tginc" igpgtcn"fg"nqecnk¦cek„p" fg" ncu" rtguvc/
ekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"swg" vgpicp"eqoq"fguvkpcvctkq"wpc"rgtuqpc"swg"pq"ugc"uwlgvq"rcukxq."gn"nwict"fg"
guvcdngekokgpvq"fgn"rtguvcfqt."gu"fgekt."nc"vtkdwvcek„p"gp"qtkigp0"Pq" qduvcpvg."gzkuvgp" fgvgtokpcfcu"
rtguvcekqpgu."eqoq"nqu" ugtxkekqu"VDG." swg"ewgpvcp"eqp"wpc"tginc" gurgekcn"fg"vtkdwvcek„p" gp"fguvkpq0"
Nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"uqnq"ugtxktƒ"rctc"cswgnncu"qrgtcekqpgu"tgcnk¦cfcu"rqt"wp"uwlgvq"rcukxq"wdkecfq"gz/
vtc/WG"swg"guvfip"uwlgvcu"c"KXC"gp"wp"GO"fgdkfq"c"fkejcu"tgincu"gurgekcngu0"
82" Fgnqkvvg."Kphqtog" 5³" uqdtg+ 9∗∗∃∗∗∆∃3&+ ∋)+&1∃+ ∀∆Ι.∃∆∃3&/&∀∋3+ ∋)+ &1∃+ Ψ[Ζε+ Ι./%∃+∋)+∗−ΙΙ.4+
#−.∃∗+/30+&1∃+=∀3∀;Λ3∃+Ε&∋Ι+Ε1∋Ι."fcvqu"tgncvkxqu"cn"ugiwpfq"vtkoguvtg"fg"42380
83" Gp"guvg"ugpvkfq." NCOGPUEJ."O0."ÑFguvkpcvkqp"dcugf" vczcvkqp"qh"eqtrqtcvg"rtqhkvu/rtgnkok/
pct{"hkpfkpiu" tgictfkpi"vcz"eqnngevkqp"kp"etquu/dqtfgt" ukvwcvkqpuÒ."ΛΥ)∋#0+θ∋#π∀3Χ+(/Ι∃#+Ε∃#∀∃∗ϑ+Lwnkq"
4239."rr0"33/35
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
454
rtkpekrkqu"guvtwevwtcngu."fgdgoqu"cpcnk¦ct" gn" hwpekqpcokgpvq" {" cnecpeg" fg" guvc"
xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E0"
Gn"rtkogt"curgevq"hwpfcogpvcn"gu"nc"fgvgtokpcek„p"fg"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"swg"rwg/
fgp"fgenctctug"c"vtcxfiu" fg" guvg" tfiikogp" gurgekcn xgpvcu" c" fkuvcpekc" fg" dkgpgu"
korqtvcfqu"ew{q"xcnqt"kpvtpugeq"pq"gzegfc"fg"372"Û"{"swg"pq"ug"vtcvg"fg"rtqfwe/
vqu"uwlgvqu"c"korwguvqu"gurgekcngu0"Nc"ewcpvc"Þlcfc"rctc"rqfgt"ceqigtug"c"guvg"
tfiikogp"gurgekcn"{."eqp"gnnq."swg"qrgtg"nc"gzgpek„p"fgn"KXC"c"nc"korqtvcek„p"pq"gu"
c¦ctquc0"Eqkpekfg"eqp"nc"gzgpek„p"fg"nqu"ctcpegngu"c"nc"korqtvcek„p"fg"ncu"Ñogt/
ecpecu"ukp"xcnqt"guvkocdngÒ."Þlcfc"rqt"gn"ctv0"45"fgn"Tgincogpvq"*EG+"33:81422;."
fg"38"fg"pqxkgodtg."gp"fkejc"ewcpvc"fg"372"Û"84 0"
Guvc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec."rqt"vcpvq."ug"crnkec"c"cswgnnqu"dkgpgu"swg"pq"xcp"c"ugt"qdlg/
vq"fg"wpc"nkswkfcek„p"vtkdwvctkc"gp"cfwcpc"rqt"ctcpegngu"c"nc"korqtvcek„p0"Cu."ug"
ukornkÞec"vcodkfip"gn"eqdtq"fgn"KXC."{c"swg"nc"wvknk¦cek„p"fg"guvg"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"
gnkokpc"nc"qdnkicek„p"rqt"guvg"korwguvq"gp"cfwcpc."cn"fgenctct"gzgpvc"nc"korqtvc/
ek„p."rqurqpkgpfq"gn"rciq"fgn"korwguvq"c"nc"fgenctcek„p"rgtk„fkec"swg"ug"jcic"
gp"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec0" Uw"wvknk¦cek„p"kornkec" swg"nqu"gpxqu" fg"dkgpgu"pq" fgdgp"
ewornkt"qdnkicekqpgu"vtkdwvctkcu"gp" ncu" cfwcpcu" eqowpkvctkcu." rwfkgpfq" wvknk¦ct"
gn")/∗&;/%π"cpvgu"ogpekqpcfq0"Nqu"dkgpgu"ew{q"xcnqt"kpvtpugeq"uwrgtg"nqu"372"Û"
xcp"c"swgfct"uwlgvqu"c"nc"fgenctcek„p"eqorngvc"fg"ctcpegngu"c"nc"korqtvcek„p."rqt"
nq"swg"gn"jgejq"fg"gzenwkt"gn"rciq"fgn"KXC"gp"cfwcpc"pq"tguwnvctc"gp"wpc"oglqtc"
vcp"uwuvcpekcn" c" nc"swg"ug"fc"gp" nqu" swg"rtgugpvgp"wp" xcnqt" kphgtkqt0"Rqt"gnnq." cn"
nkokvct"gn"wuq"fg"guvg"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"c"ncu"ogtecpecu"Ñukp"xcnqt"guvkocdngÒ"gp"
vfitokpqu"cfwcpgtqu."pq"ug"crnkec"nc"gzgpek„p"KXC"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"rtqfwe/
vqu"fg"korqtvg" uwrgtkqt."swg"fgdgtƒp" ucvkuhcegt"gp"cfwcpc"vcpvq"nqu"korwguvqu"
ctcpegnctkqu"eqoq"gn"KXC0"
Wp"oqvkxq"ukoknct"lwuvkÞec"nc"gzenwuk„p"fg"nqu"rtqfwevqu"uwlgvqu"c"korwguvqu"gu/
rgekcngu0"Rqt"wp" ncfq."nc"gzgpek„p"fg"ctcpegngu" c"ogtecpecu"ukp"xcnqt"guvkocdng"
pq"ug"crnkec"pk"c"rtqfwevqu"cneqj„nkequ"pk"cn"vcdceq0"Rqt"qvtq."nqu"korwguvqu"gurg/
ekcngu"vcodkfip"fgdgp"nkswkfctug"c"nc"korqtvcek„p0"Cfgoƒu."nc"ewqvc"vtkdwvctkc"fg"
guvcu"ceekucu"hqtoc"rctvg"fg"nc"dcug"korqpkdng"fgn"KXC."rqt"nq"swg"ugtƒ"pgeguctkq"
eqpqegt"uw" ewcpvc" rctc"fgvgtokpct"gn" xcnqt" fg"nqu"rtqfwevqu"c" nqu"swg"fgdgtƒ"
crnkectug"gn"korwguvq0"Rqt"gnnq."nc"ukornkÞecek„p"fg"wvknk¦ct"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rkgt/
fg"uw"ugpvkfq"gp"guvqu"rtqfwevqu."fcfc"nc"pgegukfcf"fg"ewornkogpvct"qdnkicekq/
pgu"vtkdwvctkcu"gp"cfwcpc0"
Cu."nqu" rtqxggfqtgu" swg" tgcnkegp"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"swg"
gpvtgp"fgpvtq"fg"nqu"nokvgu"octecfqu"rqftƒp"ceqigtug"c"guvg"tfiikogp"gurgekcn0"
Gn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"guvƒ"eqpÞiwtcfq"rctc"swg"ug"rwgfcp"ceqigt" c"nc"xgpvcpknnc"
84" Fg"jgejq." gn"ectƒevgt"ÑkpvtpugeqÒ"fgn" xcnqt"fgn"rtqfwevq" cn"swg" fgdg" cvgpfgtug"rctc" fg/
vgtokpct"uk"gu"uwuegrvkdng"fg"ugt"fgenctcfq"rqt"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"gu"eqpuqpcpvg"eqp"nc"vgtokpqnqic"
gorngcfc"rqt"nc"gzgpek„p"fg"ctcpegngu"fg"korqtvcek„p"c" ncu"ogtecpecu"ukp" xcnqt"guvkocdng0"Gp"guvg"
ugpvkfq."nc"EQO*4238+"979"hkpcn."∋Ι6+%∀&6."r0"33."nq"fghkpg"eqoq"Ñgn"xcnqt"fg"nqu"rtqfwevqu"gzenwukxcogp/
vg."ukp"kpenwkt"pk"gn"ugiwtq"pk"gn"vtcpurqtvgÒ0"Ukp"godctiq."uk"cvgpfgoqu"c"nq"fgenctcfq"rqt"gn"Vtkdwpcn"fg"
Ewgpvcu"fg"nc"WG."gp"uw"Kphqtog"Gurgekcn"p³"341423;."∋Ι6+%∀&6ϑ+cr0"349."rcugu"eqoq"Ktncpfc"{"Cngocpkc"
gpvkgpfgp"swg"vcn"xcnqt"rwgfg"kpenwkt"nqu"equvgu"fgn"vtcpurqtvg0"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP455
¿pkec"vcpvq"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"WG" eqoq"pq"guvcdngekfqu."uk"dkgp"
nqu"tgswkukvqu"hqtocngu"gzkikfqu"c"wpqu"{"qvtqu"xctcp"8 5 0"Nqu"gortguctkqu"{"rtqhg/
ukqpcngu"guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"WG"swg"tgcnkegp"guvcu"xgpvcu"fg"rtqfwevqu"korqtvcfqu"
rqftƒp"ceqigtug" c" guvg" tfiikogp"fg"ocpgtc"fktgevc"q" ogfkcpvg" tgrtgugpvcek„p"
glgtekfc"rqt" wp"kpvgtogfkctkq"nqecnk¦cfq"gp" vgttkvqtkq" eqowpkvctkq"8 6 0"Rqt"gn" eqp/
vtctkq."ewcpfq"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E"ncu"tgcnkegp"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu."
guvqu"uqnq"rqftƒp"wvknk¦ct"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"guvcu"xgpvcu"uk"guvƒp"tgrtgugpvc/
fqu"rqt"wp"kpvgtogfkctkq"guvcdngekfq"gp"nc"Wpk„p"87 "q"uk"uw"rcu"fg"guvcdngekokgpvq"
jc"Þtocfq"wp"cewgtfq"fg"cukuvgpekc" owvwc"gurgeÞeq"eqp"nc"WG"8 8 0"Fcfq"swg"nc"
fgenctcek„p"fg"ncu"xgpvcu"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"rqt"guvg"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"jceg"
swg"nqu" dkgpgu" gpvtgp" gp" vgttkvqtkq"KXC"ukp" ucvkuhcegt" gn" korwguvq"gp"cfwcpc."nc"
pqtoc"cugiwtc" swg" nc" rgtuqpc" swg" jcdtƒ" fg" ewornkt" ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"rqt"guvg"
korwguvq"vgpic"wp"guvcdngekokgpvq"gp"vgttkvqtkq"fg"nc"Wpk„p"q"gp"wp"rcu"cn"swg"
ug"rwgfc"uqnkekvct"c{wfc"rctc"nc"tgecwfcek„p"fg"guvg"korwguvq"89 0"
Nc"xgpvclc"hwpfcogpvcn"fgn"ukuvgoc"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"gu"swg" rgtokvg"c"nqu"uw/
lgvqu"rcukxqu"swg"ug"ceqlcp"c"gnnc"qrgtct"gp"vqfqu"nqu"GGOO"fg"nc"WG"rgtq"rqfgt"
kpuetkdktug"{"ewornkt"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"ocvgtkcngu"{"hqtocngu"fgn"korwguvq"gp"wpq"
uqnq"fg"gnnqu"8 : 0"Fkejq"rcu"gu"gn"swg"ug"fgpqokpc"GO"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p0"Rctc"swg"
ug"ewornc"gn"rtkpekrkq"fg"korqukek„p"gp"fguvkpq."gn"GO"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"rtqegfg/
85" Ug"eqpukfgtc"swg"wp"uwlgvq"rcukxq"pq"ug"gpewgpvtc"guvcdngekfq"gp"wp"GO"ewcpfq"pq"vkgpg"
pk"nc"ugfg"fg"uw"cevkxkfcf"geqp„okec"pk"wp"guvcdngekokgpvq"rgtocpgpvg"gp"gn"vgttkvqtkq"fg"nc"WG."eqp"
kpfgrgpfgpekc"fg"uk"guvƒ"kfgpvkhkecfq"c"ghgevqu"fgn"KXC"gp"cni¿p"rcu"fg"nc"Wpk„p"q"pq0"
86" Gn"hwvwtq"ctv0"48;"&∃#0∃%∀∃∗"fg"nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC"fghkpktƒ "cn"kpvgtogfkctkq"eqoq"nc"r gtuqp c"Ñfg/
ukipcfc"rqt"gn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"]É̲"eqoq"tgurqpucdng"fgn"ewornkokgpvq"fg"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"rtgxkuvcu"rqt"
gn"rtgugpvg"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"gp"pqodtg"{"rqt"ewgpvc"fg"fkejq"uwlgvq"rcukxqÒ0"
87" Gp"nc" rtqrwguvc"fg"Fktgevkxc" tgcnk¦cfc"rqt" nc" Eqokuk„p"ug" rncpvg„" swg" vcodkfip" rwfkgtcp"
ceqigtug"cn" tfiikogp"gurgekcn." ukp"pgegukfcf" fg" tgrtgugpvcpvg"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu"gp" nc"
Eqowpkfcf"swg"hwgtcp"cwvqtk¦cfqu"rqt"nqu"GGOO"fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p"ewcpfq"ug"ewornkgtcp"vtgu"etkvg/
tkqu{"hkuecn="cnvq"itcfq"fg"
eqpvtqn"fg"qrgtcekqpgu"{"hnwlq"fg"ogtecpecu"ogfkcpvg"wp"ukuvgoc"fg"iguvk„p"fg"tgikuvtqu"{"vtcpurqt/
vgu="uqnxgpekc"hkpcpekgtc"cetgfkvcfc0"Guvc"qrek„p"rqftc"rtgugpvct"korqtvcpvgu"fkhkewnvcfgu"fg"eqpvtqn."
{c"swg"ug"vtcvc"fg"gortgucu"guvcdngekfcu"hwgtc"fg"nc"WG."{"hwg"fgugejcfc0
88" Vcngu"cewgtfqu"fg"eqqrgtcek„p"cfokpkuvtcvkxc"fgdgp"vgpgt" wp"ƒodkvq" fg" crnkecek„p"ukok/
nct"cn"fg"nc"Fktgevkxc"42321461WG."fg"38"fg"oct¦q."uqdtg"nc" cukuvgpekc"owvwc"gp"ocvgtkc" fg"eqdtq"fg"
nqu"etfifkvqu"eqttgurqpfkgpvgu"c"fgvgtokpcfqu"korwguvqu."fgtgejqu"{"qvtcu"ogfkfcu0"Gn"Eqpukfgtcpfq"
36"fg"nc"Fktgevkxc"423914677"chktoc"swg" fgdgp"eqphgtktug" c"nc"Eqokuk„p" eqorgvgpekcu"fg"glgewek„p"
rctc"swg"fgucttqnng"guvqu"cewgtfqu0"Eqoq"tghnglc"gn"Vtkdwpcn"fg"Ewgpvcu"Gwtqrgq."Kphqtog"Gurgekcn"p³"
341423;."∋Ι6+%∀&6."cr0"56."cevwcnogpvg"nc"WG"uqnq"jc"hktocfq"wp"cewgtfq"kpvgtpcekqpcn"fg"eqqrgtcek„p"
uqdtg"gn"KXC"eqp"Pqtwgic."swg"gpvt„"gp"xkiqt"gn"3"fg"ugrvkgodtg"fg"423:0"Cfgoƒu."eqogpvc"swg"nqu"
GGOO"pq"cewfgp"c"uqnkekvwfgu"fg"cukuvgpekc"owvwc"gp"ocvgtkc"cfwcpgtc"eqp"vgtegtqu"rcugu"{."eqpetg/
vcogpvg"gp"gn"ecuq"fg"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"swg"rtqxkgpgp"fg"Ejkpc."eqpukfgtcp"ÑguecucuÒ"ncu"Ñrtqdcdknk/
fcfgu"fg"qdvgpgt"wpc"tgurwguvcÒ0"
89" IðOG¥"CTCIðP"etkvkec"swg"c"nqu"kpvgtogfkctkqu"swg"rwgfcp"ceqigtug"cn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"
pq"ngu"korqpic"pkpiwpc"eqpfkek„p"cfkekqpcn"swg"gn"fg"guvct"guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"WG."uqdtg"vqfq"swg"pq"
ug"ngu"korqpic"tgswkukvq"fg"uqnxgpekc"cniwpc0"IðOG¥"CTCIðP."F0."ÑPwgxq"vtcvcokgpvq"gp"gn"KXC"fg"
ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"{"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"c"fkuvcpekc"rctc"fguvkpcvctkqu"eqpuwokfqtgu"hkpcnguÒ."
:/#&/+,#∀5−&/#∀/6+Ο∃8∀∗&/+0∃+ΛΙ∀3∀Η3ϑ"p³"57."4 23:."r0"38"*xgtuk„p"ygd +0"
8:" Wp"cpƒnkuku" gp" fgvcnng"uqdtg"gn" hwpekqpcokgpvq"fg"nqu" tgiogpgu" gurgekcngu"fg"xgpvcpknnc"
¿pkec"c"tc¦"fg"ncu" tgekgpvgu"oqfkhkecekqpgu"swg"jcp"ukfq" crtqdcfcu"gp"OCECTTQ"QUWPC."L0"O0."ÑGn"
pwgxq"tfiikogp"fg" xgpvcu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu" c"fkuvcpekc" fg"dkgpgu"{"nc"igpgtcnk¦cek„p"fgn"tghqtocfq"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
456
tƒ"c"tgrctvkt"nc" tgecwfcek„p"swg"eqttgurqpfc"c"nqu"fkuvkpvqu"GGOO"fg"eqpuwoq"
gp"hwpek„p"fg"ncu"cevkxkfcfgu"nqecnk¦cfcu"gp"uw"vgttkvqtkq0"Gp"gn"ecuq"fgn"tfiikogp"
gurgekcn"fg"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu."nc"fgvgtokpcek„p"fg"gp"swfi"
GO"fgdg"kfgpvkÞectug"wp"gortguctkq"q"rtqhgukqpcn"swg"tgcnkeg"guvcu"qrgtcekqpgu"
fgrgpfg"fg"uk"ug"gpewgpvtc"guvcdngekfq"gp"nc"WG"{"uk"qrgtc"c"vtcxfiu"fg"wp"kpvgt/
ogfkctkq"swg"ng"tgrtgugpvc0"Nqu"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"{"nqu"kpvgtogfkctkqu"guvcdngekfqu"
gp"nc"Wpk„p"fgdgtƒp"kfgpvkÞectug"gp"gn"GO"gp"swg"ug"gpewgpvtg"nc"ugfg"fg"uw"ce/
vkxkfcf"geqp„okec"{."fg"pq"gpeqpvtctug"guvc"gp"vgttkvqtkq"eqowpkvctkq."fqpfg"vgp/
ic"wp"guvcdngekokgpvq"rgtocpgpvg" *GR+0"Uk"vwxkgtc"wpc"rnwtcnkfcf" fg"GRu."rqftƒ"
gueqigt"gn"rcu"fqpfg"ug"tgikuvtctƒ"gp"guvg"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"8 ; 0"Rqt"uw"rctvg."nqu"
uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu"swg" pq"pgegukvgp" kpvgtogfkctkq"rqftƒp" gueqigt"
gn"rcu"fg"nc"WG"gp"swg"ug"kpuetkdktƒp"gp"gn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn0"
Nqu"qdnkicfqu" vtkdwvctkqu" swg" rtgvgpfcp" ceqigtug" cn" tfiikogp"gurgekcn"fgdgtƒp"
eqowpkectnq"cn"rcu"swg"cevwctƒ"eqoq"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec."fgdkgpfq"uwokpkuvtct"fg"
ocpgtc"gngevt„pkec" nc" kphqtocek„p" swg" fgvgtokpc" nc" Fktgevkxc"KXC."eqp" gurgekcn"
ogpek„p"fgn" PKH/KXC"pcekqpcn0" Gn" GO"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"cukipctƒ" cn" uwlgvq"rcukxq"
q"cn"kpvgtogfkctkq"wp"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"gurgeÞeq"c" ghgevqu"fgn"tfiikogp"
gurgekcn"gp"ewguvk„p"9 2 0" Gp" gn" ecuq" fg" kpvgtogfkctkqu"swg" cev¿gp"rqt"ewgpvc"fg"
fkxgtuqu"uwlgvqu" rcukxqu." guvqu" tgekdktƒp"wp"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p" kpfkxkfwcn"
rqt"ecfc" gortguctkq" swg" ngu" jc{c" fgukipcfq"rctc"vcn" ncdqt"9 3 0" Guvg" p¿ogtq" fg"
kfgpvkÞecek„p"gu" rkg¦c"encxg"fgn"ukuvgoc." fgdkgpfq" gn"GO"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p" rtq/
rqtekqpctnq"c"vqfqu"nqu"GGOO"fg"nc"Wpk„p"gp"gn"rnc¦q"fg"32"fcu"fgufg"swg"cecdc"
gn"ogu"gp"swg"jcp"tgekdkfq"nc"kphqtocek„p"fgn"qdnkicfq"swg"ug"fc"fg" cnvc"gp"gn"
tfiikogp"gurgekcn"94 0"
ukuvgoc"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkecrctc"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"kpvtc/WG"eqp"eqpuwokfqtguAÒ."
Ο∃8∀∗&/+?∗Ι/φ∋./+0∃+!∃#∃%1∋+2∀3/3%∀∃#∋."p³"3:3."423;."rr0"39;/4530"
8;" Nc"gngeek„p"fgn"GO"fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p"pq"uqnq"kornkec"swg"fgdgtƒp"ewornktug"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"
ocvgtkcngu"{"hqtocngu"fgn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"gp"fkejc"Cfokpkuvtcek„p"Vtkdwvctkc."ukpq"swg"vkgpg"vcodkfip"
ghgevqu"gp"nq"eqpegtpkgpvg"c"nc"hcevwtcek„p"fg"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu0"Fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"ctv0"43;"5∀∗040d+"fg"
nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC."ewcpfq"wp"uwlgvq"ug" ceqlc"c"nqu" tgiogpgu"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"ncu"pqtocu"fg" hcevw/
tcek„p"ugtƒp"nc"fgn"GO"fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p"{"pq"ncu"fgn"rcu"fqpfg"ug"eqpukfgtg"ghgevwcfc"nc"gpvtgic"fg"
dkgpgu0"
92" Nc"oqfkhkecek„p"fgn"Tgincogpvq"*WG+"4:414233"rtqrwguvq"rqt"nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"{"crtq/
dcfq"rqt" gn" Eqpuglq" guvcdngeg" gzrtgucogpvg." gp"wp"ct v0"79"Ρ−∀3Ρ−∀∃∗." swg" gn" tfiikogp" gurgekcn" fg"
xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"ugtƒ"crnkecdng"fgufg"gn"fc"gp"swg"ug"jc{c"cukipcfq"cn"uwlgvq"
rcukxq"q"cn"kpvgtogfkctkq"swg"cev¿c"rqt"uw"ewgpvc"gn"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p"gurgehkeq"fgn"tfiikogp"
fg"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E0"Rqt"uw"rctvg."kpfkec"swg"gn"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p"swg"ug"cukipg"c"wp"kpvgt/
ogfkctkq"rctc"rqfgt"cevwct"rqt"ewgpvc"fg"wp"uwlgvq"rcukxq"pq"rwgfg"ugt"wucfq"rctc"swg"fgenctg"uwu"
rtqrkcu"qrgtcekqpgu"uwlgvcu"cn"KXC0
93" Gn"Tgincogpvq"*WG+" 423914676"fgn"Eqpuglq."fg"7"fg"fkekgodtg"fg"4239." jc"oqfkhkecfq" gn"
Tgincogpvq";2614232."fg"Eqqrgtcek„p"Cfokpkuvtcvkxc" fgn"KXC."kpvtqfwekgpfq"gp"gn"ctv0"39" wp"pwgxq"
crctvcfq"swg" guvcdngeg" swg"nqu" GGOO" fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p" fgdgtƒp" ocpvgpgt."fwtcpvg"wp" opkoq" fg"
ekpeq"c‚qu." wp" tgikuvtq" fg"nqu"p¿ogtqu" fg" kfgpvkhkecek„p" qvqticfqu"rctc" guvg" tfiikogp"gurgekcn"cu"
eqoq"gn"xcnqt"vqvcn"fg"ncu"ogtecpecu"gzgpvcu"c"nc"korqtvcek„p"fgenctcfcu"ecfc"ogu"rqt"ecfc"uwlgvq0
94" Lwpvq"eqp"guvg"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p"gurgehkeq"fgn"QUU"fg"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E"ug"uwok/
pkuvtctƒ"vqfc"nc"kphqtocek„p"tgekdkfc"gp"gn"tgikuvtq"gp"gn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn0"Guvcu"ewguvkqpgu"ug"kpenwktƒp"
gp"nc"tghqtoc"fgn"Tgincogpvq";2614232."eqpetgvcogpvg"gp"gn"hwvwtq"ctv0"69"ugzkgu." swg"kpvtqfweg"gn"
ekvcfq"Tgincogpvq"*WG+"4239146760"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP457
Nc"korqtvcpekc"fg"guvg"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"{"fg"swg"ugc"eqpqekfq"rqt"vqfqu"
nqu"GGOO"tcfkec"gp"nc"gzgpek„p"c"nc"korqtvcek„p0"Cpvgu"fg"rtgugpvct"nc"fgenctc/
ek„p"fg"korqtvcek„p"gn"qdnkicfq"swg"fgenctctƒ"nc"xgpvc"D4E"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"
Ïuwlgvq"rcukxq"q"kpvgtogfkctkqÏ." fgdgtƒ"hceknkvct"fkejq" kfgpvkÞecfqt"c"nc" cfwcpc"
fgn"GO"fg"korqtvcek„p0"Ncu"cwvqtkfcfgu"cfwcpgtcu"fgdgtƒp"eqortqdct"gngevt„/
pkecogpvg" nc" xcnkfg¦" fg" fkejq" p¿ogtq" fg" kfgpvkÞecek„p" *hwvwtq" ctv0" 69" 3∋3∀∃∗"
Tgincogpvq";2614232+"swg."n„ikecogpvg."fgdgtƒp"vgpgt"cukipcfq"rtgxkcogpvg"c"
nc"korqtvcek„p0"Wpc"xg¦"ugc"eqttqdqtcfq."nqu"dkgpgu"rqftƒp"ugt"kpvtqfwekfqu"gp"
vgttkvqtkq"KXC"ukp"vgpgt"swg"ucvkuhcegt"gn"korwguvq0
Nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC"xc"oƒu"cnnƒ."rwgu"gp"gn"hwvwtq"ctv0"58;"8∀%∀∃∗"cÞtoc"swg"nqu"GGOO."
gp"nq"tgncvkxq"c"nqu"dkgpgu"swg"ug"korqtvgp"crqtvcpfq"gn"p¿ogtq"fgn"tfiikogp"gu/
rgekcn."Ñpq"rqftƒp"korqpgt."c"ghgevqu"fgn"KXC."pkpiwpc"qvtc"qdnkicek„p"q"eqpvtqn"
gp"gn"oqogpvq"fg"nc"korqtvcek„pÒ0"Guvc"fkurqukek„p"eqpÞtoc"nc"kfgc"fg"etgct"wp"
rtqegfkokgpvq"tƒrkfq"fg"korqtvcek„p"Ï)/∗&;/%πκ+rctc"guvqu"rtqfwevqu."swg"pq"
vgpftƒp"swg"ucvkuhcegt"ctcpegngu"pk"KXC"gp"nc"cfwcpc"9 5 0"
Fgdgoqu"gurgtct"c" swg" ug" rqpic" gp" hwpekqpcokgpvq"guvg"ukuvgoc"rctc"eqpq/
egt" nqu" tguwnvcfqu" gp" vfitokpqu" fg" tgecwfcek„p" {" fg" htcwfg0" Ukp" godctiq."pqu"
rncpvgcoqu"uk" guvc" gzgpek„p" c" nc" korqtvcek„p" eqp" rquvgtkqt" fgenctcek„p" gp" KXC"
pq"rqukdknkvc"cniwpqu"fg"nqu"rtqdngocu" swg"rtgugpvc"cevwcnogpvg"nc"gzgpek„p"c"
nc"korqtvcek„p"fg" dkgpgu" fg"guecuq"xcnqt0"Hwpfcogpvcnogpvg"nc" kphtcxcnqtcek„p"
fg"nqu"rtqfwevqu"swg."uk"dkgp"pq"ugtxktƒ"rctc" eqpukfgtctnqu"gzgpvqu"eqoq"jcuvc"
cjqtc."u"rgtokvktƒ"swg"rcugp"nc"cfwcpc"ukp"qdnkicekqpgu"KXC"fg"ectc"c"wpc"hwvwtc"
fgenctcek„p"gp"gn"QUU"fqpfg"ug"eqpukipg"wp"KXC"ow{"kphgtkqt"cn"tgcnogpvg"fgxgp/
icfq"{."cfgoƒu."ug"gxkvg"gn"rciq"fg"ctcpegngu0"
Nc"pq"nkswkfcek„p"fgn"KXC"gp"nc"cfwcpc"fg"korqtvcek„p"eqpnngxc"nc"qdnkicek„p"fg"
tgcnk¦ct"wpc"fgenctcek„p"rgtk„fkec"fg"vqfcu"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"uwlgvcu"cn"tfiikogp"gu/
rgekcn"96 0"Fkejc"qdnkicek„p"vgpftƒ"ectƒevgt"ogpuwcn."fgdkgpfq"gn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"q"gn"
95" Rctc"nc"ciknk¦cek„p"fg"guvqu"vtƒokvgu."{"vgpkgpfq"gp"ewgpvc"gn"gngxcfq"p¿ogtq"fg"gpxqu"swg"
xcp"c"rcuct" rqt" cfwcpc"ceqikfipfqug" cn" pwgxq" tfiikogp" fg" korqt vcekqpgu" D4E."ug" jc"oqfkhkecfq"nc"
pqtocvkxc"cfwcpgtc"rctc"swg"ug"rwgfcp"fgenctct"guvqu"gpxqu"fg"ocpgtc"ukornkhkecfc"eqp"wpc"ogpqt"
ecpvkfcf"fg"fcvqu"swg"wpc"fgenctcek„p"cfwcpgtc"eqttkgpvg0"Cu."gn"ekvcfq"Tgincogpvq"423;13365"tgevk/
hkec"gn"Tgincogpvq"Fgngicfq"*WG+"423714668."oqfkhkecpfq"nqu"fcvqu"swg"fgdg"eqpvgpgt"nc"fgenctcek„p"
fg"korqtvcek„p"c"nkdtg"rtƒevkec"fg"nqu" dkgpgu"swg"ug"ceqlcp"c"nc"htcpswkekc" ctcpegnctkc."fgpvtq"fg"nqu"
swg"ug"gpewcftcp"nqu"swg"eqogpvcoqu"{"vcodkfip"nqu"swg"ug"ceqigtƒp"cn"tfiikogp"ukornkhkecfq"fg"ko/
rqtvcek„p"cnvgtpcvkxq"swg"xgtgoqu"c"eqpvkpwcek„p0"Eqoq"tguwnvc"n„ikeq."ug"gzenw{g"fg"nc"fgenctcek„p"nc"
fgvgtokpcek„p"fgn"ofivqfq"fg"rciq"fg"nqu"korwguvqu"ewcpfq"ugcp"fgenctcfqu"rqt"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"
rgtq"pq"rqt"gn"tfiikogp"fg"korqtvcek„p"ukornkhkecfc"cnvgtpcvkxc0"U"ugtƒ"qdnkicvqtkq."fgpvtq"fg"ncu"Ñtg/
hgtgpekcu"hkuecngu"cfkekqpcnguÒ"swg"fgdgtƒp"kpenwktug"gp"nc"fgenctcek„p."nc"eqowpkecek„p"fgn"p¿ogtq"fg"
kfgpvkhkecek„p"gurgekcn"c"ghgevqu"fg"guvg"QUU"fg"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E0"
96" Swgtgoqu"tgucnvct" swg"nc"Eqokuk„p" Gwtqrgc." gp"uw"kpkekcvkxc" fg"tghqtoc"fgn"Tgincogpvq"
fg"Glgewek„p"fgn"KXC"*EQO*423:+":43"hkpcn+."rtqrqpg"swg"gp"gn"uwrwguvq"fg"swg"fwtcpvg"wp"rgtkqfq"
korqukvkxq"pq"ug"jc{cp"tgcnk¦cfq"qrgtcekqpgu"swg"fgdcp"ugt"fgenctcfcu"gp"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"pk"jc{c"
swg"kpvtqfwekt"tgevkhkecekqpgu"gp"fgenctcekqpgu"cpvgtkqtgu."gn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"q"gn"kpvgtogfkctkq"swg"cev¿g"
rqt"ewgpvc"fgdgtƒ"ewornkt"eqp"nc"qdnkicek„p"hqtocn"fg"rtgugpvct"nc"fgenctcek„p"KXC"eqttgurqpfkgpvg."
kpfkecpfq"swg"pq"ug"jcp"uwokpkuvtcfq"dkgpgu."gp"wpc"fgenctcek„p"fg"rciq"egtq0"Ukp"godctiq."gzenw{g"
cn"tfiikogp"fg"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu."uqnq"crnkeƒpfqug"guvc"qdnkicek„p"c"nc"xgpvcpknnc"
¿pkec"kpvtc/WG"{"fg"ugtxkekqu"gzvtc/WG"*c"nqu"swg"nkokvc"nc"gzrtguk„p"Ñtgiogpgu"gurgekcnguÒ+0"U"ug" fc"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
458
kpvgtogfkctkq"swg"cev¿g"rqt"fin"rtgugpvct"rqt"xc"gngevt„pkec"wpc"fgenctcek„p"swg"
eqpvgpic"gn"korqtvg"vqvcn" fg"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"rqt"ecfc"
GO"fg"eqpuwoq"gp"gn"swg"ug"jc{cp"gpvtgicfq"97 0"Jc{"swg"vgpgt"gp"ewgpvc"swg"nc"
fgenctcek„p"cpvg" nc" xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"uqnq"rgtokvktƒ" kpenwkt" KXC"fgxgpicfq"gp"ncu"
xgpvcu"tgcnk¦cfcu0"Gn"KXC"uqrqtvcfq"gp"ncu"eqortcu"swg"ug"jc{cp"tgcnk¦cfq"gp"nqu"
GGOO"fg"eqpuwoq"fgdgtƒ"ugt"tgewrgtcfq"fg"cewgtfq"eqp"ncu"xcu"pqtocngu"fg"
fgfweek„p"{"fgxqnwek„p"gp"hwpek„p"fg"uk"ug"guvƒ"kfgpvkÞecfq"gp"gnnqu"q"pq0"
Nc"rtgugpvcek„p"fg"nc"nkswkfcek„p"{"gn"rciq"fg"nc"fgwfc"vtkdwvctkc"eqttgurqpfkgpvg"
cn"eqplwpvq"fg"GGOO"fgdgtƒp"tgcnk¦ctug"gp"gn"ogu"ukiwkgpvg"cn"swg"ug"fgenctc0"Gn"
GO"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"vtcpuhgtktƒ"gn"korqtvg"eqttgurqpfkgpvg"c"ecfc"GO"fg"eqpuw/
oq."c"oƒu"vctfct."42"fcu"fgurwfiu"fg"swg"cecdg"gn"rgtkqfq"korqukvkxq"98 0"Cfgoƒu."
nqu"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"swg"ug"ceqlcp"c"guvg"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"fgdgtƒp"ocpvgpgt"wp"
tgikuvtq"fg"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"kpenwkfcu"gp"gn"okuoq."swg"fgdgtƒ"ugt"uwÞekgpvgogpvg"
fgvcnncfq"eqoq"rctc"nc"Cfokpkuvtcek„p"vtkdwvctkc"fgn"GO"fg"eqpuwoq"rwgfc"eqo/
rtqdct"nc"eqttgeek„p"fg"nc"fgenctcek„p0"Gp"gn"ecuq"fg"nqu"kpvgtogfkctkqu."guvg"tgiku/
vtq"fgdgtƒ"tgcnk¦ctug"rqt"ecfc"uwlgvq"rcukxq"rqt"ewgpvc"fgn"swg"cev¿gp0"Gn"rnc¦q"
fg"ocpvgpkokgpvq"fgn"tgikuvtq"ugtƒ"fg"32"c‚qu"990"Cevwcnogpvg."gn"Tgincogpvq"fg"
Glgewek„p"fgn"KXC"eqpvkgpg"nc"kphqtocek„p"swg"fgdgp"iwctfctug"gp"nqu"tgikuvtqu"
rctc"ncu"xgpvcpknncu"¿pkecu"swg"ug"gpewgpvtcp"gp"hwpekqpcokgpvq0"Nc"rtqrwguvc"fg"
tghqtoc"fg"fkejq"Tgincogpvq"*WG+"4:414233"crtqdcfc" rqt"nc"Eqokuk„p" cfcrvc"
gn"ctv0"85" Ρ−/&∃#" c"nqu"tgiogpgu"gurgekcngu" swg" ug"crnkectƒp"gp"4243"9: 0" Jgoqu"
fg"fguvcect"swg."gp"gn"ecuq"fg"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E."fcfq"swg"xcp"c" rcuct"ncu"
cfwcpcu"rqt" gn" ekvcfq")/∗&;/%π."pq"ug" gzkigp" fqu"fcvqu"swg"u" ug" xcp"c"kpenwkt"
gp"nqu"tgikuvtqu"swg"jcdtƒp"fg" nngxctug"gp"gn"tfiikogp"cnvgtpcvkxq"fg"fgenctcek„p"
ukornkÞecfc"fg"ncu"korqtvcekqpguÑp¿ogtq"¿pkeq" fg"gzrgfkek„p"q"gn"p¿ogtq"
wp"vtcvq"wpkhqtog" c"vqfqu" nqu"tgiogpgu"fg" xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec" ewcpfq"gn"qdnkicfq"pq"rtgugpvg"nc"fg/
enctcek„p"swg"fgdc0"Gp"vcn"uwrwguvq."gn"GO"fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p"ng"gpxkctƒ"wp"tgeqtfcvqtkq"gp"gn"rnc¦q"fg"
32"fcu"fgufg"gn"hkp"fgn"rnc¦q"gp"rgtkqfq"xqnwpvctkq."kphqtoƒpfqug"cn"tguvq"fg"GGOO"fg"fkejq"gpxq0"
Nc"rtqrwguvc"fg"nc"Eqokuk„p"fkeg" gzrtgucogpvg"swg" qvtqu"tgeqtfcvqtkqu" {"ogfkfcu"rctc"nkswkfct"gn"
KXC"ugtƒp"tgurqpucdknkfcf"fgn"GO"fg"eqpuwoq."uk"dkgp"guvq"pq"gzkog"fg"nc"qdnkicek„p"fg"rtgugpvct"nc"
nkswkfcek„p"fgn"KXC"cpvg"gn"GO"fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p0"Cfgoƒu."nc"hcnvc"fg"fgenctcek„p"q"nc"hcnvc"fg"rciq."q"gn"
tgvtcuq"gp"guvcu"qdnkicekqpgu."fg"cewgtfq"eqp"guvc"rtqrwguvc"rgtokvg"cn"GO"fg"eqpuwoq"swg"ecnewng"
nqu"kpvgtgugu." ucpekqpgu"{"fgoƒu" ectiqu." swg"ng" fgdgtƒp" ugt"cdqpcfqu"fktgevcogpvg." ukp"vgpgt"swg"
rcictnq"cn"GO"fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p0"
97" Guvg"rnc¦q"eqpvtcuvc"eqp"gn"rgtkqfq"vtkoguvtcn"swg"ug"guvcdngeg"rctc"nqu"tgiogpgu"fg"xgp/
vcpknnc"¿pkec"crnkecdngu"c"ncu"xgpvcu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"{"ugtxkekqu"kpvtc/WG"{"cn"fg"
ugtxkekqu"rtguvcfqu"rqt"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"WG0"
98" Lwpvq"eqp"gn"gpxq"fgn"KXC"fgxgpicfq."gn"GO"fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p"vcodkfip"fgdgtƒ"gpxkct"c"nqu"
GGOO"fg"eqpuwoq"nc"kphqtocek„p"kpenwkfc"gp"nc"fgenctcek„p"¿pkecc"ghgevqu"
fgn"tfiikogp" gurgekcn." korqtvg" vqvcn" ukp"KXC"fg" xgpvcu" c"fkuvcpekc"fg" dkgpgu" korqtvcfqu" tgcnk¦cfcu."
vkrqu"fg"KXC"crnkecdngu"{"fgwfc"vtkdwvctkc"vqvcn0"
99"Gn"rtqegfkokgpvq"rctc"swg"nqu"GGOO"fg"eqpuwoq"rwgfcp"uqnkekvct"vcn"tgikuvtq"guvƒ"tgiwnc/
fq"gp"gn"hwvwtq"ctv0"69"0∃%∀∃∗"fgn"Tgincogpvq"*WG+";26142320
9:" Nc"EQO*423:+" :43" rncpvgc" swg." rqt" oqvkxqu" fg" rtqvgeek„p" fg" fcvqu."pq"ug" iwctfgp" gp"
fkejqu"tgikuvtqu"nqu"pqodtgu"fg"nqu"enkgpvgu"c"nqu"swg"xc{cp"fguvkpcfqu"nqu"dkgpgu."swg"cevwcnogpvg"
fgdgp"tgikuvtctug."fg"eqpqegtug."fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"crctvcfq"m+"fgn"ctv0"85"Ρ−/&∃#030"Guvc"ewguvk„p"vco/
dkfip"guvƒ"eqpvgpkfc"gp"gn"ekvcfq"vgzvq"ceqtfcfq"rqt"gn"Eqpuglq0
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP459
¿pkeq"fg"vtcpuceek„pÒ"{"cn"Ñp¿ogtq"¿pkeq"fg"gzrgfkek„p"ewcpfq"gn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"
kpvgtxgpic"fktgevcogpvg"gp"nc"gpvtgicÒ"9; 0
Ν6Ν6Ψ6+ +?.+#ΦΧ∀∆∃3+/.&∃#3/&∀8∋+/+./+8∃3&/3∀../+α3∀%/+Ι/#/+./+0∃%./#/%∀Η3+
∗∀∆Ι.∀)∀%/0/+0∃.+>Β9+∃3+∀∆Ι∋#&/%∀∋3∃∗
Gn"tfiikogp"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"nc"xgpvc"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"pq"
gu"nc"¿pkec"pqxgfcf"swg"ug"jc"kpvtqfwekfq"rctc"ukornkÞect"gn"hwpekqpcokgpvq"fgn"
korwguvq"gp"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"kpvgtpcekqpcngu0"Nc"Fktgevkxc"423914677."fgdkfq"cn"
eqpukfgtcdng"kpetgogpvq"fg"gpxqu"swg"fgdgp"rcuct"rqt"ncu"cfwcpcu"eqowpkvc/
tkcu."guvcdngeg" wp" tfiikogp"gurgekcn"rctc"nc" fgenctcek„p"{"nkswkfcek„p"fgn" KXC"gp"
korqtvcekqpgu"fg" dkgpgu" *gp" cfgncpvg" tfiikogp" ukornkÞecfq" fg" korqtvcekqpgu+0"
Guvg"ukuvgoc"ugtƒ"fg"crnkecek„p"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"dkgpgu"ew{q"xcnqt"kpvtpug/
eq"pq"ugc"uwrgtkqt"c"372Û"{"swg"pq"guvfip"uwlgvqu"c"korwguvqu"gurgekcngu."tgswkuk/
vqu"swg"eqkpekfgp"eqp"nqu"fg"ncu"pwgxcu"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu0"
Ukp"godctiq."pcfc"ug"fkeg"uqdtg"gn"gngogpvq"uwdlgvkxq"fg"nc"qrgtcek„p."gu"fgekt."uk"
fgdg"vtcvctug"fg"wpc"korqtvcek„p"D4E"gp"nc"swg"gn"fguvkpcvctkq"ugc"gn"guvcdngekfq"
rqt"gn"ctv0"360604"FKXC"q"uk"rqftc"crnkectug"c"vqfcu"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"dkgpgu"
swg"eworncp"vcngu"tgswkukvqu0"
Gn"hwvwtq" ctv0" 58;"∗∃Υ8∀%∀∃∗"FKXC"cÞtoc"swg" uw"wvknk¦cek„p"rqt"rctvg"fg" nqu"qdnk/
icfqu"vtkdwvctkqu"gzkig"swg"pq"ug"ÑqrvgÒ"rqt"gn"tfiikogp"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"
korqtvcekqpgu" D4E0" Nc" tgfceek„p" fg" ncu" qrgtcekqpgu" swg" rwgfgp" ceqigtug" c"
guvg"tfiikogp" ukornkÞecfq" fg" korqtvcekqpgu"rctgegtc"enctc."{c"swg"cn"jcdnctug"
fg"Ñqrek„pÒ"ugtc"tc¦qpcdng" rgpuct"swg"ug"vtcvc"fg" wp"tfiikogp"cnvgtpcvkxq"rctc"
ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"guvtkevcogpvg"kffipvkecu"c"ncu"fgenctcdngu"rqt" nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec0"
Ukp"godctiq."gn"eqpukfgtcpfq"fgekoqswkpvq" fg"nc" Fktgevkxc"423914677"rtqfweg"
eqphwuk„p."cn" gurgekÞect"swg"guvg" tfiikogp"ukornkÞecfq"ug" crnkec"ewcpfq"Ñpq"ug"
wvknkegÒ"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E0"Nc"tgfceek„p"cpinquclqpc"fgn"
hwvwtq"ctvewnq"fg"nc" Fktgevkxc"KXC."rqt"uw"rctvg."wvknk¦c"nc"h„townc" gorngcfc"rqt"
gn"eqpukfgtcpfq" eqogpvcfq." cn" fgekt" gzrtgucogpvg"swg"guvc" ukornkÞecek„p" c" nc"
korqtvcek„p"ug"crnkec"ewcpfq"gn"QUU"Ñpq"ug"wvknkegÒ":2 ."pq"ewcpfq"ukgpfq"wpc"qrg/
tcek„p"uwuegrvkdng"fg"ugt"fgenctcfc"gp"vcn"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"ug"fgekfc"pq"crnkectnc0
Gn"jgejq"fg"swg"qvtcu"xgtukqpgu"cnwfcp"c"nc"wvknk¦cek„p"fgn"QUU"fg"korqtvcekqpgu"
D4E."{"pq"c"nc"gngeek„p."cn"vkgorq"swg"ug"guvcdngeg"swg"gu"wp"tfiikogp"ukornkÞecfq"
9;"Jc{"swg"fguvcect"swg"nc"rtqrwguvc"fg"nc"Eqokuk„p"fg"oqfkhkecek„p"fgn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glg/
ewek„p"fgn"KXC."∋Ι6+%∀&6."kpenw{g"pwogtqucu"oqfkhkecekqpgu"fgn"hwpekqpcokgpvq"hqtocn"{"rtqegfkogpvcn"
fgn"ukuvgoc" fg" xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec ewguvkqpgu" fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p."fg" rqukdknkfcf" fg"ceqigtug"cn" QUU" gp"
qvtq"GO"fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p"ewcpfq"pq" ug"eworngp"nqu"tgswkukvqu"gp"gn"swg"ug" guvƒ"kfgpvkhkecfq."uqdtg"
nc"gngeek„p" fg"wp" pwgxq"kpvgtogfkctkq" ewcpfq" gn"gzkuvgpvg" xkgpg"gzenwkfq" fgn"ukuvgoc" rqt"gn"GO" fg"
kfgpvkhkecek„p."q"ewguvkqpgu"eqoq"gn"tggodqnuq"fktgevcogpvg"rqt"nqu"GGOO"fg"eqpuwoq"fg"ncu"ewqvc"
gzegukxcu"rcicfc."gve0"
:2" Nc"xgtuk„p" gp"kpinfiu"fkeg Ñθ1∃#∃ϑ+)∋#+&1∃+ ∀∆Ι∋#&/&∀∋3+∋)+Χ∋∋0∗ϑ+ ∃Υ%∃Ι&+Ι#∋0−%&∗+ ∗−5Π∃%&+ &∋+
∃Υ%∀∗∃+0−&∀∃∗ϑ+∀3+%∋3∗∀Χ3∆∃3&∗+∋)+/3+∀3∀3∗∀%+8/.−∃+3∋&+∃Υ%∃∃0∀3Χ+?7Ο+Ζε[ϑ+&1∃+∗Ι∃%∀/.+∗%1∃∆∃+∀3+Ε∃%&∀∋3+
_+∋)+:1/Ι&∃#+ς+∀∗+3∋&+−∗∃0"]É̲Ò0"Rqt"uw"rc tvg."vcpvq"nc"x gtu k„p "gp"k vcn kcp q"eq oq"nc"htcpeguc"gorngcp"vco/
dkfip"nc"vgtokpqnqic"fg"pq"wvknk¦cek„p3∋3++−&∀.∀ΣΣ/&∋Ò"{"Ñ3∃∗&+Ι/∗+−&∀.∀∗ΦÒ0
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
45:
rctc"gn" jgejq" korqpkdng" fg" korqtvcekqpgu."Þlcpfq"uqnq" nokvgu" qdlgvkxqu" uqdtg"
nqu"dkgpgu."pqu"jceg"rgpuct"swg"pq"xc"c"guvct"tguvtkpikfq"c"nqu"nokvgu"uwdlgvkxqu"
swg"ug"crnkecp" c" ncu" xgpvcu" c" fkuvcpekc" fg" dkgpgu" korqtvcfqu":3 0" Eqp" guvc" kpvgt/
rtgvcek„p."guvg"tfiikogp"ukornkÞecfq"rqftc"vcodkfip"crnkectug"rctc"vtcpuceekqpgu"
gpvtg"gortguctkqu" q" rtqhgukqpcngu"ÏD4DÏ"q"c"kpvtqfweekqpgu"fg" dkgpgu" gp" nkdtg"
rtƒevkec"ewcpfq"gn"vtcpurqtvg"ugc"tgcnk¦cfq"pvgitcogpvg"rqt"gn"cfswktgpvg":4 0"Cu."
guvctcoqu"cpvg"wp"tfiikogp"ukornkÞecfq"rctc"vqfcu"cswgnncu"korqtvcekqpgu"swg."
pq"fgenctƒpfqug"rqt"wpc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec."guvfip"gzgpvcu"fg"ctcpegngu"c"nc"korqt/
vcek„p."pq"vgpkgpfq"swg"rtgugpvct"wpc"fgenctcek„p"eqorngvc"fg"korqtvcek„p"gp"
cfwcpc":5 0"
Nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC"guvcdngeg"swg"rctc"guvcu" qrgtcekqpgu"nqu"GGOO" fgdgtƒp" rquk/
dknkvct"Ïpq"rwfkgpfq"ugt"fg"wvknk¦cek„p"qdnkicvqtkcÏ"nc"crnkecek„p"fg"guvg"tfiikogp"
ukornkÞecfq."cn" swg" rqftƒ"ceqigtug"nc"rgtuqpc"swg" rtgugpvc" ncu"ogtecpecu"gp"
cfwcpc"rqt"ewgpvc"fg"nc"rgtuqpc"c"nc"swg"xcp"fguvkpcfcu0"Jc{"swg"vgpgt"gp"ewgp/
vc"swg"gn"vgpqt"nkvgtcn"fg"nc"pqtoc"cÞtoc"swg"nc"fgekuk„p"fg"ceqigtug"c"guvg"tfiik/
ogp"ukornkÞecfq"gu"fg"nc"rgtuqpc"swg"rtgugpvc"ncu"ogtecpecu"gp"nc"cfwcpc0"Guvc"
ewguvk„p"xgpftc"fgucttqnncfc"rqt"nc"rtqrwguvc"fg"oqfkÞecek„p"fgn"Tgincogpvq"
fg"Glgewek„p" 4:414233" swg" jc" korwnucfq" gn" Eqpuglq0" Gn" eqpukfgtcpfq" fgekoq/
vgtegtq"fg"fkejc"rtqrwguvc"cÞtoc"swg"nqu"GGOO"pq"guvƒp"qdnkicfqu"c"gzkikt"c"nc"
rgtuqpc"swg" rtgugpvg"nqu"dkgpgu" gp"cfwcpc"swg" ewgpvg"eqp"nc" cwvqtk¦cek„p"fgn"
fguvkpcvctkq"rctc"tgcnk¦ct"vcn" rtgugpvcek„p0"Gn"rqvgpekcn"ctv0" 85"Ρ−/&∃#"fgn"Tginc/
ogpvq"4:414233"guvcdngeg"swg"ugtƒ"uwÞekgpvg"eqp"swg" nc"rgtuqpc"swg"rtgugpvc"
nqu"dkgpgu"gp"cfwcpc"fgenctg"uw"kpvgpek„p"fg"ceqigtug"cn"tfiikogp"ukornkÞecfq"{"
swg"xc"c"tgrgtewvkt"gn"KXC"cn"fguvkpcvctkq"fg"nqu"rtqfwevqu0
Dclq"guvg"tfiikogp."gn" uwlgvq"swg"kpvtqfweg" ncu"ogtecpecu"gp" gn"vgttkvqtkq"cfwc/
pgtq"fg"nc"Wpk„p"fgdgtƒ"tgecwfct"gn"KXC"fgn"fguvkpcvctkq" {"ghgevwct"gn"rciq"fgn"
korwguvq0"Nc"Fktgevkxc."ukp"godctiq."cÞtoc"gzrtgucogpvg"swg"nc"tgurqpucdknkfcf"
:3" Gp"wp"ugpvkfq" ukoknct."IðOG¥"CTCIðP."F0."ÑPwgxq"vtcvcokgpvq"gp"gn"KXCÉÒ."∋Ι6+%∀&6."r0"3:"
*xgtuk„p"ygd+."swg" chktoc"gzrtgucogpvg" swg"Ñecdg"tc¦qpcdngogpvg"gurgtct" swg"gn" tfiikogp"*ukornk/
hkecfq"fg"korqtvcekqpgu+"]É̲"ug"crnkectƒ"gp"nc"rtƒevkec"rtgekucogpvg"gp" uwrwguvqu"fg"korqtvcekqpgu"
tgurgevq"fg"ncu"swg" pq"eqpewttktcp" ukswkgtc" nqu"tgswkukvqu" rtgxkuvquÒ"rctc" gn"QUU" fg"korqtvcekqpgu"
D4E0"
:4" Jc{"swg" vgpgt" gp" ewgpvc" swg" guvg"tfiikogp"ukornkhkecfq" pq" uwrqpg" wpc" xgpvcpknnc" ¿pkec"
fqpfg"wp"GO"tgekdg"nc"tgecwfcek„p"swg"eqttgurqpfg"cn"rcu"fg"eqpuwoq"{"rquvgtkqtogpvg"ug"nc"vtcpu/
hkgtg0"Rqt" gn" eqpvtctkq."guvg"ukuvgoc" kornkec" swg" nc" korqtvcek„p" guvƒ" uwlgvc" {"pq"gzgpvc" {" gn" GO" fg"
korqtvcek„p"tgekdg"vcn"tgecwfcek„p0"Pq"gu"wp"tfiikogp"rgpucfq"rctc"wpc"korqt vcek„p"swg"ug"fgenctg"
gzgpvc"rqtswg."fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"ctv0"365030f+"FKXC."ug"tgcnkeg"gp"nc"cfwcpc"fg"wp"Guvcfq"swg"pq"ugc"
gn"GO"fg"fguvkpq"fgn"dkgp"{"xc{c"ugiwkfc"fg"wpc"gpvtgic"kpvtceqowpkvctkc"fg"dkgpgu0"Cu."guvg"tfiikogp"
ukornkhkec"nc"fgenctcek„p"fgn"KXC"gp"nc"cfwcpc"fgn"GO"fqpfg"nc"korqtvcek„p"swgfc"uwlgvc"cn"rciq"fgn"
korwguvq0
:5"Nc"tgfweek„p"fg"nqu"fcvqu"swg"fgdg"eqpvgpgt"nc"fgenctcek„p"cfwcpgtc"fg"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"
swg"guvfip" gzgpvcu" fg"ctcpegngu"Ïrqt" vgpgt" wp"xcnqt"pq" uwrgtkqt" c"372ÛÏ." guvcdngekfc" rqt" gn"ekvcfq"
Tgincogpvq"423;13365."guvƒ"rgpucfc"rctc"nc"fgenctcek„p"fgn"KXC"fg"cewgtfq"eqp"nqu"fqu"tgiogpgu"
gurgekcngu"eqogpvcfqu."fgdkfq"c"swg"nc"nkswkfcek„p"fgn"korwguvq"pq"fgdg"jcegtug"gp"cfwcpc"*Eqpuk/
fgtcpfqu"ewctvq"{"ugzvq+0"Ug"gzenw{g"rctc"nqu"uwrwguvqu"fg"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"tgeqikfcu"gp"nqu"e„fkiqu"
64"{"85"fgn"tfiikogp"cfwcpgtq"swg"eqttgurqpfgp."tgurgevkxcogpvg."c"wpc"korqtvcek„p"gzgpvc"fg"KXC"
rqtswg"xc" ugiwkfc"fg"wpc" gpvtgic" kpvtceqowpkvctkc"gzgpvc" {" c" wpc"tgkorqtvcek„p"eqp" fgurcejq" c"
eqpuwoq0"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP45;
fgn"rciq"fgn"korwguvq"ugtƒ"fg"nc"rgtuqpc"c"nc"swg"xcp"fguvkpcfc"ncu"ogtecpecu": 6 0"
Gp"guvg"ugpvkfq."gpeqpvtcoqu"ukoknkvwfgu"gpvtg"gn"rcrgn"swg"lwgic"nc"rgtuqpc"swg"
tgcnk¦ctƒ"nc"rtgugpvcek„p"fg"ncu"ogtecpecu"gp"cfwcpc"eqp"nc"Þiwtc"fgn"uwuvkvwvq"
fgn"eqpvtkdw{gpvg."{c"swg"guvctc"qdnkicfq"c"ucvkuhcegt"gn"rciq"fg"qdnkicek„p"vtk/
dwvctkc"rtkpekrcn"{"c"ewornkt"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"hqtocngu."guvcdngekgpfq"nc"Ng{"swg"
gzklc"fgn"eqpvtkdw{gpvg"ncu"ewqvcu"swg"fgdgtƒ"ucvkuhcegt":7 0"
Lwpvq"c"guvg"fgurnc¦cokgpvq"uwdlgvkxq"fgn"rciq"fgn"korwguvq."nc"qvtc"ectcevgtu/
vkec"gugpekcn" fg" guvg"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"gu" swg" uwrqpg" wp"fkhgtkokgpvq"fgn"rciq"
fgn"KXC"c"nc"korqtvcek„p0"Uk" dkgp"gn"fgxgpiq"fg"nc" qrgtcek„p"ukiwg"ukgpfq"gp"gn"
oqogpvq"gp" swg" ug" rtqfweg" nc" korqtvcek„p."ug"rgtokvktƒ"cn"kpvgtogfkctkq"swg"
rtgugpvc"ncu" ogtecpecu"tgcnk¦ct"fgenctcekqpgu"gngevt„pkecu" fgn"KXC"eqp"ectƒevgt"
ogpuwcn."fgdkgpfq" kpfkect"gp"guvcu"nc" vqvcnkfcf"fgn"korwguvq" tgecwfcfq"fg"nqu"
eqpvtkdw{gpvgu"gp" gn" ogu" ekxkn" eqttgurqpfkgpvg" *ctv0" 58;" ∗∃Ι&8∀%∀∃∗+ &∃#+0"Gn"rnc¦q"
rctc"tgcnk¦ct"gn"rciq"{."gpvgpfgoqu."rctc"tgcnk¦ct"nc"nkswkfcek„p."gu"gn"ogu"rquvg/
tkqt":8 0"Fg"pwgxq."nc"tgfceek„p"fg"nc"pqtoc"pqu"igpgtc"fwfcu."{c"swg"nc"fgenctcek„p"
swg"fgdgtƒ"rtgugpvctug"cvkgpfg"cn"KXC"ÑtgecwfcfqÒ."gu"fgekt."gn"swg"gn"uwlgvq"swg"
fgdg"tgcnk¦ct"gn"rciq"jc"fg"uqnkekvct"rtgxkcogpvg"cn"fguvkpcvctkq"fg"nqu"dkgpgu":9 0"
Tgeqtfgoqu"swg" nc"eqpÞiwtcek„p" fgn" tfiikogp" gurgekcn" nkokvc"gzrtgucogpvg"gn"
vtcuncfq"fg"nc"qdnkicek„p"fgn"rciq"fgn"vtkdwvq."rgtocpgekgpfq"guvc"gp"gn"korqtvc/
fqt0"Cu."cn"wvknk¦ct"gn"vfitokpq"ÑKXC"tgecwfcfqÒ"gpvgpfgoqu"swg"gn"tfiikogp"gurg/
ekcn"qdnkic"cn"kpvgtogfkctkq"c"ucvkuhcegt"ncu"ewqvcu"swg"jc{c"tgekdkfq."rgtq"pq"oƒu."
gu"fgekt."pq"nc"vqvcnkfcf"fgn"KXC"fgxgpicfq"uk"pq"jwdkgtc"rqfkfq"qdvgpgt"gn"rciq"
rqt"rctvg"fgn"korqtvcfqt"rqt"ecwucu"swg"pq"ng"hwgtcp"korwvcdngu": : 0"
:6"Rgug"c"swg"ug"wvknkeg"nkvgtcnogpvg"gn"vfitokpq"ÑtgurqpucdknkfcfÒ."gn"fguvkpcvctkq"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"
gu"gn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"fg"nc"korqt vcek„p0"Gpvgpfgoqu"swg"guvg"vfitokpq"pq"cnwfg"c"nc"hkiwtc"fgn"tgurqp/
ucdng"vtkdwvctkq."ukpq"cn"fgdgt"fg"ucvkuhcegt"nc"qdnkicek„p"vtkdwvctkc"rtkpekrcn"swg"vkgpg"gn"eqpvtkdw{gpvg"
fg"wp" vtkdwvq0" Cfgoƒu." uk" qdugtxcoqu" qvtcu"xgtukqpgu"nkpi¯uvkecu"xgoqu" swg" gp" kpinfiu" ug"cnwfg"c"
Ñ∗1/..+5∃+ .∀/5.∃Ò"q" gp"kvcnkcpq"c" nc"rgtuqpc" Ñ&∃3−&/+/.+Ι/Χ/∆∃3&∋Ò."gu" fgekt."ug" guvctc"tghktkgpfq" c"nc"
rqukek„p"fgn"eqpvtkdw{gpvg
:7" Ctv0"5805"fg"nc"Ng{"7:14225."fg"39"fg"fkekgodtg."Igpgtcn"Vtkdwvctkc0
:8" Nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"jc" rtqrwguvq"oqfkhkect"guvg"rnc¦q." {c"swg" fkhkgtg"fgn" qvqticfq"rqt"
gn"ctv0"333"fgn"E„fkiq"Cfwcpgtq"fg"nc"Wpk„p"rctc"gn"rciq"inqdcn"fg"nc"fgwfc"cfwcpgtc0"Gn"pwgxq"rg/
tkqfq"xqnwpvctkq"fg"rciq"cdctectƒ"jcuvc"nc"okvcf"fgn"ogu"ukiwkgpvg"cn"ogu"fg"korqtvcek„p0"Cu."gp"nc"
EQO*423:+":3;"hkpcn."fg"33"fg"fkekgodtg"fg"423:."ug"jc"rncpvgcfq"oqfkhkect"nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC"wvknk¦cp/
fq"guvg"rnc¦q0"Guvc"rtqrwguvc"vcodkfip"hwg"crtqdcfc"rqt"gn"GEQHKP"fg"34"fg"oct¦q"fg"423;."fqpfg"
vcodkfip"ug"kpvtqfwlq"wpc"ewguvk„p"cfkekqpcn"gp"gn"Tgincogpvq"4:414233."swg"rgtokvg"swg"guvc"fgwfc"
KXC"rwgfc"guvct" uwlgvc"c" ncu"tgincu"fg"crnc¦cokgpvq"swg"gzkuvgp"rctc"nqu"fgtgejqu"fg"cfwcpc" gp"gn"
E„fkiq"Cfwcpgtq"fg"nc"Wpk„p0"
:9" Rctcf„lkecogpvg."gp"nc"ekvcfc"tghqtoc"fgn"Tgincogpvq"4:414233"gn"ctvewnq"tgncvkxq" c"guvg"
tfiikogp"gurgekcn"jcdnc"fg"swg"gn"swg"rtgugpvc"ncu"ogtecpecu"gp" cfwcpc"ÑtgrgtewvcÒ"gn"KXC"cn"fguvk/
pcvctkq0"Gpvgpfgoqu"swg"pq"ug"vtcvc"fg"nc"tgrgtewuk„p"gp"gn"ugpvkfq"fgn"ctv0"::"fg"nc"Ng{"fgn"KXC"gp"nc"
swg"gn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"vtcuncfc"nc"ectic"geqp„okec"fgn"korwguvq"cn"cfswktgpvg."ukpq"uqnq"fg"nc"qdvgpek„p"
cpvkekrcfc"fg"nc"ewqvc"c"fgenctct"rqt"nc"korqtvcek„p0
::" Nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC"guvcdngeg"nc"qdnkicek„p"fg"nngxct"wp"tgikuvtq"fg"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"fgenctcfcu"
rqt"guvg"tfiikogp"ukornkhkecfq"rctc"ncu"rgtuqpcu"swg"ug"ceqlcp"cn"okuoq0"Fkejq"tgikuvtq."swg"fgdgtƒ"
vgpgt"gn"fgvcnng"uwhkekgpvg"rctc"swg"ncu"Cfokpkuvtcekqpgu"Vtkdwvctkcu"{"Cfwcpgtcu"fgn"GO"fg" korqtvc/
ek„p"rwgfcp" eqortqdct"nc" eqttgeek„p" fg"nc" fgenctcek„p." fgdgtƒp"iwctfctug"fwtcpvg" gn"vkgorq"swg"
fgvgtokpg"fkejq"GO"fg"korqtvcek„p0"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
462
Rqt"¿nvkoq."fgdgoqu" ogpekqpct" swg" nc" Fktgevkxc" KXC" guvcdngeg" swg"nqu" GGOO"
rwgfgp"rtqjkdkt"nc"crnkecek„p"fg"nqu"vkrqu"fg" KXC"tgfwekfqu"c" ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"
swg"ug"fgenctgp"ogfkcpvg" guvg" tfiikogp" ukornkÞecfq0" Gp" ecuq" fg" vqoct" vcn" fg/
ekuk„p."nc"¿pkec" ocpgtc" fg" rqfgt"dgpgÞekctug"fg" fkejq" itcxcogp" kphgtkqt" ugtƒ"
tgpwpekct"c"guvg"tfiikogp"ukornkÞecfq"{"qrvct"rqt"nc"fgenctcek„p"guvƒpfct"fg"wpc"
korqtvcek„p."tgcnk¦cpfq"gn"rciq"fgn"KXC"gp"cfwcpc0"
60" NQU"UWLGVQU"RCUKXQU"FGN"HWVWTQU"KPVGTHCEGU"
GNGEVTðPKECU
6030" W蚤乃"覇嚢濃派農乃之能這蚤"罵乃"嚢婆能杷波嚢蚤波嚢"把乃覇乃"農乃"能蚤波嚢覇覗嚢埜能乃之能這蚤"嚢農嚢之波覇這蚤能之乃"
嚢蚤"農乃"把覇嚢杷波乃之能這蚤"埜嚢"杷嚢覇琶能之能巴杷"
Wpq"fg"nqu"rtkpekrcngu"ecodkqu"swg"xc"c"gzrgtkogpvct"nc"tgiwncek„p"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"
vtcpuceekqpgu"kpvgtpcekqpcngu"c"rctvkt"fg"4243"gu"gn"rcrgn"vtcuegpfgpvcn"swg"xcp"
c"cfswktkt" nqu" kpvgtogfkctkqu"gngevt„pkequ"vcpvq" gp"korqtvcekqpgu" D4E"eqoq"gp"
fgvgtokpcfcu"vtcpuceekqpgu" tgcnk¦cfcu" rqt" qrgtcfqtgu"pq"guvcdngekfqu0"Nc"cvtk/
dwek„p"fg"uwdlgvkxkfcf"rcukxc"c"ncu"rncvchqtocu"gngevt„pkecu."ukp"godctiq."pq"gu"
wpc"ogfkfc"pwgxc"gp" gn"hwpekqpcokgpvq"fgn"korwguvq0"Gn" ctv0" 4:"fg"nc" Fktgevkxc"
KXC"guvcdngeg" nc" eqpfkek„p" fg" uwlgvq" rcukxq" fg" ncu" rgtuqpcu" swg"kpvgtogfkgp."
cevwcpfq"gp"pqodtg"rtqrkq"{"rqt"ewgpvc"clgpc."gp"wpc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu."
eqpukfgtƒpfqug"swg"jcp"tgekdkfq"{"tgcnk¦cfq"rgtuqpcnogpvg"vcngu"ugtxkekqu0" Gp"
guvcu"ektewpuvcpekcu."qdugtxcoqu"swg"gzkuvgp"fqu"vtcpuceekqpgu"fkuvkpvcuwp"
ncfq."gn"ugtxkekq" swg" tgekdg"gn" kpvgtogfkctkq"{."rqt" qvtq." nc" rtguvcek„p"swg" guvg"
tgcnk¦c"cn"fguvkpcvctkq"Þpcn"fgn"okuoq0"
Guvc"tginc"tguwnvc"fg"crnkecek„p"igpgtcn"rctc"vqfqu"nqu"ugtxkekqu"fg"kpvgtogfkcek„p"
swg"swgrcp" gp" nqu" vfitokpqu"fgn"ctv0"4:"FKXC0"Nc" gurgekÞecek„p"fg"e„oq"fgdc"
kpvgtrtgvctug"{"crnkectug" guvg"ogecpkuoq"c"ncu" rncvchqtocu"gngevt„pkecu"nngi„"gp"
4235"eqp"nc"kpvtqfweek„p"fgn"ctv0";"5∀∗"cn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"fgn"KXC":; 0"Guvg"
guvcdngeg"nc"rtguwpek„p"∀−#∀∗+&/3&−∆"fg"swg"ewcpfq"ug"rtguvgp"ugtxkekqu"rqt"xc"
gngevt„pkec" c" vtcxfiu" fg" Ñwpc" tgf" fg" vgngeqowpkecekqpgu." fg" wpc" kpvgthc¦" q" wp"
rqtvcn."eqoq"wp"ogtecfq"fg"crnkecekqpguÒ"ug"fgdg"cvtkdwkt"uwdlgvkxkfcf"rcukxc"c"
fkejqu"kpvgtogfkctkqu"gngevt„pkequ"cn"eqpukfgtct"swg"guvƒp"kpvgtxkpkgpfq"gp"pqo/
dtg"rtqrkq"{"rqt"ewgpvc"fgn"rtguvcfqt"fg"ugtxkekqu0"Gp"guvg"ugpvkfq."ugtƒp"uwlgvqu"
rcukxqu"fg"wp"ugtxkekq"rqt"xc"gngevt„pkec"Ïgn"swg"guvƒp"tgekdkgpfq"{"rtguvcpfqÏ."
pq"fg"wp"ugtxkekq"fg"kpvgtogfkcek„p"; 2 0"
:;" Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"*WG+"ṗ"326414235"fgn"Eqpuglq."fg"9"fg" qevwdtg"fg"4235." rqt"gn"
swg"ug"oqfkhkec"gn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"*WG+"ṗ"4:414233"gp"nq"tgncvkxq"cn"nwict"fg"tgcnk¦cek„p"fg"
ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu0
;2" Gn"Eqokvfi"KXC"gp"uw"tgwpk„p"p³"329."fg":"fg"lwnkq"fg"4238."chkto„"swg."rctc"swg"wpc"rtguvc/
ek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu"tgcnk¦cfc"gp"wp"gpvqtpq"fkikvcn"ug"eqpukfgtctc"wp"ugtxkekq"fg"kpvgtogfkcek„p."guvc"fg/
dgtc"eqpnngxct"wpc"kpvgtxgpek„p"cevkxc"swg"hwgtc"oƒu"cnnƒ"fg"wp"uwokpkuvtq"cwvqoƒvkeq."gp"gn"ugpvkfq"
fgn"ctv0"9"fgn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"4:4142330"Chktoc"kiwcnogpvg"swg"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"fg"ncu"rncvc/
hqtocu"gngevt„pkecu"swg"rtqrqtekqpgp"ugtxkekqu"cwvqocvk¦cfqu"eqp"wpc"kpvgtxgpek„p"jwocpc"opkoc"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP463
Nc"rncvchqtoc" gngevt„pkec" pq"ugtƒ"uwlgvq"rcukxq" fgn" KXC"fg" nqu" ugtxkekqu" rqt" xc"
gngevt„pkec"gp" swg" kpvgtogfkg" ewcpfq" gn" rtguvcfqt" fgn" ugtxkekq" ugc" tgeqpqekfq"
gzrtgucogpvg"eqoq"vcn"rqt"gn"kpvgtogfkctkq"{"swgfg"cu" tgàglcfq"gp"nqu"cewgt/
fqu"eqpvtcevwcngu"gpvtg"ncu"rctvgu0"Guvg"tgeqpqekokgpvq"gzrtguq"fgrgpfg"fg"swg"
vqfcu"ncu"hcevwtcu"gokvkfcu"gp"nc"ecfgpc"fg"uwokpkuvtq"fgn"ugtxkekq"rqt"xc"gngevt„/
pkec"{"nc"swg"ug"hceknkvg"cn"enkgpvg"kpfkswgp"nqu"ugtxkekqu"rqt"xc"gngevt„pkec"qdlgvq"
fg"nc" vtcpuceek„p" g" kfgpvkÞswgp" cn" rtguvcfqt" fg"nqu" okuoqu0" Gu" gurgekcnogpvg"
tgngxcpvg"nc"eqpetgek„p"swg"jceg"gn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"ewcpfq"cÞtoc"swg"
uk"gn"kpvgtogfkctkq"gngevt„pkeq"gu"gn"swg"cwvqtk¦c"gn"ectiq"cn"enkgpvg"q"nc"rtguvcek„p"
fg"nqu"ugtxkekqu." q" uk" gu" gn" swg" Þlc" nqu" vfitokpqu" {" ncu" eqpfkekqpgu"igpgtcngu"fg"
nc"rtguvcek„p."pq"rqftƒ"kpfkect"gzrtgucogpvg"c"nc"qvtc"rgtuqpc" eqoq"rtguvcfqt"
fgn"ugtxkekq."fgdkgpfq"eqpukfgtctug"gp"vqfq"ecuq"swg"nqu"jc"tgekdkfq"{"gu"uwlgvq"
rcukxq"fg"nqu"okuoqu0"
C"kpuvcpekcu"fg"nc"Eqokuk„p." gn"Eqokvfi"fgn" KXC"jc"fgucttqnncfq"gn" oqfq"gp"swg"
fgdg"ugt"kpvgtrtgvcfq"fkejq"ctv0";"5∀∗"gp"fkuvkpvcu"tgwpkqpgu0"Kpkekcnogpvg."gp"uw"
tgwpk„p"p³"328."fg"36"fg"oct¦q"fg"4238."eqpenw{„"swg"nc"rctvkekrcek„p"fgn"kpvgt/
ogfkctkq"gngevt„pkeq"ewornktc"nqu"vfitokpqu"Þlcfqu"gp"fkejq"ctvewnq"ucnxq"ewcpfq"
uwu"tgfgu" ¿pkecogpvg" rgtokvcp"gn"rtqegucokgpvq"fgn"rciq" {1q" vtcpuokuk„p"fgn"
eqpvgpkfq0"Rctc" fgvgtokpct"uk"ug"fcp"ncu"eqpfkekqpgu" rctc" swg" gn"kpvgtogfkctkq"
gngevt„pkeq"pq"fgdc"ugt"eqpukfgtcfq" uwlgvq"rcukxq"fgn" ugtxkekq." gpvkgpfg"gn"Eq/
okvfi"swg"jc{"swg"cvgpfgt"vcpvq"c"nqu"jgejqu"fg"nc"rtguvcek„p"fgn"ugtxkekq"eqoq"
c"nc"pcvwtcng¦c"lwtfkec"fg"nc"tgncek„p"eqpvtcevwcn"ceqtfcfc"eqp"gn"rtqxggfqt"fgn"
okuoq."rtkocpfq"gp" vqfq"ecuq"nc"tgcnkfcf"geqp„okec"rqt"gpekoc"fg"ncu"eqpfk/
ekqpgu"eqpvtcevwcngu";3 0"
Gn"Eqokvfi"KXC."rqt"wpcpkokfcf."gpvgpfk„"swg"wp"kpvgtogfkctkq"pq"rwgfg"fgekfkt."
gp"eqpvtc"fg"nc" tgcnkfcf"geqp„okec." swg"pq"ug"ng"crnkswg"nc"uwlgek„p"cn"KXC"swg"
rtgxfi"guvc"fkurqukek„p0"Fg"nc"okuoc"hqtoc."vcodkfip"tgeqtf„"wpƒpkogogpvg"nc"kp/
fgtqicdknkfcf"fg"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"vtkdwvctkcu."cn"cÞtoct"swg"ncu"enƒwuwncu"eqpvtce/
vwcngu"swg"pq"tgàglgp"nc"tgcnkfcf"geqp„okec"pq"rwgfgp"korgfkt"swg"ug"eqpukfgtg"
uwlgvq"rcukxq"c"nc"rncvchqtoc"swg"kpvgtogfkc"gp"wpc"rtguvcek„p"fg"ugtxkekqu"rqt"
xc"gngevt„pkec0" Nc" rtggokpgpekc"swg"gn"Eqokvfi" KXC"qvqtic" c" nc"tgcnkfcf"geqp„/
okec"rctc"fgvgtokpct"gn"p¿ogtq"{"nc"pcvwtcng¦c"fg"ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"
gzkuvgpvgu"Ïwpc" q" fqu" {"ugtxkekqu" rqt" xc"gngevt„pkec" q" fg" kpvgtogfkcek„pÏ."jc"
swgfcfq"vcodkfip"tgàglcfc"gp"ncu"fktgevtkegu"Þlcfcu"gp"uw"tgwpk„p"p³"333."fg"52"
fg"pqxkgodtg"fg"423:";4 0
pq"ug"eqpukfgtctƒp"ugtxkekqu"fg"kpvgtogfkcek„p."equc"swg"u"ug"rtqfwektc"uk"gzkuvkgtc"wpc"kpvgtxgpek„p"
jwocpc"pq" cwvqocvk¦cfc0"Uqdtg"gn"eqpegrvq" fg"kpvgtxgpek„p"jwocpc"uwhkekgpvg"{"nc"kpvgtrtgvcek„p"
swg"jceg"gn"Eqokvfi"KXC."xficug"OGTMZ."O0."ÑXCV"cpf"g/ugtxkegukpvgtxgpvkqp"ku"okpkocnÒ."
>3&∃#3/&∀∋3/.+Β9,+=∋3∀&∋#ϑ+Xqn0"4;."p³"3."423:."rr0"39/44
;3" Guvcu"ewguvkqpgu"hwgtqp" crtqdcfcu"ecuk"rqt"wpcpkokfcf0"Vcodkfip"eqp"gn"okuoq"itcfq"fg"
crtqdcek„p"ug"chktoc"swg"nc"uwlgek„p"rcukxc"ug"crnkec"c"vqfqu"nqu"kpvgtogfkctkqu"gngevt„pkequ"swg"rwg/
fc"jcdgt"gp"nc"ecfgpc"fg"uwokpkuvtq"{"swg."wpc"xg¦"swg"ug"jc{cp"fgoquvtcfq"nqu"gzvtgoqu"swg"fgu/
vtw{gp"nc"rtguwpek„p." cn"tgeqpqegtug"gzrtgucogpvg"cn"rtguvcfqt"fgn"ugtxkekq." pq"ug" rwgfgp"korqpgt"
qdnkicekqpgu"cfkekqpcngu"cn"kpvgtogfkctkq0
;4" Guvcu"chtqpvcdcp" nc"vtkdwvcek„p"rqt" KXC"fg" nqu" ugtxkekqu" uwokpkuvtcfqu"rqt"wpc" crnkecek„p"
fg"o„xkn"swg"eqpgevcdc"c" eqpfwevqtgu"{"enkgpvgu"swg"fgocpfcdcp"wp"ugtxkekq"fg" vtcpurqtvg0"Gn"Eq/
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
464
6040" N乃"嚢婆波嚢蚤杷能這蚤"埜嚢"農乃"杷派脳嚢之能這蚤"乃"農乃杷"能蚤波嚢覇悩乃之嚢杷"嚢農嚢之波覇這蚤能之乃杷"播派嚢"
悩乃之能農能波嚢蚤"埜嚢波嚢覇覗能蚤乃埜乃杷"嚢蚤波覇嚢濃乃杷"埜嚢"廼能嚢蚤嚢杷
Nc"rtguwpek„p"fg"uwdlgvkxkfcf"rcukxc"rctc"nqu"kpvgtogfkctkqu"fg"ugtxkekqu"rqt"xc"
gngevt„pkec"jc"qdvgpkfq"dwgpqu"tguwnvcfqu."vcpvq"gp"ukornkÞecek„p"fg"ecticu"hqt/
ocngu"rctc"ncu"rgswg‚cu"gortgucu"eqoq"gp"p¿ogtq"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"fgenctcfcu"
fg"guvc"hqtoc"; 5 0"Cfgoƒu."nqu"GGOO"jcp"eqpuvcvcfq"swg"jcegt"c"ncu"rncvchqtocu"
gngevt„pkecu"tgurqpucdngu"uqnkfctkcu"fgn"rciq"fgn"KXC"Ïctv0"427"FKXCÏ"pq"gu" uw/
Þekgpvg"rctc"ictcpvk¦ct"nc"ghgevkxc"tgecwfcek„p"fgn"korwguvq"Ïeqpukfgtcpfq"9³"
Fktgevkxc"423914677Ï0"Rqt"codqu"oqvkxqu"ug"jc"gzvgpfkfq"nc"uwdlgvkxkfcf"rcukxc"
c"ncu" kpvgthcegu" gngevt„pkecu"ewcpfq" kpvgtxgpicp" gp"fgvgtokpcfcu" gpvtgicu" fg"
dkgpgu";60"
Guvc"pwgxc"tgiwncek„p"ug"gpewgpvtc"gp"gn"ctv0"36"5∀∗+swg"kpvtqfweg"gp"nc"Fktgevkxc"
KXC"nc"Fktgevkxc"4239146770"Guvg"ctvewnq"guvƒ" eqorwguvq"fg"fqu" crctvcfqu"swg"
fkurqpgp"ncu"eqpfkekqpgu"gp" swg" ug" xc" c" fct" guvc" gzvgpuk„p"fg"nc"uwdlgvkxkfcf"
rcukxc0"Codqu"ug"crnkecp"c"nqu"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"swg."wvknk¦cpfq"wpc"kpvgthc¦"gnge/
vt„pkec"eqoq"wp"ogtecfq" gp"npgc."rncvchqtoc." rqtvcn"w"qvtqu"ogfkqu"ukoknctgu."
ÑhceknkvgpÒ"wpc"fgvgtokpcfc"gpvtgic"fg"dkgpguxgpvc"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"
korqtvcfqu"ew{q"xcnqt"kpvtpugeq"pq"gzegfc"fg"372Û="4³+"gn"uwokpkuvtq"fg"dkgpgu"
gp"gn"kpvgtkqt"fg"nc"WG"c"rgtuqpcu"swg"pq"ugcp"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"rqt"rctvg"fg"uwlgvqu"
rcukxqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"Wpk„p0"Ewcpfq"wp"kpvgtogfkctkq"vkvwnct"fg"nc"kpvgthc¦"
gngevt„pkec"hceknkvg"cniwpc"fg"guvcu"qrgtcekqpgu."ug"eqpukfgtctƒ"swg"jc"tgekdkfq"{"
uwokpkuvtcfq"fin"okuoq"vcngu"rtqfwevqu0"
Gp"gn"rtkogt"uwrwguvq."qdugtxcoqu"swg" ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E" gp"ncu" swg"gn"kp/
vgtogfkctkq"gngevt„pkeq"ug"xc"c"eqpukfgtct"uwlgvq"rcukxq"uqp"ncu"swg"vkgpgp" wp"
okvfi"KXC."vtcu"tgeqpqegt"nc"fkhkewnvcf"fg"gpwpekct"wpcu"fktgevtkegu"igpgtcngu"swg"uktxcp"rctc"vqfqu"nqu"
oqfgnqu"fg"pgiqekq"fkikvcngu."ectcevgtk¦cfqu"rqt"uw"itcp" xctkgfcf."cvgpfk„"c"nc"tgcnkfcf"eqpvtcevwcn"
{"geqp„okec"gpvtg"vqfcu"ncu"rctvgu0"Ug"chktoc."ecuk"rqt"wpcpkokfcf."swg"ewcpfq"nc"rncvchqtoc"gngevt„/
pkec"cuwoc"cpvg"gn" enkgpvg"nc"tgurqpucdknkfcf"fgn"dwgp"fgucttqnnq"fgn" ugtxkekq."fgdg" qrgtct"gn"ctv0"4:"
FKXC."{"ugtƒ"uwlgvq"rcukxq"fgn"okuoq0"Ukp"godctiq."ncu"ektewpuvcpekcu"fgn"ecuq"kdcp"oƒu"cnnƒ."rwgu"gn"
Eqokvfi"cpcnk¦„"gn"eqpvtqn"swg"vgpc"nc"rncvchqtoc"fgn"eqplwpvq"fgn"ugtxkekq."nc" rgtegrek„p"fgn"eqpuw/
okfqt"ogfkq"fg"swg"gn"rtguvcfqt"fgn"okuoq"gtc"fkejc"rncvchqtoc"{"pq"gn"eqpfwevqt."{"swg"gn"ugtxkekq"
pq"rqftc"ugt"uwokpkuvtcfq"gp"ncu"okuocu"eqpfkekqpgu"uk"pq"hwgtc"rqt"nc"kpvgtxgpek„p"fg"nc"rncvchqtoc0"
Fcfcu"vqfcu"guvcu"ektewpuvcpekcu."ug"chktoc"swg"pq"gzkuvgp"fqu"ugtxkekqu"fkhgtgpekcfqu"gp"guvg"ecuqwp"
ugtxkekq"gngevt„pkeq"rtguvcfq"rqt"nc"rncvchqtoc"{"qvtq"fg"vtcpurqtvg"rqt"gn"eqpfwevqt."ukpq"swg"ugtc"nc"
rtqrkc"rncvchqtoc"nc"rtguvcfqtc"fgn"ugtxkekq"fg"vtcpurqtvg"fg"xkclgtqu."pq"eqpukfgtƒpfqug"eqoq"ogtc"
kpvgtogfkctkc"gngevt„pkec0
;5" Nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"tgeqpqeg"swg"guvc"rtguwpek„p"jc"ukornkhkecfq"gp"itcp"ogfkfc"gn"ewo/
rnkokgpvq"fg"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"hqtocngu" rqt"rctvg"fg"ncu"rgswg‚cu"gortgucu"fgn"ugevqt."swg"jcp"oc/
pkhguvcfq"uw"crtqdcek„p"fg"guvg"ukuvgoc."ukgpfq"gn"rctgegt"fg"nqu"kpvgtogfkctkqu"gngevt„pkequ"ogpqu"
rqukvkxq."fgrgpfkgpfq"fg"uw"oqfgnq"fg"pgiqekq0"UYF*4238+"59;"hkpcn."fg"3"fg"fkekgodtg"fg"4238."rr0"
95/960"
;6"Ewtkqucogpvg."nc"Eqokuk„p"pq"kpenw{„"guvc"tgiwncek„p"gp"nc"EQO*4238+"979"hkpcn."swg"eqp/
vgpc"nc"rtqrwguvc"fg"nc"rquvgtkqt"Fktgevkxc"4239146770"Hwg"gn"Eqpuglq"gn"swg"ocpkhguv„"gn"cewgtfq"swg"
gzkuvc"rctc"korqpgt"c"ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"{"nqu"egpvtqu"nqiuvkequ"nc"qdnkicek„p"fg"tgecwfct"gn"
KXC"*GEQHKP"727."tgwpk„p"fg" :"fg"lwpkq" fg"4239."r0" 8+0"Gp"nc"tgwpk„p"rquvgtkqt"fgn" GEQHKP"fg"32" fg"
qevwdtg"fg"4239" {c"ug" cxcp¦„"gp" gn"vgzvq" eqortqogvkfq"uqdtg"nqu"ctvewnqu"36"5∀∗."88+5∀∗"{"464"5∀∗+
*GEQHKP":;:+0"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP465
xcnqt"kphgtkqt"c"372Û0"Eqoq"cÞtoc"nc"rtqrkc"Fktgevkxc."ug"Þlc"guvg"xcnqt"{c"swg"rqt"
gpekoc"fgn" okuoq" ug" tgswkgtg" wpc"fgenctcek„p"eqorngvc" fg" cfwcpc0" Eqp"guvc"
lwuvkÞecek„p"rctgegtc"swg"ug"rtgvgpfg"swg"ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"rwgfcp"fg/
enctct"vqfcu"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E" gp"swg"kpvgtogfkgp"c"vtcxfiu" fg"nc"xgpvcpknnc"
¿pkec0"Ukp"godctiq."tgeqtfgoqu"swg"gn"ctv0"58;"&∃#0∃%∀∃∗"gzenw{g"fgn"QUU"fg"ko/
rqtvcekqpgu"D4E"pq"uqnq"c"nqu"rtqfwevqu"eqp"xcnqt"uwrgtkqt"c"372Û."ukpq"vcodkfip"
c"nqu"dkgpgu"uwlgvqu"c"korwguvqu"gurgekcngu0"Pcfc"ug"fkeg"cn"tgurgevq"fg"nc"xgpvc"
fg"nqu"rtqfwevqu"uwlgvqu"c"ceekucu"rqt"rctvg"fg"ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu."rqt"nq"
swg"fgdgoqu"gpvgpfgt"swg"ugtƒp"uwlgvq"rcukxq"fg"vcngu"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E"cwp"
ewcpfq"pq"rqftƒp"ugt"fgenctcfcu"gp"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"{."eqp"gnnq."uw"korqtvcek„p"
pq"guvctƒ"gzgpvc"fg"KXC"gp"cfwcpc0
Gn"ugiwpfq"uwrwguvq"chgevc"c"dkgpgu"swg"ug"gpewgpvtcp"fgpvtq"fgn"vgttkvqtkq"KXC"
fg"nc"WG0" Xc"c"kornkect" nc" tgcnk¦cek„p" vcpvq" fg" qrgtcekqpgu" kpvgtkqtgu"eqoq"fg"
xgpvcu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu" c" fkuvcpekc" fg" dkgpgu." fgdkgpfq" gn" fguvkpcvctkq" pq" ugt"
uwlgvq"rcukxq"{"gn"vtcpuokvgpvg"pq"guvct"guvcdngekfq"Ïpq"vgpgt"ugfg"uqekcn"pk"guvc/
dngekokgpvq"rgtocpgpvgÏ"gp"nc"WG0"Gn"qdlgvkxq"gu"enctq."gxkvct"swg"wp"uwlgvq"rcuk/
xq"swg"pq"vkgpg"wpc"rtgugpekc"guvcdng"gp"nc"Wpk„p"vgpic"swg"fgenctct"ncu"ewqvcu"
KXC"swg"jc"tgrgtewvkfq"c" nqu" eqpuwokfqtgu." fcfc"nc"fkÞewnvcf"swg"vgpftcp"ncu"
Cfokpkuvtcekqpgu"Vtkdwvctkcu"rctc"tgecwfct"eqcevkxcogpvg"fkejq"vtkdwvq"cn" guvct"
nqecnk¦cfq"gp"vgtegtqu"rcugu0"
Nc"tgiwncek„p"crtqdcfc"rqt"nc"Fktgevkxc"423914677."eqorwguvc"fgn"ekvcfq"ctv0"36"
5∀∗."wpc"tginc"gurgekcn"fg"fgxgpiq"{"wpc"qdnkicek„p"fg"tgikuvtq"fg"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"
hceknkvcfcu"rqt"ncu"kpvgthcegu."tguwnvc"ow{"guewgvc."fglcpfq"pwogtququ"kpvgttqicp/
vgu"cdkgtvqu0"Ncu"ekvcfcu"rtqrwguvcu"fg"nc"Eqokuk„p"swg"jcp"ukfq"crtqdcfcu"rqt"
gn"Eqpuglq"gp"uw"tgwpk„p"fg":"fg"oct¦q"rtqhwpfk¦cp"{"cenctcp"owejcu"fg"guvcu"
ewguvkqpgu0"C"hcnvc"fg"uw"crtqdcek„p"fgÞpkvkxc"{"rwdnkecek„p"qÞekcn."cpcnk¦ctgoqu"
ncu"ewguvkqpgu" oƒu"tgngxcpvgu"swg" fgucttqnncp0"Nc"rtkogtc" ewguvk„p"gu"tgncvkxc"c"
swfi"fgdg" gpvgpfgtug"rqt"hceknkvct"wpc" gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu" fg"ncu"ekvcfcu."c" ghge/
vqu"fg"fgvgtokpct"ewƒpfq"fgdg"eqpukfgtctug"swg"nc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec"cfswkgtg"
uwdlgvkxkfcf"rcukxc0"Fgdgoqu"tgeqtfct"swg"gp"guvc"ewguvk„p"gzkuvg"nc"eqogpvcfc"
pqtocvkxc"tgncvkxc"c"nqu"ugtxkekqu"rqt"xc"gngevt„pkec"fgn"ctv0";"5∀∗+fgn"Tgincogpvq"
fg"Glgewek„p"fgn"KXC."rqt"nq"swg"gtc"fg"uwrqpgt"swg"guvc"ewguvk„p"ug"fgucttqnnctc"
eqp"wp"hwpfcogpvq"ukoknct0
Nc"rtqrwguvc"rncpvgc" nc" kpvtqfweek„p" fg" wp" pwgxq"ctv0" 7" &∃#" gp" gn"Tgincogpvq"
fg"Glgewek„p."swg"eqpukfgtc"swg"nc"kpvgthc¦"ugtƒ"uwlgvq"rcukxq"ewcpfq"rgtokvc"cn"
rtqxggfqt"swg"rqpg"dkgpgu"c"nc"xgpvc"c"vtcxfiu"fg"nc"okuoc"{"cn"enkgpvg"Ñgpvcdnct"
wp"eqpvcevq"swg"ffi"nwict"c"nc"gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu"c"vtcxfiu"fg"guc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„/
pkecÒ0"Ug"c‚cfgp"vcodkfip"nqu"uwrwguvqu"gp"swg"pq"ug"eqpukfgtctƒ"c"nc"rncvchqtoc"
gngevt„pkec"eqoq"uwlgvq"rcukxqug"gpectiwgp"fgn"vtcvcokgpvq"fg"nqu"
rciqu="fgn"nkuvcfq"q"nc"rwdnkekfcf"fg"nqu"dkgpgu="q"fg"nc"tgqtkgpvcek„p"fg"enkgpvgu"
c"qvtc"kpvgthcegu"gp"ncu"swg"ug"xgpfcp"nqu"dkgpgu."ukp"oƒu"kpvgtxgpek„p"gp"nc"gp/
vtgic0"Ug"gpvgpfgtƒ"swg"ug"jcp" hceknkvcfq"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"fgn"ctv0"36"5∀∗+ewcp/
fq"nc" kpvgthc¦" gngevt„pkec c+"guvcdng¦ec." fktgevc" q" kpfktgevcogpvg." nqu" vfitokpqu"
{"eqpfkekqpgu" gp"swg"ug"ghgev¿c" nc"gpvtgic="d+" kpvgtxgpic." fg"ocpgtc"fktgevc"q"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
466
kpfktgevc."gp"nc"cwvqtk¦cek„p"fgn"eqdtq"cn"enkgpvg="e+"kpvgtxgpic."fg"ocpgtc"fktgevc"
q"kpfktgevc." gp" gn" rgfkfq" q"nc"gpvtgic"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"; 7 0" Uk" pq" tgcnk¦c" pkpiwpc"fg"
guvcu"vtgu"qrgtcekqpgu."fkejq"uwlgvq"pq"ug"eqpukfgtctƒ"swg"jc"tgekdkfq"{"tgcnk¦cfq"
ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"fgn"ctv0"36"5∀∗0"Gpvgpfgoqu"swg"guvc"pqtocvkxc"fgdgtƒ"ugt"
kpvgtrtgvcfc."c"nc"nw¦"fg" ncu"fktgevtkegu"fgn"Eqokvfi"KXC."gp"cvgpek„p"c"nc"tgcnkfcf"
geqp„okec"{" eqpvtcevwcn" fg"nc" tgncek„p" gpvtg"ncu" vtgu" rctvgu." rtgfqokpcpfq"nc"
rtkogtc"gp"ecuq"fg"eqpàkevq"q"hcnvc"fg"enctkfcf0"
Gn"rtkpekrcn"ghgevq"fg"nc"crnkecek„p" fgn"ctv0"36"5∀∗"gu"swg." c"ghgevqu"fgn" KXC."xc"c"
fgufqdnctug"nc"gpvtgic"fg" dkgpgu" swg" hceknkvc" nc" kpvgthc¦" gngevt„pkec." rcucpfq"c"
gzkuvkt"fqu"qrgtcekqpgu"fkhgtgpekcfcu0"Wp"uwokpkuvtq"swg"ug"rgthgeekqpc"gpvtg"gn"
xgpfgfqt"{"nc"kpvgthc¦"{"qvtc"gpvtgic"swg"guvc"tgcnk¦c"cn"eqortcfqt"swg"pq"ugc"
uwlgvq"rcukxq0"Cu."tguwnvc"kortguekpfkdng"cpcnk¦ct"nc"uwlgek„p"c"KXC"fg"ecfc"vtcp/
uceek„p"{."rctc"gnnq."nc"rtkogtc"ewguvk„p"gu"nqecnk¦ct"f„pfg"ug"tgcnk¦cp"{"ewƒn"gu"nc"
swg"fgdg"gpvgpfgtug"swg"eqpnngxc"gn"vtcpurqtvg"jcekc"gn"enkgpvg0"Nc"kfgc"crtqdcfc"
rqt"gn"GEQHKP"gu"egpvtct"nc"qdnkicek„p"vtkdwvctkc"swg"uwrqpic"gn"rciq"fgn"ko/
rwguvq"gp"nc"xgpvc"swg"tgcnk¦c"nc"kpvgthc¦"cn"enkgpvg"Þpcn."fg"ocpgtc"swg"nc"gpvtgic"
fgn"xgpfgfqt"fgn"rtqfwevq"cn"kpvgtogfkctkq"gngevt„pkeq"pq"vgpic"swg"uwrqpgt"gn"
rciq"fg"wpc"ewqvc"KXC0
Rctc"gnnq."ug"rtqrqpg"nc"kpvtqfweek„p"gp"nc"Fktgevkxc"KXC"fg"wp"pwgxq"ctv0"58"&∃#."
swg"fgvgtokpc"swg"gp"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"swg"ug"gpoctswgp"gp"gn"ctv0"36"5∀∗"FKXC"Ñnc"
gzrgfkek„p"q"gn"vtcpurqtvg"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"ug"korwvctƒ"c"nc"gpvtgic"ghgevwcfc"rqt"
gug"uwlgvq"rcukxqÒ."gu"fgekt."rqt"nc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec0"Ncu"eqpugewgpekcu"fg"guvc"
tginc"uqp" fkuvkpvcu" gp" hwpek„p"fg"uk"nc"vtcpuceek„p"gu" wpc" korqtvcek„p"D4E"*cr0"
3+"q"uk"nqu"dkgpgu"{c"ug"gpeqpvtcdcp"fgpvtq"fg"nc"WG"*cr0"4+0"Gp"gn"rtkogt"ecuq."cn"
wdkect"gn"vtcpurqtvg"gp"nc"ugiwpfc"gpvtgic."nc"rtkogtc"pq"uwrqpftƒ"wpc"gpvtgic"
fg"dkgpgu"uwlgvc"c"KXC."{c"swg"ug"eqpukfgtctƒ"tgcnk¦cfc"hwgtc"fg"nc"Wpk„p0"
Gp"gn" ugiwpfq." rqt"gn"eqpvtctkq."gn" jgejq" fg"swg"gn"vtcpurqtvg"ug" nqecnkeg" gp"nc"
ugiwpfc"gpvtgic"pq"gzkog"fg"KXC"c"nc"rtkogtc."rwgu"nqu"dkgpgu"ug"gpewgpvtcp"{c"
gp"vgttkvqtkq"eqowpkvctkq0"Nc"qrgtcek„p"gpvtg"gn"xgpfgfqt"{"nc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec"
ug"eqpukfgtctƒ"wpc"qrgtcek„p"kpvgtkqt"uwlgvc"cn"KXC"gp"gn"GO"gp"swg"ug"gpewgpvtgp"
nqu"dkgpgu0"Nc"vtkdwvcek„p"fg"nc"ugiwpfc"vtcpuceek„p."fktkikfc"cn"eqpuwokfqt."fg/
rgpfgtƒ"fg"uk"guvg"ug"gpewgpvtc"gp"gn"okuoq"rcu"gp"gn"swg"guvƒp"nqu"dkgpgu"q"gp"
wp"GO"fkuvkpvq."rgtq"gp"vqfq"ecuq."gn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"ugtƒ"nc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec0"Gn"
rtqdngoc"ug"rtgugpvc"gp"nc"rtkogtc"gpvtgic."{c"swg"nc"kpvgthc¦"guvctc"uqrqtvcpfq"
nc"tgrgtewuk„p"fg"wpc"ewqvc"KXC"rqt"rctvg"fgn"xgpfgfqt"fgn"rtqfwevq0"Fcfq"swg"
guvg"uwlgvq"rcukxq"pq"guvƒ"guvcdngekfq"gp"nc"WG."gp"ecuq"fg"pq"rcict"gn"KXC"tgrgt/
ewvkfq"fg"hqtoc"xqnwpvctkc"jctc"ow{"fkhekn"wp"rtqeguq"fg"tgecwfcek„p"eqcevkxc"
rqt"rctvg"fg"nc"Cfokpkuvtcek„p"Vtkdwvctkc"eqttgurqpfkgpvg."tgswktkgpfq"fg"nc"eq/
ncdqtcek„p"fg"rcugu"vgtegtqu0
;7" Gn" vgzvq" crtqdcfq"rqt" gn" Eqpuglq" xctc" ngxgogpvg" fgn" rtqrwguvq" rqt" nc" Eqokuk„p" gp" nc"
EQO*423:+" :43"hkpcn."{c"swg"guvg"wvknk¦cdc"Ñvfitokpqu" igpgtcnguÒ"gp"xg¦"fg" vfitokpqu"{"eqpfkekqpgu"{."
uqdtg"vqfq."gpvgpfc"swg"wp"kpfkekq"fg"pq"ugt"uwlgvq"rcukxq"gtc"pq"kpv gt xgp kt"gp"g n"eqdt q."o kgpvt cu"swg "
gn"vgzvq"korwnucfq"rqt"gn"GEQHKP"jcdnc"fg"Ñcwvqtk¦cek„p"fgn"eqdtqÒ0
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP467
Rctc"gxkvct"guvc"ektewpuvcpekc."ug"kpvtqfwektc"wpc"pwgxc"gzgpek„p"gp"gn"ctv0"358"5∀∗."
swg"chgevctc"c"nc"gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu"swg"ug"tgcnkeg."fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"ctv0"36"5∀∗64."
fgn"xgpfgfqt" pq"guvcdngekfq"c"nc" kpvgthc¦0" Fg"guvc"ocpgtc."nc" ¿pkec" vtcpuceek„p"
swg"fgxgpictc"KXC"ugtc"nc"cecgekfc"gpvtg"nc" rncvchqtoc"gngevt„pkec"{"gn"eqpuw/
okfqt"fgn"rtqfwevq."jcekgpfq"tgecgt"vqfc"nc"tgecwfcek„p"gp"vcngu"kpvgtogfkctkqu"
gngevt„pkequ0"Ukp"godctiq."cn"fgenctct"gzgpvc"nc"gpvtgic"D4D"ug"rqftc"guvct"rtq/
xqecpfq"wpc"ukvwcek„p"eqpvtctkc"c" nc"pgwvtcnkfcf"Þuecn0"Nqu"rtqfwevqu"vtcpuokvk/
fqu"rqt"gn"xgpfgfqt"c"nc"rncvchqtoc"ug"gpeqpvtcdcp"{c"gp"vgttkvqtkq"eqowpkvctkq"
{"ugiwcp"ukgpfq"fg"uw"rtqrkgfcf0"Guvq"kornkec"swg"nc"cfswkukek„p"q"korqtvcek„p"
fg"fkejqu"dkgpgu"ng"uwrwuq"kpewttkt"gp"wp"KXC"uqrqtvcfq"swg."cn"fgenctct"gzgpvc"
guvc"vtcpuceek„p."ug"eqpxgtvktc"gp"pq"fgfwekdng0"Rctc"gxkvct"guvc"eqpugewgpekc."{"
swg"gn"KXC"pq"ug"eqpxkgtvc"gp"wp"equvg"rctc"nqu"qrgtcfqtgu"pq"guvcdngekfqu"swg"
xgpfcp"c"vtcxfiu"fg"kpvgthcegu."ug"rtqrqpg"tghqtoct"gn"ctv0"38;0d+"FKXC."{"swg"guvc"
gzgpek„p"u"ffi"fgtgejq"c"nc" fgfweek„p" fgn" KXC"uqrqtvcfq." rctc" nq" ewcn" fgdgtƒ"
guvct"tgikuvtcfq"gp"gn"GO"fg"cfswkukek„p"q"korqtvcek„p"fg"vcngu"dkgpgu0"
Fcfq"swg"nc"vtcpuceek„p"qtkikpcn"gpvtg"xgpfgfqt"{"enkgpvg"xc"c"fkxkfktug"c"ghgevqu"
fgn"KXC"gp"fqu"gpvtgicu" fg" dkgpgu."gpvtg"rtqxggfqt"g" kpvgthc¦" {" gpvtg"guvc"{"gn"
eqortcfqt."nc"Fktgevkxc"423914677" kpvtqfwlq" wpc" pwgxc" tginc"fg"fgxgpiq"rctc"
nc"qrgtcek„p"fg"nc"swg"gu"uwlgvq"rcukxq"nc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec0"Fkejc"fkurqukek„p"
guvcdngeg"swg"gn"fgxgpiq"fgn"korwguvq"gp"guvcu"vtcpuceekqpgu"{"uw"gzkikdknkfcf"ug"
rtqfwektƒp"Ñwpc"xg¦"jc{c"ukfq"cegrvcfq"gn"rciqÒ0"Eqoq"jgoqu"xkuvq."guvc"tginc"
eqkpekfg"eqp"gn"fgxgpiq"guvcdngekfq"rctc"ncu"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqt/
vcfqu"swg"ug"fgenctgp"c"vtcxfiu"fg"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"*ctv0"58;"Ρ−∀30∃%∀∃∗"FKXC+";8 0"
Rgug"c"swg"guvg"ct vewnq"cecdc"fg"ugt"crtqdcfq."{c"ug"jc"rncpvgcfq"uw"tghqtoc0"Gn"
ekvcfq"ctv0"88"5∀∗"uqnq"cvkgpfg"cn"pcekokgpvq"fg"nc"qdnkicek„p"vtkdwvctkc"fg"nc"swg"
gu"uwlgvq"rcukxq"nc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec."rgtq"pq"gurgekÞec"pcfc"fg"nc"vtcpuceek„p"
gpvtg"gn"xgpfgfqt"{"fkejq"kpvgtogfkctkq0"Nc"oqfkÞecek„p"korwnucfc"rqt"gn"Eqp/
uglq"Ïpq"eqpvgpkfc"gp"nc"Eqowpkecek„p"fg"nc"Eqokuk„pÏ"gu"swg"codcu"gpvtgicu"
fg"dkgpgu" vgpicp" wp" fgxgpiq" ukownvƒpgq." {" rctc"gnnq."ug"rtqrqpg"oqfkÞect"nc"
tgfceek„p"fgn"ctvewnq"cornkcpfq"uw"cnecpeg"pq"uqnq"c"ncu"gpvtgicu"jgejcu"rqt"nc"
kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec."ukpq"vcodkfip"Ñgp"nq"swg"tgurgevc"c"nc"gpvtgic"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"c"
fkejq"uwlgvq"rcukxqÒ";90"
;8" Ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"swg"ugcp"uwlgvq"rcukxq"fgn"KXC"fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"ctv0"36"5∀∗"rq/
ftƒp"tgcnk¦ct"vcpvq"xgpvcu" c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu" *3605∀∗03+"eqoq"qrgtcekqpgu"kpvgtkqtgu"{"
xgpvcu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"*3605∀∗64+0"Gn"fgxgpiq"fg"ncu"rtkogtcu"eqkpekfg"eqp"guvc"
tginc" fg" fgxgpiq" ewcpfq" guvfip" fgenctcfcu" c"vtcxfiu" fg" nc" xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec0" Ukp" godctiq."guvc" tginc"
gurgehkec"fg"fgxgpiq"fgn"KXC"fgurnc¦c"c"ncu"gzkuvgpvgu"rctc"ncu"gpvtgicu"kpvgtkqtgu"g"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"
swg"rwgfcp"jcegt"ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"gp"xktvwf"fg"guvg"ctvewnq0"Gp"guvg"ugpvkfq."nc"cegrvcek„p"
fgn"rciq"guvctc"hwpekqpcpfq"fg"ocpgtc"ukoknct"c"nc"tginc"igpgtcn"fg"fgxgpiq"fg"rciqu"cpvkekrcfqu"
swg"ug"fc"rctc"ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"{"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu."vcn"eqoq"guvcdngeg"gn"ctv0"87"FKXC0"
;9"Jc{"swg"vgpgt"gp"ewgpvc"swg"uqnq"nc"xgpvc"jgejc"rqt"nc"kpvgthc¦"guvctƒ"uwlgvc"{"pq"gzgpvc"
cn"KXC."{"swg"ncu"xgpvcu"jgejcu"cn"kpvgtogfkctkq"pq"guvctƒp"uwlgvcu"c"KXC"gp"gn"uwrwguvq"fgn"360dku03."{"
guvctƒp"uwlgvcu"{"gzgpvcu"gp"ncu"gpvtgicu"fgn"360dku040"Cu."{"c"hcnvc"fg"uw"crtqdcek„p"fghkpkvkxc."gpvgp/
fgoqu"swg"guvc"gzvgpuk„p"fg"nc"tginc"fg"fgxgpiq"guvctc"rgpucfc"rctc"ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"swg"{c"
ug"gpeqpvtctcp"fgpvtq"fg"nc"WG0"Pq"qduvcpvg."fcfq"gn"ectƒevgt"gzgpvq"fg"fkejcu"xgpvcu."uw"kornkecek„p"
cegtec"fgn"rgtkqfq"gurgehkeq" gp"swg" gn"KXC"ugtƒ"nkswkfcfq" cvkgpfg"c" nc"vtcpuceek„p"tgcnk¦cfc" rqt"nc"
kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec0"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
468
Gp"guvg"ugpvkfq."nc"rtqrwguvc"fg"nc"Eqokuk„p"fg"tghqtoc"fgn"Tgincogpvq"4:414233"
crtqdcfc"rqt"gn"Eqpuglq"gurgekÞec"nc"cegrvcek„p"fgn"rciq"fgn"okuoq"oqfq"gp"
swg"ug"fgvgtokp„"rctc"gn"ekvcfq"tfiikogp"gurgekcn0"Gn"hwvwtkdng"ctv0"63"5∀∗"fgn"Tg/
incogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p."cn"kiwcn"swg"uw"jqo„nqiq"ctv0"83"&∃#."cÞtoc"swg"gn"rciq"
ug"gpvkgpfg"cegrvcfq"ewcpfq"gn"rtqxggfqt"swg" xgpfg"nqu"dkgpgu" c"vtcxfiu"fg"nc"
kpvgthc¦"tgekdg"nc"eqpÞtocek„p"fgn"rciq."gn"ogpuclg"fg"cwvqtk¦cek„p"fgn"okuoq"q"
wp"eqortqokuq"fg"rciq"fgn"enkgpvg."Ñnq"swg"qewttc"rtkogtq"]É̲"eqp"kpfgrgpfgp/
ekc"fg"ewƒpfq"ug" jc{c"ghgevwcfq"gn"rciq"ghgevkxq"fg"fkpgtqÒ0"Jc{"swg"vgpgt"gp"
ewgpvc"swg"guvg"etkvgtkq"jceg"fgrgpfgt"gn"fgxgpiq"fg"nc"gpvtgic"jgejc"rqt"nc"kp/
vgthc¦"fgn"eqpqekokgpvq"rqt"rctvg"fgn"rtqxggfqt."pq"fgn"kpvgtogfkctkq."fg"swg"ug"
jc"ucvkuhgejq"q."cn"ogpqu."ug"jc"qdvgpkfq"wp"eqortqokuq"fg"rciq"fgn"rtgekq0"Gp"
cswgnnqu"ecuqu"gp"swg"nc"kpvgthc¦"tgcnk¦c"vcodkfip"cevkxkfcfgu"fg"eqdtq"q"fg"cwvq/
tk¦cek„p"fgn"okuoq."rqftƒ"eqpqegt"gn"oqogpvq"fgn"fgxgpiq"fg"nc"qrgtcek„p0"Ukp"
godctiq."uk"gn"kpvgtogfkctkq"gngevt„pkeq"tgcnk¦ctc"vctgcu"swg"kornkecp"uw"ectƒevgt"
fg"uwlgvq"rcukxq"rgtq"pq"vwxkgtc"wp"eqpqekokgpvq"fktgevq"fg"fkejc"cwvqtk¦cek„p"
fg"eqdtq."fgrgpfgtƒ"fg"nc"kphqtocek„p"fcfc"rqt"gn"rtqxggfqt"q"rqt"gn"iguvqt"fgn"
eqdtq"rctc"eqpqegt"ewƒpfq"ug"jc"fgxgpicfq"nc"vtcpuceek„p"gp"ewguvk„p0"
6050" U能覗把農能悩能之乃之能巴蚤嚢杷"悩巴覇覗乃農嚢杷"罵"杷派杷波乃蚤之能乃農嚢杷"把乃覇乃"農乃杷"能蚤波嚢覇悩乃之嚢杷"
嚢農嚢之波覇這蚤能之乃杷"播派嚢"杷嚢乃蚤"之巴蚤杷能埜嚢覇乃埜乃杷"杷派脳嚢波巴"把乃杷能琶巴"
Guvc"pwgxc" tgiwncek„p" uwrqpg" jcegt" tgecgt"vqfcu"ncu" ecticu" hqtocngu" fg"guvcu"
vtcpuceekqpgu"gp"ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu0"Rctc"tgnclct"cniwpc"fg"ncu"ewguvkqpgu"
swg"rqftcp"uwrqpgt"oc{qtgu"eqornkecekqpgu"rctc"guvqu"uwlgvqu"ug"jcp"rtqrwgu/
vq"fqu"tgincu"cfkekqpcngu"c"kpvtqfwekt"gp"gn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"fgn"KXC0"Nc"
rtkogtc"gu"tgncvkxc"c"nc"fgvgtokpcek„p"fg"nc"pcvwtcng¦c"lwtfkec"vcpvq"fgn"xgpfgfqt"
eqoq"fgn"eqortcfqt"fg"ncu"gpvtgicu"gp"swg"kpvgtxkgpg0"Eqoq"jgoqu"eqogpvc/
fq."ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"eqpvgpkfcu" gp"gn"ctv0"36"5∀∗"uqp" qrgtcekqpgu"D4E."gu"fgekt."
fg"wp"uwlgvq"rcukxq"c"wpc"rgtuqpc"swg"pq"quvgpvc"guvc"ewcnkfcf0"Ncu"rncvchqtocu"
gngevt„pkecu."rctc"rqfgt"fgvgtokpct"uk"uqp"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"q"pq"fg"ncu"gpvtgicu"gp"
swg"kpvgtogfkgp." fgdgtcp" vgpgt"kphqtocek„p"uwÞekgpvg"uqdtg"nqu"kpvgtxkpkgpvgu"
gp"nc"vtcpuceek„p0"Rctc"gxkvct"guvc"ectic"fg"vgpgt"swg"qdvgpgt"ogfkqu"fg"rtwgdc"
cn"tgurgevq."ug"rncpvgc"wp"pwgxq"ctv0"7"Ρ−∀3Ρ−∀∃∗"fgn"Tgincogpvq"4:414233."swg"
guvcdngeg"wpc" rtguwpek„p" ∀−#∀∗+ &/3&−∆ucnxq"swg"nc"kpvgthc¦"fkurqpic"fg" kphqt/
ocek„p"swg"kpfkswg"nq"eqpvtctkq."ug"eqpukfgtc"swg"nc"rgtuqpc"swg"xgpfg"dkgpgu"c"
vtcxfiu"fg"fkejc"rncvchqtoc"gu"uwlgvq"rcukxq."{"swg"nc"rgtuqpc"swg"nqu"cfswkgtg"pq"
nq"gu0" Cu."nqu"kpvgtogfkctkqu" gngevt„pkequ"fgdgtƒp"rtguwokt."ucnxq"swg"nqu"kpvgt/
xkpkgpvgu"gp"nc"vtcpuceek„p"ng"rtqrqtekqpgp"ogfkqu"fg"rtwgdc"gp"eqpvtctkq"Ïrqt"
gl0."swg"gn" cfswktgpvg" uqnkekvctc" wpc" hcevwtc" eqorngvc" crqtvcpfq" uw" p¿ogtq" fg"
kfgpvkÞecek„p"KXCÏ."swg"gp"vqfcu"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"tgeqikfcu"gp"gn"ctv0"36"5∀∗"gp"
swg"kpvgtxgpicp"ugtƒp"nqu"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"fgn"korwguvq0"Ug"ngu"nkdgtc."rqt"vcpvq."
fg"nc"ectic"fg"rtqdct"nc"pcvwtcng¦c"lwtfkec"fg"cfswktgpvg"{"eqortcfqt0"
Lwpvq"eqp"guvc"rtguwpek„p." vcodkfip"ug"rtqrqpg"kpvtqfwekt"wp" ctvewnq" gp"gn"Tg/
incogpvq"4:414233"swg"tgdclg"uwuvcpekcnogpvg"nc"tgurqpucdknkfcf"fg"nc"kpvgthc¦"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP469
gngevt„pkec0"Gp"hwpek„p"fg" ncu"cevkxkfcfgu"swg"ug"eqpukfgtcp"swg"rwgfg" tgcnk¦ct"
wp"kpvgtogfkctkq"gngevt„pkeq"rctc" hceknkvct"ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"fgn"ctv0"36"5∀∗."
gu"rqukdng"swg"uw"kpvgtxgpek„p"pq"cdctswg"ncu"ceekqpgu"fg"cwvqtk¦cek„p"fgn"rciq."
rwfkgpfq"fgueqpqegt"nc"ecpvkfcf"ghgevkxcogpvg"ucvkuhgejc"rqt"gn"eqpuwokfqt0"Gp"
vcngu"ecuqu."eqoq"uwlgvq"rcukxq"fgn"korwguvq."rqftc"guvct"fgenctcpfq"eqp"dwgpc"
hg."gp"dcug"c"nc"kphqtocek„p"rtqrqtekqpcfc"rqt"gn"xgpfgfqt."wpc"ewqvc"KXC"kphgtkqt"
c"nc" eqttgurqpfkgpvg" cn"rtgekq"tgcn"fg" nc" vtcpuceek„p0"Rctc"gxkvct" swg" nc" kpvgthc¦"
gngevt„pkec"tgurqpfc"gp"guvqu"uwrwguvqu"ug"kpvtqfwektc"wp"pwgxq"ctv0"7"Ρ−/&∃#"gp"
gn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p0"
Guvg"gnkokpctc" nc" tgurqpucdknkfcf" fgn" rciq" fg" wp"KXC"kphgtkqt" cn" tgcnogpvg" fg/
xgpicfq"ewcpfq"ug"fkgtcp"ukownvƒpgcogpvg"vtgu"ektewpuvcpekcu+"swg"nc"kpvgthc¦"
fgrgpfg"fg"nc"kphqtocek„p"fcfc"rqt"gn"rtqxggfqt"rctc"fgenctct"{"rcict"gn"KXC"fg"
ncu"gpvtgicu"gp"swg"kpvgtxgpic="d+"swg"fkejc"kphqtocek„p"tgekdkfc"ugc"kpeqttgevc="
e+"swg"nc"kpvgthc¦"rwgfc"fgoquvtct"swg"pq"ucdc."pk"rqftc"tc¦qpcdngogpvg"ucdgt."
swg"vcn"kphqtocek„p"gtc"kpeqttgevc0"Gp"vqfq"ecuq."rgug"c"swg"nc"kpvgthc¦"rqftƒ"nk/
dtctug"fg"ugt"tgurqpucdng"fg"fkejc"ewqvc"uwrgtkqt."fgdgoqu"fguvcect"swg"nc"ectic"
fg"nc"rtwgdc"ug"kpxkgtvg"{"swg"gu"gn"kpvgtogfkctkq"gngevt„pkeq"gn"swg"fgdg"fgoqu/
vtct"uw"dwgpc"hg."eqp"nqu"eqpukiwkgpvgu"equvgu"kpfktgevqu"swg"guvq"rwgfg"eqpnngxct0"
Nc"korqtvcpekc"fg"ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"gp"nc"tgecwfcek„p"fg"ewqvcu"fg"KXC"
swg"eqttgurqpfgtƒp"c"xgpvcu"uwlgvcu"gp"nqu"fkuvkpvqu"GGOO"jc"igpgtcfq"vcodkfip"
swg"ug"kpvtqfw¦ec"wpc"qdnkicek„p"cfkekqpcn"fg"tgikuvtct"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"gp"ncu"swg"
jcp"kpvgtxgpkfq0" Gn" hwvwtq" ctv0" 464" 5∀∗"FKXC"guvcdngeg"swg"guvqu"kpvgtogfkctkqu"
gngevt„pkequ."ewcpfq"ÑhceknkvgpÒ"wpc" gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu"q"rtguvcek„p" fg"ugtxkekqu"
tgcnk¦cfcu"c"rgtuqpcu"swg"pq"ugcp"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"vgpftƒp"swg"nngxct"wp"tgikuvtq"
fg"ncu" vtcpuceekqpgu" swg" jc{cp" hceknkvcfq"; : 0"Gn"tgikuvtq."swg" fgdgtƒ" ocpvgpgtug"
fwtcpvg"wp"rgtkqfq"fg"32" c‚qu."fgdgtƒ"vgpgt"gn" uwÞekgpvg"fgvcnng"rctc"rgtokvkt"
swg"ncu"Cfokpkuvtcekqpgu"vtkdwvctkcu"fg"nqu"GGOO"fg"eqpuwoq"rwgfcp"eqortq/
dct"nc"eqttgeek„p"fg"nc"vtkdwvcek„p0"
Nc"qdnkicek„p"fg"ocpvgpkokgpvq"fg"guvqu"tgikuvtqu"pq"ug"crnkec"¿pkecogpvg"c"ncu"
kpvgthcegu"swg"tgcnkegp"ncu"gpvtgicu"tgiwncfcu"gp"gn"ctv0"36"5∀∗."ukpq"swg"kpenwktƒp"
vqfcu"ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"{"ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"xgpfkfqu"c"rgtuqpcu"
swg"pq"ugcp"gortguctkq"q"rtqhgukqpcn"gp"ncu"swg"nc"kpvgthc¦"jc{c"rgtokvkfq"gpvc/
dnct"eqpvcevq"c"enkgpvgu"{"rtqxggfqtgu0"Jc{"swg"vgpgt"gp"ewgpvc"swg"nc"tgfceek„p"
fgn"ctv0" 464" 5∀∗" pq"ug"tgÞgtg"gzrtgucogpvg"c"swg" gn" tgikuvtq" jc{c" swg" nngxctnq"
¿pkecogpvg"fg"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"swg"qvqticp"nc"uwdlgvkxkfcf"rcukxc"fg"nc"okuoc"
c"nc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec."pk"vcorqeq"ug"gzkig"swg"ug"vtcvg"fg"qrgtcekqpgu"vtcpu/
htqpvgtk¦cu0"Gn"vgpqt"fg"guvg"ctvewnq"rctgeg"gzvgpfgtug"c"vqfcu"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"
D4E"fg"dkgpgu"{"ugtxkekqu"swg"ug"xgcp"hceknkvcfcu"rqt"wpc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec"; ; 0"
;:" Nc"rtqrwguvc"fg"tghqtoc"fgn"Tgincogpvq"4:414233"kpeqtrqtc"wp"ctv0"75"&∃#"fqpfg"eqpetgvc"
swfi"fgdg"gpvgpfgtug"rqt"ÑhceknkvctÒ"c"ghgevqu"fg"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"fg"ncu"swg"jc{"swg"ocpvgpgt"tgikuvtq0"
Tgcnogpvg"pq"gu"oƒu" swg"wpc"tgrgvkek„p" fg"nc"eqpetgek„p" fgn"vfitokpq"c" ghgevqu"fgn"ct v0"36"5∀∗"rgtq"
gzvgpfkgpfq"uw"crnkecek„p"c"ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu0"
;;" Gn"ctv0"464"5∀∗"jcdnc"nkvgtcnogpvg"fg" Ñgn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"vkvwnct" fg"nc" kpvgthc¦Ò."rgtq"pq"eqpuk/
fgtcoqu"swg"guvq"kornkswg"nkokvct"nc"qdnkicek„p"fg"tgikuvtq"c"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"gp"ncu"swg"guvg"kpvgt/
ogfkctkq"gngevt„pkeq"rcuc"c"ugt"uwlgvq"rcukxq"fg"uw"tgcnk¦cek„p0"Fg"jgejq."cn"cpcnk¦ct"gn"fgucttqnnq"fgn"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
46:
Nc"rtqrwguvc"fg"tghqtoc"fgn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p"fgn"KXC"fkhgtgpekc"nc"kphqt/
ocek„p"swg"fgdg"eqpvgpgt"gn"tgikuvtq"gp"hwpek„p"fg"uk"ug"vtcvc"fg"ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"
dkgpgu"fgn"ctv0"36"5∀∗"{"ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"rqt"xc"gngevt„pkec"gp"ncu"swg"
ug"rctvkekrg"fg"cewgtfq" eqp"gn"ctv0" ;"5∀∗"fgn"ekvcfq"Tgincogpvq."gp"ncu"swg"xc"c"
eqpukfgtctug"uwlgvq"rcukxq"fg"ncu"xgpvcu"cn"eqpuwokfqt"Þpcn."q"uk"ug"vtcvc"fg"qvtcu"
qrgtcekqpgu0"Gp"gn"ecuq"fg"ncu"rtkogtcu."nc"rtqrwguvc"fkhgtgpekc"gp"hwpek„p"fg"uk."
eqoq"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu."jcp"fgenctcfq"fkejcu"qrgtcekqpgu"c"vtcxfiu"fg"uw"xgpvcpknnc"
¿pkec"eqttgurqpfkgpvg"q"pq0"Gp"ecuq"fg"jcdgtug"nkswkfcfq"c"vtcxfiu"fg"guvqu"tgi/
ogpgu"gurgekcngu."nc"kphqtocek„p"swg"jcdtƒ"swg"tgikuvtct"ugtƒ"nc"guvcdngekfc"rqt"
gn"ctv0"85"Ρ−/&∃#"rctc"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"ceqikfcu"cn" QUU"3 2 2 0"Rqt"gn" eqpvtctkq."uk"ug"
jc"qrvcfq"rqt"pq"wvknk¦ct"guvg"ukuvgoc."fgdgtƒp"ewornktug"nqu"fkevcfqu"fgn"ctv0"464"
FKXC."swg"gzkig"nngxct"wpc"eqpvcdknkfcf"uwÞekgpvgogpvg"fgvcnncfc"rctc"rgtokvkt"gn"
eqpvtqn"vtkdwvctkq0"Rctgeg"n„ikeq"rgpuct"swg"uk"ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"cfswkg/
tgp"uwdlgvkxkfcf"rcukxc"{"vkgpgp"swg"fgenctct"qrgtcekqpgu."fgdgtƒp"ocpvgpgt"nqu"
tgikuvtqu"swg"{c"gzkuvgp"rctc"fkejcu"qdnkicekqpgu"vtkdwvctkcu0"
Rqt" uw"rctvg."rctc"gn" tguvq"fg" vtcpuceekqpgu"swg"jc{c"hceknkvcfq"nc"kpvgthc¦."nc"kp/
hqtocek„p"swg"fgdgtƒp"iwctfct"xkgpg"fgvgtokpcfc"gp"gn"rqvgpekcn"ctv0"76"Ρ−/&∃#"
fgn"Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„pnqu"dkgpgu"q"ugtxkekqu"vtcpu/
okvkfqu."uw"xcnqt"{."uk"guvƒ"fkurqpkdng."kphqtocek„p"uqdtg"gn"nwict" fg"nngicfc"fgn"
vtcpurqtvg"{"fgn"oqogpvq"fg"nc"gpvtgic"q"gn"nwict"{"oqogpvq"fg"nc"rtguvcek„p"
fgn"ugtxkekq=" d+" gn" pqodtg"{" fktgeek„p"fgn" rtqxggfqt"{." uk" guvƒp" fkurqpkdngu." uw"
fktgeek„p"gngevt„pkec"q"ukvkq"ygd."uw"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"KXC"{"gn"p¿ogtq"fg"
nc"ewgpvc"dcpectkc"q" xktvwcn" fg"fkejq"xgpfgfqt0"Cu."nqu"GGOO"rqftƒp"fkurqpgt"
fg"nc" kphqtocek„p"fg"vqfcu"ncu" vtcpuceekqpgu"D4E"gp"swg" hceknkvgp"ncu"kpvgthcegu"
gngevt„pkecu"{"pq"ugcp"uwlgvq"rcukxq."rqt"glgornq"gp"xgpvcu"kpvgtkqtgu"q"gp"xgpvcu"
kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"D4E"gp"ncu"swg"gn"rtqxggfqt"guvfi"guvcdngekfq"gp"nc"WG0"Nc"kphqt/
ocek„p"swg"cnocegpctƒp"gp"guvqu"ecuqu"ugtƒ"kphgtkqt."{c"swg"uw"wvknkfcf"ugtƒ"swg"
ncu"Cfokpkuvtcekqpgu"vtkdwvctkcu"rwgfcp"fktkiktug"rquvgtkqtogpvg"cn"rtqxggfqt"fgn"
uwokpkuvtq0"
Rqt"¿nvkoq."fgdgoqu"eqogpvct"swg"ug"jc"rtqrwguvq"wpc"oqfkÞecek„p"fgn"cnecp/
eg"fg" nc" xgpvcpknnc" ¿pkec"kpvtc/WG"rctc"cdctect" gn"uwrwguvq"eqpvgpkfq"gp" gn" ctv0"
3605∀∗04."gp"gn"swg"nc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec"hceknkvc"gpvtgicu"D4E"fg"dkgpgu"swg"{c"ug"
gpewgpvtcp"gp"nc"WG."gp"ncu"swg"gn"xgpfgfqt"pq"guvƒ"guvcdngekfq"gp"nc"Wpk„p0"Nqu"
kpvgtogfkctkqu"gngevt„pkequ."gp"hwpek„p"fg"guvg"ctvewnq."rwgfgp"xgpfgt"rtqfwe/
vqu"swg"guvfip"gp"wp"GO"c"eqpuwokfqtgu"nqecnk¦cfqu"vcpvq"gp"fkejq"rcu"eqoq"gp"
qvtqu"GGOO0"Cu."rwgfgp"ugt"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"vcpvq"fg"xgpvcu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"c"
fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu."swg"rqftcp"fgenctctug"gp"uw"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"eqttgurqpfkgp/
Tgincogpvq"fg"Glgewek„p."gn"hwvwtq"ctv0"76"Ρ−/&∃#"fkhgtgpekc"gpvtg"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"fgn"ctv0"3605∀∗"{"
qvtcu."nq"swg"pqu"jceg"eqpenwkt"swg"fgdgtƒp"ocpvgpgt"wp"tgikuvtq"fg"vqfcu"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"swg"ug"
ceqogvcp"c"vtcxfiu"fg"vcngu"kpvgthcegu."ugcp"qrgtcekqpgu"kpvgtkqtgu"Ïkpenwkfcu"fg"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"guvc/
dngekfqu"gp"nc"WGÏ"q"xgpvcu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu0"
322"Eqoq"jgoqu"xkuvq."fkejq" ctvewnq."rtqrwguvq" gp"nc" tghqtoc"fgn" Tgincogpvq"fg" Glgewek„p"
fgn"KXC."gu"gn"swg"fgvgtokpc"nc"kphqtocek„p"swg"fgdg"iwctfctug"gp"nqu"tgikuvtqu"fg"nqu"tgiogpgu"fg"
xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"qrgtcekqpgu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu." vcpvq" xgpvcu"c" fkuvcpekc"eqoq"rtguvcekqpgu" fg"
ugtxkekqu."{"rctc"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu0"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP46;
vg."eqoq"fg"qrgtcekqpgu"kpvgtkqtgu0"Nc"hqtowncek„p"gzkuvgpvg"fgn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"
rctc"gpvtgicu"fg" dkgpgu"{"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"kpvtc/WG" pq"rgtokvg"swg"ug"
fgenctgp"qrgtcekqpgu"swg"pq"ugcp"vtcpuhtqpvgtk¦cu0"Guvq"kornkectc"swg"ncu"kpvgthc/
egu"gngevt„pkecu"fgdgtcp"fctug"fg"cnvc"c"ghgevqu"fgn"KXC"gp"vqfqu"cswgnnqu"GGOO"
gp"nqu"swg"hceknkvgp"qrgtcekqpgu"kpvgtkqtgu"fgn"ctv0"3605∀∗040"
Rctc"gxkvctnq."gn"Eqpuglq"jc"korwnucfq"nc"rtqrwguvc"fg"nc"Eqokuk„p"fg"oqfkÞect"
nc"fgpqokpcek„p"{"gn"cnecpeg"fgn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"vtcp/
uceekqpgu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu0"Ug"rqftƒp"fgenctct"gp"fin"ncu"xgpvcu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"
c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu."ncu"rtguvcekqpgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"tgcnk¦cfcu"rqt"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"
guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"WG"rctc"eqpuwokfqtgu"pq"uwlgvqu" rcukxqu"guvcdngekfqu" gp"wp"
GO"fkhgtgpvg" {" ncu" gpvtgicu"fg" dkgpgu" hceknkvcfc" rqt"ncu" kpvgthcegu" gngevt„pkecu"
ewcpfq."fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"ctv0"3605∀∗04"FKXC."Ñgn"vtcpurqtvg"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"gpvtgic/
fqu"eqokgpeg"{"cecdg"gp"gn"okuoq"Guvcfq"okgodtqÒ0"Guvg"GO"ugtƒ."n„ikecogpvg."
gn"GO"fg"eqpuwoq0"Gn"GO"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"fgrgpfgtƒ"fg"uk"nc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec"
guvƒ"guvcdngekfc"q"pq"gp"nc"WG0"Uk"ug"gpewgpvtc"guvcdngekfc."ugiwktgoqu"ncu"tgincu"
eqogpvcfcuGO" fqpfg" ug" gpewgpvtg"nc"ugfg" fg" uw" cevkxkfcf"geqp„okec" q" wp"
guvcdngekokgpvq"rgtocpgpvg"gp"fghgevq"fg"nc"rtkogtc"{."uk"jwdkgtc"xctkqu"GRu."gp"
gn"GO"fg"uw"gngeek„p0"
Pq"qduvcpvg."rwgfg"qewttkt"swg"gn"kpvgtogfkctkq"gngevt„pkeq"swg"hceknkvg"nc"gpvtgic"
pq"ug"gpewgpvtg"guvcdngekfq"gp"nc"Wpk„p"32 3 0"Gp"vcn"ecuq."ug"rtqrqpg"tghqtoct"gn"ctv0"
58;"5∀∗"FKXC."guvcdngekgpfq"swg."rctc"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"WG."gn"
GO"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"ugtƒ"cswfin"fgufg"gn"swg"ug"gzrkfcp"q"vtcpurqtvgp"nqu"dkgpgu."
tginc"xƒnkfc"vcpvq"rctc"qrgtcekqpgu"kpvgtkqtgu"eqoq"rctc"xgpvcu"kpvtceqowpk vc tk cu "
D4E0"Gp"ecuq"fg"swg"gzkuvc"oƒu"fg"wp"GO"fgufg"gn"swg"ug"hceknkvg"nc"gpvtgic"fg"
dkgpgu."gn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"rqftƒ"kpfkect"gn"GO"swg"fgdgtƒ"eqpukfgtctug"fg"kfgpvkÞ/
ecek„p."xkpewncpfq"guvc"gngeek„p"fwtcpvg"fkejq"c‚q"{"nqu"fqu"ukiwkgpvgu0
70" QVTCU"EWGUVKQPGU"SWG"RNCPVGC"NC"UWLGEKðP"FG"NCU"
KPVGTHCEGU"GNGEVTðPKECU"["NC"XGPVCPKNNC"óPKEC"RCTC"
KORQTVCEKQPGU"D4E
Vqfcu"guvcu"oqfkÞecekqpgu"korwnucfcu"rqt"gn"Eqpuglq."swg"eqpetgvcp"nc"pqtocvkxc"
KXC"tgncvkxc"cn"rcrgn"fg"ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu."tguwnvcp"gugpekcngu"rctc"fqvctnc"
fgn"itcfq"fg"fgucttqnnq"pgeguctkq"rctc"swg"rwgfcp"qrgtct"eqttgevcogpvg0"Pq"qdu/
vcpvg."gzkuvgp"cniwpcu"ewguvkqpgu"swg"pqu"igpgtcp"kpegtvkfwodtg"cegtec"fgn"oqfq"
gp"swg"rwgfcp"ugt"tguwgnvcu"q"fg"ncu"eqpugewgpekcu"swg"rwgfcp"vgpgt"gp"vfitokpqu"
fg"htcwfg"KXC0"Ukiwkgpfq"pwguvtc"gzrqukek„p."xgoqu"swg"ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"
swg"rwgfgp"ugt"eqpukfgtcfcu"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"fg"cewgtfq"eqp"gn"ctv0"3605∀∗"pq"vkgpgp"
rqt"swfi"guvct"guvcdngekfcu"gp"vgttkvqtkq"fg"nc"WG0"Nc"kpvgtxgpek„p"fg"wpc"kpvgthc¦"pq"
guvcdngekfc"gp"xgpvcu"fg"dkgpgu"swg"{c"guvfip"gp"vgttkvqtkq"WG"rqt"rctvg"fg"rtqxgg/
323"Guvc"tginc"ugtc"pgeguctkc"cwpswg"pq"ug"cornkctc"gn"cnecpeg"fgn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"kpvtc/WG."{c"
swg"ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"rqftcp"tgcnk¦ct"xgpvcu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"c"fkuvcpekc"ukp"guvct"guvcdngek/
fcu"gp"nc"Wpk„p0"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
472
fqtgu"pq"guvcdngekfqu"*ctv0"3605∀∗04+"pq"uwrqpg"wp"itcp"ecodkq."rwgu"gn"rciq"fgn"
korwguvq"tgecgtƒ."gp"vqfq"ecuq."gp"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"Wpk„p0"
Ukp"godctiq."gp"gn"uwrwguvq"fg"uw"kpvgtogfkcek„p"gp"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"
korqtvcfqu"fg"ogpqu"fg"372"Û."ecdg"nc"rqukdknkfcf"fg"swg"gn"rtqxggfqt"fg"fkejqu"
dkgpgu"u"guvfi"nqecnk¦cfq"gp"vgttkvqtkq"KXC."rgtq"swg"nc"kpvgthc¦"rwgfc"pq"guvctnq0"Gp"
guvg"uwrwguvq"ug"guvctc"jcekgpfq"tgecgt"gn"ewornkokgpvq"fg"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"KXC"
gp"uwlgvqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu."rgug"c"swg"gn"uwokpkuvtcfqt"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"u"nq"guvfi"3 2 4 0"
Gn"jgejq"fg"swg"ug"jcicp"tgecgt"qdnkicekqpgu"vtkdwvctkcu."vcpvq"uwuvcpekcngu"eqoq"
hqtocngu."gp"kpvgthcegu"pq"guvcdngekfcu"rwgfg"uwrqpgt"wpc"fkÞewnvcf"c‚cfkfc"rctc"
ncu"Cfokpkuvtcekqpgu"Vtkdwvctkcu"fg"nqu"GGOO"c" nc"jqtc"fg"tgcnk¦ct"cevkxkfcfgu"fg"
eqpvtqn"vtkdwvctkq"uqdtg"ncu"fgenctcekqpgu"tgcnk¦cfcu."cu"eqoq"rctc"rtqegfgt"c"wpc"
tgecwfcek„p"eqcevkxc"fgn"rciq"3 2 5 0"Swk¦ƒu"rqftcp"jcdgtug"guvcdngekfq"wpqu"tgswkuk/
vqu"opkoqu"fg"uqnxgpekc"{"Þcdknkfcf"rctc"cswgnncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"swg"fg/
enctctcp"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"gp"swg"kpvgtogfkctcp"c"vtcxfiu"fg"nqu"tgiogpgu"fg"xgp/
vcpknnc"¿pkec."q"c‚cfkfq"wpc"qdnkicek„p"fg"pqodtct"wp"kpvgtogfkctkq"guvcdngekfq"
gp"nc"WG"vcodkfip"rctc"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"fgenctcfcu"gp"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"kpvtc/WG0"
Wpc"ugiwpfc"ewguvk„p"swg" pqu"rctgeg"tgngxcpvg"eqogpvct"gu"nc"eqornglkfcf"fg"uk/
vwcekqpgu"swg"rwgfgp"fctug"gp"uwrwguvqu"fg"fgxqnwek„p"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"ew{c"gpvtgic"
jc{c"hceknkvcfq"wpc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec."uqdtg"vqfq"gp"ecuqu"gp"swg"fkejc"rncvchqtoc"
pq"jc{c"fgucttqnncfq"nc"hwpek„p"fg"iguvk„p"fgn"rciq0"Uwrqpicoqu"gn"ukiwkgpvg"ecuq
wpc" ygd" swg" hwpekqpc" eqoq" ∆/#π∃&Ι./%∃"fqpfg"ug"qhgtvcp"vcpvq"dkgpgu"rtqrkqu"
eqoq"fg"qvtqu"rtqxggfqtgu="swg"gu"nc"gpecticfc"fg"guvcdngegt"nqu"vfitokpqu"{"eqpfk/
ekqpgu"fg"nc"gpvtgic"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"fg"nqu"vgtegtqu"swg"xgpfcp"c"vtcxfiu"uw{c."rgtq"swg"
pq"kpvgtxkgpg"gp"gn"eqdtq"cn"enkgpvg."ukgpfq"wpc"vgtegtc"gortguc"nc"swg"ug"gpectic"fg"
fkejc"hwpek„p0"Wp"eqpuwokfqt"Þpcn"tgcnk¦c"wpc"eqortc"fg"wp"dkgp"qhgtvcfq"rqt"wpc"
gortguc"vgtegtc"c"vtcxfiu"fgn"ekvcfq"=/#π∃&Ι./%∃."cegrvcpfq"nqu"vfitokpqu"{"eqpfkekq/
pgu"octecfqu"rqt"guvg."{"ukgpfq"tgfktkikfq"c"wpc"ygd"fg"wp"vgtegtq"gzenwukxcogpvg"
rctc"gn"rciq."swg"ng"eqdtc"gn"rtgekq"fgn"rtqfwevq"{"gn"KXC"eqttgurqpfkgpvg0"Eqp"kpfg/
rgpfgpekc"fgn"rqtegpvclg"fgn"rtgekq"swg"nc"kpvgthc¦"gzklc"eqoq"eqokuk„p"cn"rtqxggfqt."
swg"chgevctƒ"vcodkfip"cn"tgrctvq"fgn"korqtvg"eqdtcfq."nc"ewqvc"fgn"korwguvq"fgdgtƒ"
ugt"vtcpuhgtkfc"c"nc"kpvgthc¦."qdnkicfc"c"uw"fgenctcek„p"{"rciq."okgpvtcu"swg"cn"xgpfg/
fqt"fgdgtƒ"ucvkuhcegtug"nc"ewcpvc"swg"ng"eqttgurqpfc0
Uwrqpicoqu"swg"gn"dkgp"gpvtgicfq"pq"gu"cegrvcfq"rqt"fkejq"enkgpvg."swg"rtqegfg"
c"uw"fgxqnwek„p."uqnkekvcpfq"gn"tggodqnuq"fgn"korqtvg"ucvkuhgejq0"Nc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„/
324"Pq"jc{"swg"qnxkfct"swg"rctc"rqfgt"ceqigtug"c"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"fg"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"
dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu."wpc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec"pq"guvcdngekfc"uqnq"rqftc"wvknk¦ct"fkejq"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"
ogfkcpvg"nc"fgukipcek„p"fg"wp"kpvgtogfkctkq."ucnxq"swg"guvfi"guvcdngekfc"gp"wp"rcu"swg"jc{c"hktocfq"
gn"eqogpvcfq"Cewgtfq"fg"cukuvgpekc"owvwc"eqp"nc"WG0"Gp"gn"ecuq"fg"tgcnk¦ct"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"kpvg/
tkqtgu"g"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu"fgn"ctv0"3605∀∗04"{"swgtgt"ceqigtug"cn"tfiikogp"eqttgurqpfkgpvg"fg"xgpvcpknnc"
¿pkec"kpvtc/WG."nc"kpvgthc¦"pq"guvcdngekfc"vgpftƒ"swg"kfgpvkhkectug"gp"wp"GO."rgtq"pq"guvctƒ"qdnkicfc"c"
pqodtct"kpvgtogfkctkq"rctc"ewornkt"eqp"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"fgn"QUU"kpvtc/WG0"
325"Gp"guvg"ugpvkfq"ug"rtqpwpek„"NCOGPUEJ."O0."ÑVjg"tqng"qh"octmgvrncegu"kp"D4E"uwrrnkguÒ."gp"
gn"Eqpitguq":∋−#&+∋)+Θ−∗&∀%∃+∋)+&1∃+?−#∋Ι∃/3+73∀∋3β+Ο∃%∃3&+Β9,+:/∗∃+µ."gp"Xkgpc"gn"4;"fg"gpgtq"fg"
423;."fqpfg"fguvce„"nc"fkhkewnvcf"fg"tgcnk¦ct"eqpvtqngu"vtkdwvctkqu"ewcpfq"nc"rncvchqtoc"pq"guvfi"guvc/
dngekfc."kpenwuq"guvcpfq"kfgpvkhkecfc"c"ghgevqu"KXC0"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP473
pkec"fgdgtƒ"tgvqtpct"gn"korqtvg"fg"nc"ewqvc"KXC."gp"rtkpekrkq."cn"iguvqt"fgn"eqdtq"swg"
tgcnk¦ctc"nc"fgxqnwek„p."rctc"swg"guvc"rwgfc"ugt"fgxwgnvc"cn"eqpuwokfqt0"Ukp"godct/
iq."gn"hwpekqpcokgpvq"fg"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"jceg"swg"vcngu"oqfkÞecekqpgu"fgdcp"
ugt"fgenctcfcu"gp"ncu"ukiwkgpvgu"nkswkfcekqpgu"swg"ug"tgcnkegp0"Nc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec."
rgug"c"swg"uqnq"jc"hceknkvcfq"nc"gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu"fg"vgtegtqu."xc"c"vgpgt"swg"uqrqtvct"
nc"rfitfkfc"fg"nkswkfg¦"swg"uwrqpg"guvc"fgxqnwek„p"jcuvc"swg"rwgfc"eqorgpuctnc"
gp"hwvwtcu"fgenctcekqpgu0"Guvcu"rncvchqtocu."rqt"vcpvq."pq"xcp"c"cfswktkt"¿pkecogpvg"
qdnkicekqpgu"vtkdwvctkcu" {"uqrqtvct"wp"korqtvcpvg"kpetgogpvq" fg"ecticu"hqtocngu"{"
equvgu"kpfktgevqu."ukpq"swg"rwgfgp"gzrgtkogpvct"rgtlwkekqu"geqp„okequ."cn"ogpqu"gp"
vfitokpqu"fg"nkswkfg¦."rqt"uw"eqpukfgtcek„p"eqoq"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"3 2 6 0"
Rqt" ¿nvkoq." swgtgoqu" eqogpvct" wpc" ewguvk„p" swg." ukp" ugt" gzenwukxcogpvg"cvk/
pgpvg"c"nc" uwdlgvkxkfcf" rcukxc" fg" ncu" kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu."rwgu"ug" egpvtc" gp"
gn"hwpekqpcokgpvq" fg"ncu"xgpvcu" c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu" korqtvcfqu." rwgfg"xgtug"
gorgqtcfc"rqt"ncu"rqukdknkfcfgu"swg"rncpvgc"gn"ctv0"3605∀∗03"FKXC0"Pqu"tghgtkoqu."
fg"pwgxq."cn"hwpekqpcokgpvq"fgn"tfiikogp"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcp/
ekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"swg" rgtokvg"swg"fkejcu"gpvtgicu"swgfgp"gzgpvcu"fgn"
KXC"gp"gn"oqogpvq"fg"uw"korqtvcek„p0"Eqoq"eqogpvcoqu."gn"ctv0"69"3∋3∀∃∗"fgn"
Tgincogpvq";2614232"guvcdngeg"swg"nc"¿pkec"eqortqdcek„p"swg"fgdg"tgcnk¦ctug"
ewcpfq"nqu"dkgpgu"nngiwgp"c"nc"cfwcpc"gu"gn"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"fgn"tfiikogp"
gurgekcn." swg" jcdtƒ" fgdkfq" ugt" eqowpkecfq" Ñc" oƒu" vctfct" gp" gn" oqogpvq" fg"
nc"rtgugpvcek„p" fg"nc"fgenctcek„p"fg" korqtvcek„pÒ0"Crqtvcfq"fkejq"p¿ogtq." nqu"
GGOO"Ñpq"rqftƒp"korqpgt."c"ghgevqu"fgn"KXC."pkpiwpc"qvtc"qdnkicek„p"q"eqpvtqn"
gp"gn"oqogpvq"fg"nc"korqtvcek„pÒ"*ctv0"58;"8∀%∀∃∗"FKXC+0"
Guvc"hcnvc"fg"eqpvtqngu"cfkekqpcngu"rwgfg"uwrqpgt"swg"ug"tgrkvcp"cniwpqu"fg"nqu"
rtqdngocu"fg"htcwfg"swg"ug"fcp"cevwcnogpvg"eqp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"dkgpgu"fg"
guecuq"xcnqt0"Rgpugoqu"gp" wpc" xcnqtcek„p"q"fgenctcek„p"gtt„pgc"fg"rtqfwevqu."
cÞtocpfq"swg"gu"kphgtkqt"c"372Û."rctc"fgenctct"wpc"korqtvcek„p"gzgpvc"{"rquvg/
tkqt"nkswkfcek„p"gp"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"ucvkuhcekgpfq"wp"KXC"ow{"kphgtkqt"cn"swg"fg/
dgtc"fgxgpictug0"Rqt"glgornq."gn"uwrwguvq"fg"htcwfg"swg"rqpg"nc"Eqokuk„p"fg"nc"
fgenctcek„p"kpeqttgevc"fg"∗∆/#&Ι1∋3∃∗"korqtvcfqu"*8∀06+∗−Ι#/+"rctc"swg"gpvtgp"nk/
dtgu"fg"KXC"rqftc"eqpvkpwct0"Nc"kphtcxcnqtcek„p"{c"pq"vgpftc"eqoq"eqpugewgpekc"
nc"rfitfkfc"vqvcn" fg"nc"tgecwfcek„p."rwgu" nc"vtcpuceek„p"fgdgtc"fgenctctug"gn"KXC"
gp"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec0"Pq"qduvcpvg."gn"korqtvg"fgenctcfq"rqftc"ugt"ow{"kphgtkqt"
cn"tgcn0"Gp"vqfq"ecuq."ug"vtcvc"fg"eqpfwevcu"htcwfwngpvcu"gp"ncu"swg"wp"eqpvtqn"fg"
nc"xgtcekfcf"fg"nc"fgenctcek„p"{"nqu"rtqfwevqu"korqtvcfqu"rgtokvktc"uw"eqttgeek„p"
{"nc"korqukek„p"fg"ucpekqpgu"eqttgurqpfkgpvgu0
Pq"qduvcpvg."pqu"rncpvgcoqu"swg"gn"tfiikogp"oqfgncfq"rwgfc"rgtokvkt"qvtq"vkrq"
fg"eqpfwevcu" htcwfwngpvcu"oƒu"fkhekngu"fg" eqpvtqnct0"Uwrqpicoqu"swg"wp" rtq/
326"Guvcu"rfitfkfcu"fg" nkswkfg¦"rwgfgp" uwrqpgt"wp" rtqdngoc"rctc"cswgnncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„/
pkecu"fg"ogpqt"vcoc‚q"{"rqvgpekcn"geqp„okec0"Qvtcu."eqoq"rqt"glgornq"Coc¦qp."fktgevcogpvg"jcp"
etgcfq"wp"fgrctvcogpvq"fg"cuguqtcokgpvq"rctc"gn"ewornkokgpvq"fg"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"KXC"gp"nc"WG."swg"
rtqrqtekqpc"c"ncu"gortgucu"swg"xgpfgp"c"vtcxfiu"fg"uw"ygd"nqu"ugtxkekqu"lwtfkequ"rctc"ucvkuhcegt"vqfcu"
ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"vtkdwvctkcu."vcpvq"fg"ncu"xgpvcu"c"vtcxfiu"fg"nc"kpvgthc¦"eqoq"fg"ncu"rctvkewnctgu0"1&&Ι∗β∴∴
∗∃#8∀%∃∗6/∆/Σ∋36∃∗∴∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗∴∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗;)∀∗%/.∃∗;∃3;/∆/Σ∋361&∆.ι#∃)|?Εϖ1∃/0∃#ϖΒ9,9=Κ"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
474
xggfqt"pq"guvcdngekfq"gp"nc"WG"xc"c"tgcnk¦ct"wpc"xgpvc"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"ko/
rqtvcfqu0"Fkejq"rtqxggfqt"rwgfg"guvct"kfgpvkÞecfq"c"ghgevqu"fgn"tfiikogp"gurg/
ekcn"q"pq."rwgu"gn"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"swg"xc"c"rtqrqtekqpct"c"nc"cfwcpc"fg"
korqtvcek„p"gu"gn"fg"qvtq"uwlgvq"rcukxq"fgn"swg"eqpqeg"swg"u"guvƒ"fcfq"fg"cnvc"
gp"fkejc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"fg"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E0"Gn"tguwnvcfq"gu"swg."vtcu"tgcnk¦ctug"
nc"eqortqdcek„p"fg"nc"gzkuvgpekc"{"xcnkfg¦"fgn"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"c"ghgevqu"
fgn"QUU"rqt"rctvg"fg"nc"cfwcpc."nqu"dkgpgu"gpvtctcp"gzgpvqu"fg"KXC."ewqvc"swg"pq"
xgpftc"vcorqeq"fgenctcfc"rquvgtkqtogpvg"gp"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec0"Gxkfgpvgogpvg."
nc"encxg"fg"guvc"cevwcek„p"gu"nc"qdvgpek„p"fg"wp" p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"fg" nc"
xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"rqfgt"wvknk¦ctnq"fg"ocpgtc"htcwfwngpvc0
Gu"csw"fqpfg"gpvtctc"gp"lwgiq"nc"kpvtqfweek„p"fg"nc"uwdlgvkxkfcf"rcukxc"fg"ncu"
kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"fgn" ctv0"3605∀∗03" FKXC0"Ncu"rncvchqtocu"gngevt„pkecu"ugtƒp"
uwlgvqu"rcukxqu"fg"ncu"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"fg"ogpqu"fg"372"
Û"swg"hceknkvgp"{."pqtocnogpvg."guvctƒp"fcfcu" fg"cnvc"gp"gn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"fg"
xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rctc"guvcu"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E0"Ugtƒ"ow{"jcdkvwcn"swg"nqu"rtqxgg/
fqtgu"fg"rtqfwevqu"fg"vgtegtqu"vgttkvqtkqu"rwgfcp"tgcnk¦ct"xgpvcu"vcpvq"c"vtcxfiu"
fg"fkejcu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"eqoq"fg"hqtoc"fktgevc"c"vtcxfiu"fg"uwu"rtqrkcu"
rƒikpcu" ygd0" Tgurgevq" c" ncu" xgpvcu" c" vtcxfiu" fgn" ∆/#π∃&Ι./%∃."owejcu" fg" guvcu"
kpvgthcegu"rwgfgp" fglct" swg" gn" vtcpurqtvg" fgn" rtqfwevq"ugc" qticpk¦cfq" rqt" gn"
rtqxggfqt"q."cn"ogpqu."swg"guvg"gnklc"gn"vtcpurqtvkuvc"32 7 0
Ukp"godctiq."fgdkfq"c"swg"gn"uwlgvq"swg"tgcnk¦ctƒ"gn"vtcpurqtvg"c"ghgevqu"fgn"KXC"{."
rqt"vcpvq."nc"rgtuqpc"swg"ug"gpvgpfgtƒ"swg"tgcnk¦c"nc"xgpvc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"
gu"nc"kpvgthc¦."ugtƒ"uw"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"c"ghgevqu"fgn"tfiikogp"fg"xgpvcpknnc"
¿pkec"gn"swg"vgpftƒ"swg"eqowpkectug"c"nc"cfwcpc"fg"gpvtcfc"fg"nqu"rtqfwevqu0"Guvq"
rwgfg"rtqxqect"swg"nqu"rtqxggfqtgu"q."eqoq"opkoq."ncu"gortgucu"fg"vtcpurqtvg"
Ïswg"rwgfgp"jcdgt"ukfq" gngikfcu" rqt" fkejqu" xgpfgfqtguÏ" vgpicp" eqpqekokgpvq"
fgn"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"fgn"tfiikogp"gurgekcn"fg"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E0"Wp"rtq/
xggfqt"swg"swkukgtc"cjqttctug"gn"KXC"gp"uwu"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E" fktgevcu."swg"pq"
jwdkgugp"ukfq"hceknkvcfcu"rqt"wp"∆/#π∃&Ι./%∃."rqftc"guvct"vgpvcfq"fg"rtqrqtekqpct"
fkejq"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"fg"nc"kpvgthc¦"gp"uwu"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"
korqtvcfqu0"Nqu"rtqfwevqu"guvctcp"gzgpvqu" fg"KXC"gp"cfwcpc"{" pq"xgpftcp"fg/
enctcfqu"gp"nc"xgpvcpknnc" ¿pkec" pk" rqt" gnnqu" pk" rqt"nc"rncvchqtoc"gngevt„pkec"ew{q"
p¿ogtq"ug"hceknkv„."swg"pq"vgpftc"eqpqekokgpvq"fg"nc"korqtvcek„p"tgcnk¦cfc0"
Etggoqu"swg"ugtc"eqpxgpkgpvg"chtqpvct"guvcu"ewguvkqpgu"rctc"gxkvct"swg"rwgfcp"
igpgtcnk¦ctug"pwgxcu"hqtocu"fg"htcwfg"fgn"KXC"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"swg"rwgfc"uw/
rqpgt"wpc"korqtvcpvg"rfitfkfc"tgecwfcvqtkc0"Rqftcp"rgpuctug"ceekqpgu"vgpfgp/
vgu"c"cvcect"c"ncu"gortgucu"swg"tgcnk¦ctcp"guvcu"cevwcekqpgu."eqoq"rqt"glgornq"
jcegt"ecodkqu"rgtk„fkequ"fg"nqu"p¿ogtqu"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"c"ghgevqu"fgn"tfiikogp"
327"Rqfgoqu"rqpgt"gn"glgornq"fg"Cnkgzrtguu."wpq"fg"nqu"oc{qtgu"∆/#π∃&Ι./%∃∗"fgn"owpfq."gp"
ew{c"rwdnkekfcf"ug"cnwfg"gzrtgucogpvg"c"nc"rqukdknkfcf"fg"swg"nqu"xgpfgfqtgu"gpxgp"nqu"rgfkfqu"eqp"
uw"Ñrtqrkq"vtcpurqtvkuvcÒ0"1&&Ι∗β∴∴∗∃..6/.∀∃ΥΙ#∃∗∗6%∋∆∴∃∗∴ϖϖΙ%∴∀&,)νΛε"Vcodkfip"Coc¦qp."uk"dkgp"
qhgtvc"wp"ugtxkekq"fg"nqiuvkec"rtqrkq."rgtokvg"c"nqu"rtqxggfqtgu"c"nqu"swg"hceknkvc"uwu"xgpvcu"gpxkct"{"
iguvkqpct"gn"vtcpurqtvg"rqt"uw"ewgpvc0"1&&Ι∗β∴∴∗∃#8∀%∃∗6/∆/Σ∋36∃∗∴∗∃#8∀%∀∋∗∴8∃30∃#;Ι∋#;∀3&∃#3∃&∴8∃30∃;
0∋#∃∗;∀3&∃#3/%∀∋3/.∃∗61&∆."
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP475
gurgekcn."fg"vcn"ocpgtc"swg"cswgnnqu"gpxqu"swg"ukiwkgtcp"wvknk¦cpfq"nqu"kfgpvkÞ/
ecfqtgu"cpvkiwqu"swgfctcp"rctcnk¦cfqu"gp"cfwcpc"c"gzrgpucu"fg"nc"eqpÞtocek„p"
fgn"vkvwnct"fgn"p¿ogtq"ecfwecfq0"Ukp"godctiq."gpvgpfgoqu"swg"pq"ugtc"uwÞekgp/
vg"eqp" ogfkfcu" tgcevkxcu"fg"guvg" vkrq." ukpq"swg"fgdgtcp"guvcdngegtug"ogfkfcu"
rtgxkcu"swg"korkfkgtcp"guvc"rqukdknkfcf0
Rqt"glgornq."rqftc"rncpvgctug"c"ncu"cwvqtkfcfgu"cfwcpgtcu"nc"rqukdknkfcf"fg"swg"c"
ncu"xgpvcu"c"fkuvcpekc"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"ug"ngu"cukipctc."eqoq"qewttg"gp"ncu"ko/
rqtvcekqpgu"swg"ug"ceqlcp"cn"tfiikogp"ukornkÞecfq"cnvgtpcvkxq"c"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec."wp"
p¿ogtq"¿pkeq"fg"vtcpuceek„p"q"fg"gzrgfkek„p."{"swg"guvg"hwgtc"kpenwkfq"gp"nqu"fcvqu"c"
tgikuvtct0"Fg"guvg"oqfq."rctc"swg"nc"korqtvcek„p"fgn"dkgp"guvwxkgtc"gzgpvc"nc"cfwcpc"
fg"gpvtcfc"fgdgtc"eqortqdct"vcpvq"gn"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"fg"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pk/
ec"eqoq"fkejq"p¿ogtq"fg"rgfkfq"q"vtcpuceek„p"gurgeÞeq0"Fkejqu"p¿ogtqu"rqftcp"
ugt"eqttgncvkxqu."fg"ocpgtc"swg"uk"wp"gpxq"vwxkgtc"wp"p¿ogtq"fg"vtcpuceek„p"swg"
{c"jwdkgtc"ukfq"fgenctcfq"gp"wpc"cfwcpc."gn"ukiwkgpvg"gpxq"eqp"gn"okuoq"e„fkiq"
tgswktkgtc"wpc"eqortqdcek„p"rqt"rctvg"fgn"korqtvcfqt0"Cn"rtqxggfqt"swg"rtgvgpfkgtc"
fghtcwfct"pq"ng"dcuvctc"eqp"gn"eqpqekokgpvq"fgn"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkÞecek„p"c"ghgevqu"
fgn"QUU"fg"qvtq"uwlgvq"q"fg"nc"kpvgthc¦"gngevt„pkec."ukpq"swg"fgdgtc"crqtvct"vcodkfip"
fkejq"e„fkiq" kpfkxkfwcnk¦cfq" fgn" gpxq" gp" ewguvk„p"32 8 0" Uqoqu"eqpuekgpvgu"fg"swg"
guvq"rwgfg"kpetgogpvct"gp"itcp"ogfkfc"nc"ectic"cfokpkuvtcvkxc"fg"wpcu"cfwcpcu."
swg"{c"eqp"nc"iguvk„p"fgn"pwgxq"oqfgnq"fg"tgecwfcek„p"fgn"KXC"{"nc"gnkokpcek„p"fg"
ncu"gzgpekqpgu"fg"guecuq"xcnqt."xcp"c"xgt"kpetgogpvcfq"uw"vtcdclq0"
Pq"qduvcpvg."eqpukfgtcoqu" swg"fgdgtc"kpvgpvct"cvclctug"ncu"rqukdngu"nciwpcu"q"
hcnncu"swg"rtgugpvg"gn"oqfgnq"cpvgu"fg"uw"korngogpvcek„p" ghgevkxc0" Jc" ukfq"tg/
ewttgpvg"nc"cnwuk„p"c"wpc"korngogpvcek„p"fg"ukuvgocu"vgepqn„ikequ"swg"rgtokvcp"
tgcnk¦ct"oƒu"{"oglqtgu"eqpvtqngu"uqdtg"guvg"vkrq"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu0"Rqt"glgornq."gn"
Vtkdwpcn"fg"Ewgpvcu"Gwtqrgq"jc"ocpkhguvcfq" uwu"fwfcu"cegtec" fg"nc"ecrcekfcf"
fgn"pwgxq"tfiikogp"fg"korqtvcekqpgu"D4E"rctc"gnkokpct"gn"htcwfg"dcucfq"gp"nc"kp/
htcxcnqtcek„p"fg"nqu"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu."cu"eqoq"nc"kpecrcekfcf"fg"eqpvtqnct"nqu"
ugtxkekqu"rqt"xc"gngevt„pkec"gzvtc/WG0"Rctc"gxkvct"guvqu"uwrwguvqu."jc"kpukuvkfq"gp"
swg"fgdgtc"guvwfkctug"gn"wuq"fg"ukuvgocu"fg"tgecwfcek„p"rqt"ewgpvc"fgn"enkgpvg"
q"fg"vgtegtqu."gp"wpc"enctc"cnwuk„p"cn"Β9,+ΕΙ.∀&"gp"gn"swg"ncu"gpvkfcfgu"gpecticfcu"
fgn"eqdtq"ugrctctcp"gn"korqtvg"fgn"rtgekq"fg"nc"ewqvc"KXC"32 9 ."cdqpcpfq"guvc"fk/
tgevcogpvg"c"nc"Cfokpkuvtcek„p"Vtkdwvctkc"32 : 0
328"Vcodkfip"rqftc"gzkiktug"guvg"p¿ogtq"uqnq"c"cswgnnqu"rtqxggfqtgu"q"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"
eqp"oc{qt"xqnwogp"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu." fcfq"swg"uw"p¿ogtq"fg"kfgpvkhkecek„p"ugtƒ"uwuegrvkdng"fg"ugt"
eqpqekfq"eqp"hceknkfcf"rqt"wpc"ecpvkfcf"fg"uwokpkuvtcfqtgu"uwrgtkqt0"
329"Wp"cpƒnkuku"uqdtg"ncu"kpkekcvkxcu"fg"Β9,+∗ Ι.∀ &+ gp"nc" Wpk„p"Gwtqrgc."eqpetgvcogpvg"gp"Kvcnkc."
Rqnqpkc."Twocpc" {" Tgkpq"Wpkfq." cu" eqoq" uwu"ghgevqu." gp" RTʻV¥NGT."T0" E0." ÑUrnkv" Rc{ogpvu"kp" XCV"
U{uvgo"/"Ku"vjku"vjg"hwvwtgÒ.">3&∃#3/&∀∋3/.+Β9,+=∋3∀&∋#ϑ+Xqn0"4;."p³"4."4 23 :. "r r0 "8 8/ 92 0" Gn "c wvqt"eqpenw{g "
swg"guvg"ukuvgoc"pq"rtgugpvc"gurgekcngu"xgpvclcu"gp"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"D4E"tgurgevq"c"nc"kpxgtuk„p"fgn"
uwlgvq"rcukxq."rgtq"swg"u"rqftc"ugt"wp"ogecpkuoq"¿vkn"rctc"rtgxgpkt"gn"htcwfg"KXC"gp"ncu"vtcpuceekq/
pgu"eqp"eqpuwokfqtgu"hkpcngu0"Pq"qduvcpvg."eqpukfgtc"swg"uw"korngogpvcek„p"pq"ugtc"ugpeknnc."rwgu"
jcdtc"swg"fgucttqnnct"ewguvkqpgu"eqoq"nc"hqtoc"fg"eqowpkect"c"ncu"gpvkfcfgu"fg"rciq"nqu"rqtegpvc/
lgu"fg"fgfwekdknkfcf"fg"nqu"cfswktgpvgu0"
32:"Vtkdwpcn"Gwtqrgq"fg"Ewgpvcu."Kphqtog"Gurgekcn"p³"341423;."∋Ι6+%∀&0."rr0"6:/6;"{"750"
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
476
Wpc"rqukdng"uqnwek„p"rctc"tgcnk¦ct"wp"eqpvtqn"oƒu"gzjcwuvkxq"fg"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"
pq"fgenctcfcu"{"cevwct"eqpvtc"ncu"eqpfwevcu"htcwfwngpvcu"ugtc"nc"korngogpvcek„p"
fg"nc"tgekgpvg"rtqrwguvc"fg"nc"Eqokuk„p"Gwtqrgc"gp"uw"EQO*423:+":34"Þpcn"3 2 ; 0"Nc"
Eqokuk„p"rtqrqpg"swg"vqfqu"nqu"rtqxggfqtgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"fg"rciq."gpvgpfkfipfqug"
rqt"guvqu"ncu"gpvkfcfgu"fg"etfifkvq."fg"fkpgtq"gngevt„pkeq."fg"iktq"rquvcn"{"qvtcu"gpvk/
fcfgu"fg"rciq"*ctv0"3"Fktgevkxc"4237145881WG."fg"45"fg"fkekgodtg"fg"4237+"fgdgtƒp"
ocpvgpgt"wp"tgikuvtq"fgvcnncfq"fg"nqu"dgpgÞekctkqu"{"ncu"qrgtcekqpgu"fg"rciq"swg"
rgtokvc"c"nqu"GGOO"eqpvtqnct"ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"{"rtguvcekqpgu"vtcpuhtqpvgtk¦cu"
swg"ug"jc{cp"tgcnk¦cfq0"Guvc"rtqrwguvc"guvctc"fktkikfc"gzenwukxcogpvg"c"vtcpuceekq/
pgu"gortguctkcngu."rctc"nq"swg"guvcdngegtcp"wp"nokvg"opkoq"fg"47"qrgtcekqpgu"
fg"rciq"fguvkpcfcu"cn"okuoq"dgpgÞekctkq"gp"gn"vtkoguvtg"pcvwtcn0"
Cfgoƒu."ug"vtcvc" fg"wpc"ogfkfc"swg"ug"crnkectc"gzenwukxcogpvg"c"rciqu"vtcpu/
htqpvgtk¦qu."rwgu"uqnq"ug" tgikuvtctƒp"nqu"rciqu"swg"rtqxgpicp"fg"wp"qtfgpcpvg"
tgukfgpvg"gp"wp"GO"c"wp"dgpgÞekctkq"guvcdngekfq"gp"qvtq"GO"q"gp"wp"vgtegt"rcu"q"
vgttkvqtkqu0"Nc"wdkecek„p"ug"eqortqdctƒ"c"vtcxfiu"fgn"e„fkiq"KDCP0"Guvc"rtqrwguvc"
swgfc"nglqu"fg"qvtcu"oƒu"codkekqucu"eqoq"gn"ekvcfq"Β9,+∗Ι.∀&."rgtq"ukp"fwfc"uw/
rqpftc"wp"kpetgogpvq"fg"ncu"jgttcokgpvcu"eqp"ncu"swg"eqpvctcp"ncu"Cfokpkuvtc/
ekqpgu"vtkdwvctkcu"pq"uqnq"rctc"eqpqegt"cswgnncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"pq"fgenctcfcu."ukpq"
vcodkfip"rctc"ucect"c"tgnwekt"ncu"swg"jc{cp"ukfq"kphtcxcnqtcfcu"gp"cfwcpc0
80" EQPENWUKQPGU
Ncu"tghqtocu" swg" jgoqu" eqogpvcfq" uwrqpgp" wpc" cwvfipvkec"tgxqnwek„p"gp" ncu"
xgpvcu"fg" dkgpgu" korqtvcfqu0" Wpc"ogfkfc" etwekcn" jc" ukfq"nc"gnkokpcek„p" fg" nc"
gzgpek„p"fgn" KXC"c"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu" fg" guecuq" xcnqt0"Guvc" gzgpek„p" eqpuvkvw{g"
wpc"fg" ncu"oc{qtgu"kphtceekqpgu" fg"pgwvtcnkfcf"Þuecn"swg" rtgugpvc"gn"korwguvq"
{"uwrqpg."cn"okuoq"vkgorq."wpc"fguxgpvclc"eqorgvkvkxc"rctc"ncu"gortgucu"gwtq/
rgcu"{"wpc"hwgpvg"fg"htcwfg"{"cdwuqu"swg"guvƒ"fkuvqtukqpcpfq"gn"ogte cf q"k pvgtkqt0"
Fgufg"wpc"rgturgevkxc"tcekqpcn"uw"gnkokpcek„p"gu"oƒu"swg"wp"cekgtvq."gu"wpc"pg/
egukfcf0"Dclcpfq"c"wp"pkxgn"rtcioƒvkeq."gn"kpetgogpvq"fg"vtcpuceekqpgu"swg"fg/
dgtƒp"rtqeguct"ncu"cfwcpcu"eqowpkvctkcu"rqt"nc"gnkokpcek„p"fg"guvc"gzgpek„p"uqnq"
tguwnvc"rqukdng"rqt"nc"etgcek„p"fg"pwgxqu"jgejqu"korqpkdngu"{"nc"igpgtcnk¦cek„p"
fgn"ukuvgoc"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec0
Gn"pwgxq"ukuvgoc"eqpÞiwtcfq"rctc"vtcpuceekqpgu"eqp"eqpuwokfqtgu"ug"uwuvgpvc"
gp"nc"uwuvkvwek„p"fg"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"eqoq"jgejq"korqpkdng."gp"gn"swg"gn"eqpvtk/
dw{gpvg"gu"gn"eqortcfqt."rqt"nc"fg"wpc"gpvtgic"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu."gp"nc"swg"
gn"uwlgvq"rcukxq"tguwnvctƒ"gn"xgpfgfqt0"Gn"korwnuq"fg"nqu"tgiogpgu"gurgekcngu"fg"
xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rqt"rctvg"fg"nc"Wpk„p"Gwtqrgc"gu"gxkfgpvg."rwgu"ug"gtkigp"eqoq"
nc"encxg"fg"d„xgfc"fgn"ukuvgoc."{c"swg"uw"wvknk¦cek„p"rgtokvktƒ"nc"gzgpek„p"fg"ncu"
korqtvcekqpgu"{"swg"ncu"xgpvcu"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"ugcp"ncu"¿pkecu"vtcpuceekq/
32;"EQO*423:+":34"hkpcn."fg"34"fg"fkekgodtg"fg"423:."Rtqrwguvc"fg"Fktgevkxc"fgn"Eqpuglq"rqt"nc"
swg"ug"oqfkhkec"nc"Fktgevkxc"422813341EG"gp"nq"swg"tgurgevc"c"nc"kpvtqfweek„p"fg"fgvgtokpcfqu"tgswk/
ukvqu"rctc"nqu"rtqxggfqtgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"fg"rciq0
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP477
pgu"swg"fgdcp"nkswkfct"gn"korwguvq0"Gn"pwgxq"oqfgnq"rctgeg"eqpugiwkt"nc"oc{qt"
rctvg"fg"nqu"qdlgvkxqu"swg"nq"kpurktcp0"Rqt"wp"ncfq."ug"ukornkÞecp"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"
vtkdwvctkcu"swg"fgdgtƒp"ewornkt"nqu"eqpuwokfqtgu"Þpcngu"cn"guvcdngegt"nc"gzgpek„p"
fg"ncu"korqtvcekqpgu"fg"ncu"swg"ugtcp"uwlgvqu"rcukxqu0"Cn"okuoq"vkgorq."ug"nkdgtc"
fg"vtcdclq"c"ncu"cfwcpcu"rctc"nqu"dkgpgu"swg"pq"guvfip"uwlgvqu"c"ctcpegngu"cfwc/
pgtqu."cn"rqfgt"fgenctctug"gn"korwguvq"gp"nc"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"rquvgtkqtogpvg."{"pq"
gp"nc"kpvtqfweek„p"fg"dkgpgu"gp"gn"vgttkvqtkq"KXC0"Rqt"qvtq."ug"rtgvgpfg"tgfwekt"nqu"
ecuqu"gp"swg"nc"tgecwfcek„p"fgrgpfg"gzenwukxcogpvg"fg"uwlgvqu"pq"guvcdngekfqu0"
Rctc"gnnq"ug"ngu"qdnkic"c"pqodtct"wp"kpvgtogfkctkq"rctc"rqfgt"ceqigtug"cn"QUU"fg"
xgpvcu"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"{."uqdtg"vqfq."ug"fc"c"ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"wp"
rcrgn"hwpfcogpvcn"gp"nc"tgecwfcek„p"fgn"KXC0
Nc"pwgxc"hwpek„p"swg"xcp"c"ewornkt"ncu"kpvgthcegu"gngevt„pkecu"eqoq"uwlgvqu"rc/
ukxqu"ewcpfq"hceknkvgp"xgpvcu"D4E"fg"dkgpgu"korqtvcfqu"{"gpvtgicu"fg"uwlgvqu"pq"
guvcdngekfqu"gu."ukp"fwfc."wpq" fg"nqu" rtkpekrcngu"cxcpegu"swg"kpeqtrqtc"guvc"tg/
iwncek„p0"C"gzrgpucu"fg"nc"pgeguctkc"crtqdcek„p"fgn"fgucttqnnq"pqtocvkxq"eqogp/
vcfq."guvc"pqxgfcf"rwgfg"tgfwekt"gp"itcp"ogfkfc"gn"p¿ogtq"fg"fgenctcpvgu"pq"
guvcdngekfqu"gp"nc"Wpk„p"{"eqpvtkdwkt"c"okpqtct"ncu"rfitfkfcu"tgecwfcvqtkcu"gp"ncu"
korqtvcekqpgu"D4E0"Gn"kpetgogpvq"fg"equvgu"cfokpkuvtcvkxqu"rctc"vcngu"kpvgthcegu"
tguwnvc"gxkfgpvg."uqdtg"vqfq"rctc"cswgnncu"fg"ogpqt"vcoc‚q."rwguvq"swg"cniwpcu"
fg"oc{qt"fkogpuk„p"{c"jceg"vkgorq"swg"rtqrqtekqpcp"ugtxkekqu"fg"ewornkokgp/
vq"fg"ncu"qdnkicekqpgu"KXC0"
Pq"qduvcpvg."nc"tghqtoc"{"ncu"rtqrwguvcu"eqogpvcfcu"fglcp"cniwpqu"kpvgttqicpvgu"
ukp"tgurqpfgt."{"pq"chtqpvcp"nc"vqvcnkfcf"fg"nqu"rtqdngocu"swg"chgevcp"c"ncu"korqt/
vcekqpgu0"Fgvgtokpcfcu"eqpfwevcu"eqoq"nc"rqukdknkfcf"fgn"wuq"fg"wp"p¿ogtq"fg"
kfgpvkÞecek„p"fgn"tfiikogp"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"fg"qvtq"qrgtcfqt."q"nc"rqukdknkfcf"fg"
kphtcxcnqtct"nqu"rtqfwevqu"fgenctcfqu" rctc"rcict"wp"KXC"ow{"kphgtkqt"fkheknogpvg"
rqftƒp"ugt"gnkokpcfqu"gzenwukxcogpvg"eqp"ncu"ogfkfcu"korngogpvcfcu0"Gp"gn"hwvwtq"
fgdgtgoqu" ugiwkt" guvwfkcpfq" nc" rqukdknkfcf" fg" eqorngogpvct" ncu" fkurqukekqpgu"
cfqrvcfcu"eqp"ukuvgocu"cfkekqpcngu."eqoq"gn"eqpvtqn"fg"nqu"rciqu"swg"rtqrqpg"
nc"Eqokuk„p" q." kpenwuq." rtqrwguvcu" oƒu"codkekqucu0"Okgpvtcu"vcpvq."gu" korqtvcp/
vg"korngogpvct"eqpvtqngu"swg"nkokvgp"ncu"eqpfwevcu"fg"htcwfg"swg"gn"ukuvgoc"c¿p"
pq"eqpukiwg"cvclct"fg"ocpgtc"eqorngvc0"Cn"okuoq"vkgorq."nc"eqpuqnkfcek„p"fg"nc"
xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec"eqoq"ogecpkuoq"egpvtcn"fg"ncu"vtcpuceekqpgu"eqp"eqpuwokfqtgu"
tgswgtktƒ"swg"ncu"Cfokpkuvtcekqpgu"vtkdwvctkcu"ng"rtguvgp"owejc"oƒu"cvgpek„p"swg"
jcuvc"cjqtc."{"swg"nc"eqncdqtcek„p"gpvtg"cwvqtkfcfgu"fg"nqu"fkuvkpvqu"GGOO"ug"tgc/
nkeg"fg"ocpgtc"ghgevkxc0"Vqfq"gp"ctcu"fg"ugiwkt"rgthgeekqpcpfq"gn"hwpekqpcokgpvq"
fgn"KXC"{"fg"qrvkok¦ct"gn"eqogtekq"kpvgtpcekqpcn"gp"nc"Wpk„p"Gwtqrgc0
DKDNKQITCHìC
DCN."C0."ÑVjg" ejcpikpi"ncpfuecrg"qh"vjg"GW"XCV"XCV"Rcemcig"cpf"FgÞpkvkxg"XCV"
U{uvgoÒ."?−#∋Ι∃/3+,/Υ/&∀∋3ϑ"Xqn0"7;."p³"4∴5."423;0
Eqrgpjcigp"Geqpqokeu"*Cwvqtgu"Dcucnkueq."D0."Ycjn."L0."Qmjqno."J0+0."?;%∋∆∆∃#%∃+>∆Ι∋#&∗+
∀3&∋+?−#∋Ι∃β+Β9,+/30+:−∗&∋∆∗+,#∃/&∆∃3&."Eqrgpjciwg."42380
+;<934=;
Gn"hwvwtq"fgn"KXC"gp"ncu"korqtvcekqpgutqdngocu."uqnwekqpgu"g"kpegtvkfwodtgu""
*Lqufi"Ocpwgn"Ocecttq"Quwpc+
Pwgxc"Hkuecnkfcf"̋"OqpqitƒÞeq"̋"!∀#∃%&∋(%()∀∗+,−∗%∃∋.∗%&)/)0.12∗∋+%−∋%"̋"KUUP
478
Eqrgpjcigp"Geqpqokeu." ÑG鰭gevu" qh" tgoqxkpi" vjg" XCV"fg" Okpkoku" qp"G/Eqoogteg"Ko/
rqtvuÒ."Eqrgpjciwg."42390
Fgnqkvvg."ÑCpcn{uku"qh"equvu."dgpgÞvu." qrrqtvwpkvkgu"cpf"tkumu"kp"tgurgev"qh"vjg"qrvkqpu"hqt"
vjg" oqfgtpkucvkqp" qh" vjg" XCV" curgevu" qh" etquu/dqtfgt"g/EqoogtegÒ. " 4³" Gu vwfk q"
rctc"nc"Eqokuk„p"uqdtg"Qrvkqpu"hqt"oqfgtpkukpi"XCV"hqt"etquu/dqtfgt"G/Eqoogteg"
Hkpcn"Tgrqtv."42370
Fgnqkvvg."ÑCuuguuogpv"qh"vjg"korngogpvcvkqp" qh"vjg" 4237" rnceg" qh" uwrrn{" twngu" cpf" vjg"
Okpk/Qpg"Uvqr"UjqrÒ."5³"Guvwfkq"rctc"nc" Eqokuk„p"uqdtg"Qrvkqpu" hqt"oqfgtpkukpi"
XCV"hqt"etquu/dqtfgt"G/Eqoogteg"Hkpcn"Tgrqtv."42370
G["Uvwf{"hqt"vjg"Eqookuukqp."9∗∗∃∗∗∆∃3&+∋)+&1∃+/ΙΙ.∀%/&∀∋3+/30+∀∆Ι/%&+∋)+&1∃+Β9,+∃Υ∃∆Ι;
&∀∋3+)∋#+∀∆Ι∋#&/&∀∋3∗+∋)+∗∆/..+%∋3∗∀Χ3∆∃3&∗6"2∀3/.+Ο∃Ι∋#&."oc{q"fg"4237
IðOG¥"CTCIðP."F0."ÑPwgxq"vtcvcokgpvq"gp"gn"KXC"fg"ncu"gpvtgicu"fg"dkgpgu"{"rtguvcekq/
pgu"fg"ugtxkekqu"c"fkuvcpekc"rctc"fguvkpcvctkqu"eqpuwokfqtgu"ÞpcnguÒ.":/#&/+,#∀5−&/;
#∀/6+Ο∃8∀∗&/+0∃+ΛΙ∀3∀Η3ϑ"p³"57."423:0
IðOG¥" CTCIðP."F0."ÑKorwguvq" uqdtg" gn" Xcnqt"C‚cfkfq Cevkxkfcf" fg" eqogtekq" cn" rqt"
ogpqt"fg"dkgpgu"fg"guecuq"xcnqt"swg"uqp"qdlgvq"fg"korqtvcek„p"c"vtcxfiu"fg"gpxqu"
rquvcngu."fgucttqnncfc"rqt"wp"eqogtekcpvg"rgtuqpc"hukecÒ.":/#&/+,#∀5−&/#∀/6"Ο∃8∀∗&/+
0∃+ΛΙ∀3∀Η3ϑ"p³"5;."423:0
NCOGPUEJ."O0."ÑFguvkpcvkqp"dcugf"vczcvkqp"qh"eqtrqtcvg"rtqÞvu"/rtgnkokpct{"Þpfkpiu"tgictf/
kpi"vcz"eqnngevkqp"kp"etquu/dqtfgt"ukvwcvkqpuÒ."ΛΥ)∋#0+θ∋#π∀3Χ+(/Ι∃#+Ε∃#∀∃∗ϑ"Lwnkq"42390
NCOGPUEJ."O0."ÑVjg"tqng"qh"octmgvrncegu"kp"D4E"uwrrnkguÒ."gp"gn"Eqpitguq":∋−#&+∋)+Θ−∗&∀%∃+
∋)+&1∃+?−#∋Ι∃/3+73∀∋3β+Ο∃%∃3&+Β9,+:/∗∃+µ."Xkgpc."4;"fg"gpgtq"fg"423;0
OCECTTQ" QUWPC." L0" O0."?.+ (#∀3%∀Ι∀ ∋+0∃ + Κ∃−/.∀0/0+2∀∗%/.+ ∃3+ ∃.+ >Β9." Vjqouqp" Tgw/
vgtu/Ctcp¦cfk."Ek¦wt"Ogpqt."42370
OCECTTQ" QUWPC."L0"O0."ÑGn" pwgxq"tfiikogp" fg"xgpvcu"kpvtceqowpkvctkcu" c"fkuvcpekc" fg"
dkgpgu"{"nc"igpgtcnk¦cek„p"fgn"tghqtocfq"ukuvgoc"fg"xgpvcpknnc"¿pkec
fgÞpkvkxq"rctc" ncu" qrgtcekqpgu"kpvtc/WG"eqp"eqpuwokfqtguAÒ."Ο∃8∀∗&/+?∗Ι/φ∋./+ 0∃+
!∃#∃%1∋+2∀3/3%∀∃#∋."p³"3:3."423;0
OGTMZ."O0."ÑXCV"cpf"g/ugtxkegu>3&∃#3/&∀∋3/.+Β9,+
=∋3∀&∋#ϑ"Xqn0"4;."p³"3."423:0
RTʻV¥NGT."T0"E0."ÑUrnkv"Rc{ogpvu"kp"XCV"U{uvgo"Ï"Ku"vjku"vjg"hwvwtgÒ.">3&∃#3/&∀∋3/.+Β9,+=∋;
3∀&∋#ϑ"Xqn0"4;."p³"4."423:0
Para continuar leyendo
Solicita tu prueba